The Hilltop is one of our favorite places to relax and have dinner with friends. Great service and great food!!
William and Judith
An outstanding place for an early dinner. Service was over the top. Food was beautiful and delicious. I like that there are often new menu items.
Opentable Diner
We wanted a good lunch and a place to chat for awhile. We both thought the sandwich choices were excellent It was busy but not too noisy. No one rushed us to order or finish up. A lovely Saturday lunch.
Graham
Had a reservation for 7. The restaurant was chaotic and loud. Lots of families and kids running around. The bathrooms were filthy. By 7:30 we still hadn't been seated. So we left. I will never bother with this place again.
Lori
Service was excellent! Food was delicious. Pretty loud. Parking is not great especially when people have mobility issues
Jeri
My friend and I were there to celebrate our birthdays and the note I had added to our online reservation was there when we checked in. The waitress was attentive and quick to bring take home boxes and our carrot cake to wrap up our lunch together. We both hope you'll keep the Newberry on the menu forever. It wasn't our first time ordering it, and it won't be the last!
Thomas
Outstanding food and service! The new hazelnut crusted Walleye is incredible! My partner and I love this place!!
Richard
This iconic restaurant has become one of my favorites with outstanding service, good food and moderate prices. Wifey and I had Date Night Wednesday where we were seated on the scenic patio (4 Seasons Style) and wifey started with a glass of red wine then moved onto the chicken fajitas that she claimed were the best ever with an interesting marinade on the grilled chicken and enjoyed it so much she would not share with me. I enjoyed the robust pot roast with a huge chunk of tender beef bathed (literally in a bowl) in a rich beef onion broth and excellent mashed potatoes, onions and carrots. We then split a carrot cake dessert that was moist, soft, flavorful and covered with fresh whipped cream. The Server, April, was excellent in making suggestions and helping us decide on the carrot cake. We will certainly come again and hope they can expand their parking when the construction next door is completed.
Diana
Great experience. Service and food were excellent! Very busy time, so noise level was high!
Tasha Lyles
10/2/25 I went around 3pm service was wonderful. They cared about my allergies. They asked how things were. I really enjoyed service here. I was sitting on the patio it was beautiful clean very relaxing vibe. My friend also enjoyed her food. Thank you for a wonderful experience.
The food here is top-notch. A group of us gather monthly. We typically sit on the porch & have the same waitress, Renee who is outstanding! There is MAJOR construction going on all around, making it a challenge to get there. Not as simple as point A to point B anymore. We sat on the porch & it was quite difficult to carry on a conversation due to the noise level from all the construction. We asked to sit on the porch as it is a bit more private for a larger group. It was very hot out there & fans either weren't turned on or weren't effective. Several in our group mentioned trying a different place until construction is complete.
Minh Tran
The desserts were a dream.
Xuan Phuc
Service felt polished and professional.
Merrill
Good and dependable food. Problem with a salad and they promptly replaced and comped it. Service was A+!
Laurie
Two of us already knew our orders before arriving: chicken ciabatta sandwich and tuna melt—ongoing favorites. We tried a cinnamon roll for the first time. Delicious. Our server, a longtime employee, was great—as usual. It's nice to see continuity in staff! Our only issue was not Hilltop's fault: access to the restaurant due to the ever-changing road work at 50th. We all got there but had to be creative this weekend.
The Hilltop is one of our favorite places to relax and have dinner with friends. Great service and great food!!
An outstanding place for an early dinner. Service was over the top. Food was beautiful and delicious. I like that there are often new menu items.
We wanted a good lunch and a place to chat for awhile. We both thought the sandwich choices were excellent It was busy but not too noisy. No one rushed us to order or finish up. A lovely Saturday lunch.
Had a reservation for 7. The restaurant was chaotic and loud. Lots of families and kids running around. The bathrooms were filthy. By 7:30 we still hadn't been seated. So we left. I will never bother with this place again.
Service was excellent! Food was delicious. Pretty loud. Parking is not great especially when people have mobility issues
My friend and I were there to celebrate our birthdays and the note I had added to our online reservation was there when we checked in. The waitress was attentive and quick to bring take home boxes and our carrot cake to wrap up our lunch together. We both hope you'll keep the Newberry on the menu forever. It wasn't our first time ordering it, and it won't be the last!
Outstanding food and service! The new hazelnut crusted Walleye is incredible! My partner and I love this place!!
This iconic restaurant has become one of my favorites with outstanding service, good food and moderate prices. Wifey and I had Date Night Wednesday where we were seated on the scenic patio (4 Seasons Style) and wifey started with a glass of red wine then moved onto the chicken fajitas that she claimed were the best ever with an interesting marinade on the grilled chicken and enjoyed it so much she would not share with me. I enjoyed the robust pot roast with a huge chunk of tender beef bathed (literally in a bowl) in a rich beef onion broth and excellent mashed potatoes, onions and carrots. We then split a carrot cake dessert that was moist, soft, flavorful and covered with fresh whipped cream. The Server, April, was excellent in making suggestions and helping us decide on the carrot cake. We will certainly come again and hope they can expand their parking when the construction next door is completed.
Great experience. Service and food were excellent! Very busy time, so noise level was high!
10/2/25
I went around 3pm service was wonderful. They cared about my allergies. They asked how things were. I really enjoyed service here. I was sitting on the patio it was beautiful clean very relaxing vibe. My friend also enjoyed her food. Thank you for a wonderful experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
The food here is top-notch. A group of us gather monthly. We typically sit on the porch & have the same waitress, Renee who is outstanding!
There is MAJOR construction going on all around, making it a challenge to get there. Not as simple as point A to point B anymore.
We sat on the porch & it was quite difficult to carry on a conversation due to the noise level from all the construction.
We asked to sit on the porch as it is a bit more private for a larger group. It was very hot out there & fans either weren't turned on or weren't effective.
Several in our group mentioned trying a different place until construction is complete.
The desserts were a dream.
Service felt polished and professional.
Good and dependable food. Problem with a salad and they promptly replaced and comped it. Service was A+!
Two of us already knew our orders before arriving: chicken ciabatta sandwich and tuna melt—ongoing favorites. We tried a cinnamon roll for the first time. Delicious. Our server, a longtime employee, was great—as usual. It's nice to see continuity in staff! Our only issue was not Hilltop's fault: access to the restaurant due to the ever-changing road work at 50th. We all got there but had to be creative this weekend.
Loading...