Papa Johns Pizza

I ordered the grand papa pizza without pepperoni and added extra sauce. I also ordered an extra side of sauce incase they forget the extra sauce on the pizza. Not only did they not put extra sauce on the pizza, they put no sauce, it was dry as a bone and they also didnt include the side of sauce I paid for. THIS IS SUCH A FAIL. It's impossible to mess up this bad, it feels deliberate. Whoever made this pizza and whoever let it leave the store should take a pay cut.

I like that this Papa Johns has lots of succulents inside as decoration

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Ordered two pizzas. The one my girlfriend ordered was missing 3 of the 5 toppings she paid extra for (yes we double checked the order and the stick on the box said everything that she ordered) . I called, got put on hold for 20 minutes before we gave up, but they didn't actually use the hold feature on the phone, so I got to hear all of their conversations, I especially enjoyed the yelling about sticking fingers into a certain hole, that was awesome to hear from the people that handled your food.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Serive ok food ok

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Oven down. Drove there for nothing. No call to let me know

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

This Papa John's is a hit or miss.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Not a lot of flavor to the pizza.
🍕
Wings were under done

The pizza is usually okay. No qualms about the product. It’s more so that every single time I walk into this location, they are EXTREMELY rude. Not a little bit rude. Not frustrated because they are swamped. They are obviously being purposefully rude. And the kinder you are to them, the more rude they become. Like magic! Still gonna order food because I like to watch mean people suffer.
Granted: I’m queer. The woman usually working nights, whom seems to be in charge, has made backhanded compliments. I also get looked at like I’m not allowed inside for some reason. I’m not a liberal whatsoever, but Trumps America? Lmao

Pretty good good and fast delivery

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best papa John’s on this side of the city. Friendly, kind, efficient staff, great pizza and food everytime. Wish I could afford to tip more. Great place and my go to place for a good deal on a solid pie.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Generous with the toppings always fresh

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I don’t usually write reviews, but Papa John’s at University Ave absolutely deserves one. Every time I order, the pizza arrives hot, fresh, and exactly how I asked for it. The crust is always perfect—crispy outside, soft inside—and the toppings actually taste like real ingredients (looking at you, cardboard pizza chains). Delivery is fast, staff are polite, and they’ve never once messed up an order. Bonus points for the garlic sauce. Seriously. That stuff could solve wars.

Highly recommend if you want consistent quality without the wait. Papa’s got it right.

Either someone from this place or someone in MN is stealing my information & ordering papa from this store. They can't do nothing to help like give me the address the pizza is being delivered or stop the delivery because they just want their money.. 😭 nasty pizza anyways.

This location was super quick and the pizza tasted great. Not the location's fault, but the price is a little intense for me. We also got large pizzas, and they were about the same size as a medium from other places we have been.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We are from our of town, our local papa johns are far better with customer service. Driver calls and says he fell so i had to walk out in the cold to retrieve our pizza that he dropped while falling out the reatruant. We have 3 hungry kids and the managaer only offered new pizzas which wont help us. Do better offer partial refund, spending $80 for this mess is unacceptable

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1