Red Wagon Pizza Company

5416 Penn Ave S, Minneapolis
(612) 259-7147

Recent Reviews

Benjamin Roberts

Been here a few times- I love the pizzas. It kinda feels like a premium pizza; high grade ingredients and elevated combinations. I've had a few different flavors but the red wagon is a go to.We planned to dine in but it was so busy we ordered takeout and sat at the bar and they were very accommodating.My wife found a new job alcoholic craft drink and the bartender informed us that it was local and gave us the low down on where it is available (now I get to have cool points and surprise my wife)!My wife is and daughter (should be more) gluten free and dairy free and they have THE BEST pizza in this category as well. They really don't disappoint.We also ordered the jerk dry wings which had zero spice but tons of flavor and were cooked perfectly (use the lime, it's your friend on these wings). We also had the homemade chips which were bomb but you don't get enough of the sriracha aoili with them.You do pay a little more for this pizza and for the price, atmosphere, quality and service, it's best to dine in and have the full experience.But, I'll say the reheat is solid but undercook it and gradually get it right while reheating as the thinner slices could be less forgiving in a microwave or toaster oven but it's still a good pizza then too.It seems hard to believe that someone would be disappointed unless they just don't like that wood/coal fire/thin crust kind of pizza.Been back a few times and will be back more times.Parking is not a stress-free experience, so plan to walk to be safe.Dietary restrictions: Can easily accommodate gluten free and dairy free pizza and still have the same premium pizza experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatballs, Build Your Own Pizza, Margherita, Bar Chips, Pepperoni Pizza, Nash Pizza, Red Wagon Pizza, Wings, Bahn MI Pizza, Half and Half Pizza

Nathan O

Bring back the Nash pizza (very good) and lower the beer prices a dollar or 3 lol.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jinho Park

Had Red Wagon pizza and Chicken wings (dried), quality and completion level is good, but expensive.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Megan Orchard

The establishment doesn't provide good value in terms of portion and quality.

Geoff Tilsen

Excellent atmosphere, wait staff and food! As Arnold would say, "I'll be back".

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alonzo Williams

The customer service was great but the pizza taste like card board. I will not order anything else from here.

Food: 1

Service: 5

Nick H

Jerk dry rub wings for the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandra Weise

What a gorgeous, clean, yummy pizza place. The owners are warm, friendly and funny! I highly recommend!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Buzzkillington S

Just had the Red Wagon Pizza, it was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Wagon Pizza

Eric Pitt

Mid pizza.

Food: 3

Tom Kelling

Ordered three pizzas including Popeye, Double Pep and cheese. The sauce is very good and my family agreed. The toppings are also good but ours were a bit sparse. The crust is good but doesn’t stand out which is ok. The drink/beer selection is heavy on the IPA’s but overall we all found something to satisfy. Would I go back? Not sure it was worth that bill at the end. I knew the prices going in but still….but plenty of people must not mind as the place is hopping. Make reservations!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Popeye

Kellen Stokes

Great pizza restaurant! If I lived in the neighborhood, I would visit often. Many pizza options to meet the needs of anyone. I appreciate how they allow half and half pizza; it allows you to try more flavors!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark K.

Since moving to MN 3 years ago I've wanted to try to place exclusively because of the banh mi pizza, as I moved from a city that had a delicious banh mi pizza and I wanted to compare. We ordered the banh mi, the McLovin' It, the Popeye, and the pepperoni. All in all, the pizzas were delicious. The banh mi tasted just like a banh mi sandwich, the McLovin' It tasted exactly like a Big Mac, the Popeye was delicious with great cheese and sausage, and the pepperoni was sort of our safety pizza which was still delicious (and favored by my daughter). Truth be told, I probably won't come back because of the price. I ordered for pickup, so maybe the experience would be different if we sat down and experienced "the vibe", but for take out pizza it's pretty expensive. Those four pizzas were over $100, and while delicious, it's certainly not something that's comfortably affordable enough to be a regular spot. But, that's on me. The food was delicious and still delicious even when reheated the next day!

jeffrey a.

By far the worst pizza I've ever had in my life.I didn't think it was possible to make a bad pizza.I was proven wrong

Kat Baumtrog

Great spot for date night, or a family outing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Pep, Olive Oyl Pizza, Red Wagon Pizza

Load More