Papa Johns Pizza

1117 Cedar St Ste 135, Monticello
(763) 271-1131

Recent Reviews

Sort by
MaRgArEt “MaGGiE” CaRlSoN

4 different times I ordered later in the evening and after 40 min of processing and cooking and then submitted to the driver to bring the order to me my order is canceled this also happened on the 10th the doordash driver accepted the order but couldn't even pick up the order because the store was closed...they are delaying orders in their system when it becomes 101-11pm they make the customer believe they're getting their order and then last second it's canceled and you never get it...and this time the poor doprdash driver wasted his time too...you're all pathetic if you can't handle doing your job dont work their

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gary Bautch

The food was good. The problem is once DoorDash takes it, it is nobody’s responsibility if something is wrong. I didn’t receive my whole order and when I brought it up to the DoorDash driver he couldn’t speak English. He needed his phone to translate. He said there wasn’t anything he could do and left. I called the store and they said “once it was handed off to DoorDash it wasn’t there responsibility.” I called DoorDash and he just called the store and transferred me to them where I heard the same thing. I had to go to the store to pick up what I was missing and still had to pay the delivery fee and tip.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Gerry K

We ordered a dozen pizzas for a working lunch. Pizzas we delivered hot and on time. We had a crazy assortment with varying toppings. Everyone was pleased with the quantity of toppings, a great crust and all the flavor!

John and Rebeca Scarbrough

All was good, great pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

David Canzano

Take out our delivery only.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jill S.

We had a quality issue with a recent purchase, but Tyler went above and beyond to make it right. From the moment we reached out, he was professional, empathetic, and proactive. He not only resolved the issue quickly but also followed up to ensure we were completely satisfied. It’s rare to experience this level of genuine care and commitment to customer satisfaction. Tyler turned a frustrating situation into a positive one, and we're truly grateful. Exceptional service like his deserves to be recognized—thank you, Tyler!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Benjamin Ritter

Just started recently where half the pizza is crust, called and got money back last time, but ordered again and it’s apparently just how it is now

Tim Rozko

We ordered a pizza for delivery from Papa John’s. We live just five minutes from the store, but after placing the order, we waited over an hour with no sign of our food. We kept checking the status, and the estimated delivery time kept getting pushed back with no explanation.

Eventually, we called the store and were told our order had been handed off to DoorDash. The employee said no one had claimed the order yet and couldn’t give us a real estimate of when it would arrive.

At that point, we were frustrated and decided to just go pick it up ourselves. When we got there, a car full of teenagers pulled up. One of them hopped out, came into the store, and said he was the DoorDash driver coming to grab our order. Honestly, it felt a bit unprofessional.

It was also pretty clear our food had been sitting there for a while—everything was barely warm.

To top it off, since Papa John’s had passed the order to DoorDash, they claimed it was “out of their control” and made us pay the DoorDash driver in the store—even though we never received a delivery.

The whole experience was a mess: no communication, no accountability, and no real customer service. Honestly, I could’ve grabbed a frozen pizza and had it baked, eaten, and cleaned up in less time than this whole ordeal took.

Really disappointed.

Jack Murphy

Turn the simple process of ordering a pizza into an outsourced AI nightmare. 15 minutes to place an order? Seriously?

Zahro Husainovova

Very friendly staff, working clean, Very professional

Abbie Johnson

We ordered a big order at 10pm on a Saturday night and it was delivered fast, well made, and flawlessly! Our delivery driver, Sean, was communicative and professional! Thanks, Papa John’s!

Wendy Kasprowicz

After what I saw, as they were making a customer's order, I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone! BARE HANDS in ALL the ingredients, NO tools were used for the toppings. Just their BARE hands in and out of EVERYTHING! 🤢🤢🤢🤢

Atmosphere: 3

Tom Burgard

Pretty expensive for what it is

Kristina Thorsten

The guy manager is AWESOME!!!!!! He always goes the extra mile! Our favorite pizza place in town!! They always are making sure they get it right. Love this place!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesy Bread, Brownie

Dianne And Joe Heckman

Parking: Parking was good

Loading...