Carbone's Pizzeria

2723 Commerce Dr NW, Rochester
(507) 516-8200

Recent Reviews

Jennifer Long

Love their pizza!

Barry Hughes

Excellent staff, food and atmosphere. Outstanding pizza and sides.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sauce, Garlic Parmesan Pizza Mozzarella

Shikhar D

I ordered a pizza for $25 on Saturday night at around 11 PM. The place was open but there were no staff inside. Waited about an hour for my food but despite accepting the order, there were no staff to make it. I almost always try to order from local pizza places instead of large chains, but I was so disappointed at the experience I got. Completely ruined my Saturday night! I suggest to not order from here if you’re looking for a late night pizza.(I also messaged the store later regarding this incident but they ignored my message.)

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Teera Xo

Horrible staff did a DoorDash order and couldn’t find any staff walked to the bar and there wasn’t any staff to help me there either so I walked

Service: 1

Austin Nicklay

Great place to take a large group of people. Prices are fantastic and food is great.Kid-friendliness: Tons of arcade and claw games to keep the kids busy. Right near the tables.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom MacCartney

Two words - "Buck up" $1 for your 2nd drink.....

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Oftedahl

Lunch buffet was terrible. Hardly any food on it and it was not at all busy. Had to wait 20 minutes for pizza on a buffet. Was handed the bill before I was able to get a second slice of pizza. Missing serving utensils on half of the items and the staff just seemed content to move at a snails pace. Have had takeout from this location and it was fine. But dine in just isn't on par with other Carbone's locations.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: To Go, Taco

Morgan Stamschror

Pizza was delicious and beer was cold! Service on the other hand, was not great. Bartender was on her phone a lot and didn’t notice us sit down until ~5 minutes. We had to get her attention in order for her to serve us. We will return for the food and cold beer. Service could improve. Bartender tossed a pen and the check at us without saying “thanks for coming in” or anything like that. Cheeseburger pizza was delicious, and the ranch was good too!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Al Watts

Really great lunch buffet. Reasonably priced.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy D.

Server was very nice. I had the French dip, told them I wanted cheese on it, they asked what kind. Came with no cheese. Husband had cheeseburger wrap. Not impressed with either sandwich whatsoever. We went to this place because google said this address was " the Green Mill" restaurant. It may have been at one time idk. The establishment appears dirty, & somewhat run down. They definitely could clean better & update. No reason to go back again.

Michelle Nestler

First time here and the two of us agree that we would come back. Great game day location with chili and drink specials. Actively involved patrons to cheer on the home team and have fun watching the football game.One ordered the Philly cheesesteak, it was really good. The accompanying tots were fantastic - great seasoning - please never change this! The other ordered a pound of bone-in wings with buffalo ranch seasoning. These were really good, the order came with 8 wings and a little bit of celery. We had the option for blue cheese or ranch and chose blue cheese which paired well. BOGO drink specials were good! We just tasted the chili so we would know for next time - we can understand why there wasn’t a lot left at the time, good flavor with topping options, biscuits and crackers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barb H.

Stopped in while in town visiting the Mayo Clinic. Decided to give it a shot despite the bad reviews. Service: Came on a sunday evening, during football season, and our service was actually great. Ambiance: Ehhhh...it's okay. Definitely wouldn't be a place i'd be hanging out it. Seemed very bright. Had an arcade/family area on one side and the bar on the other. They're separated pretty good, but it's just odd. Food: The food wasn't the best. I can't comment on the pizza because we didn't have that. However, seeing other people's, it didn't look bad. We just had hoagies and potato skins.Potato skins were pretty good. However, I was expecting more from the hoagie based on the description on the menu. It was just a hoagie roll with some melted butter, and the bread didn't seem the freshest. It wasn't bad, just wasn't great. Definitely edible. Also had a side of fruit that was probably cut up days ago. I know, i know. Who orders fruit at a pizzeria/sports bar? Won't be doing that again.

Truman Tucker

PHENOMENAL pizza! Then we sat for half an hour while our server rolled silverware with a friend/coworker without ever checking on her tables. I've heard the same from others- amazing food, below average service.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Tim Hamel

I went there for lunch and their $10.99 buffet. It included a salad bar and 3-5 different types of pizza. They have plates available at the buffet if you want to go more than once. Overall, I thought it was good. I didn't try the salad bar this time but plan to in the future. Over time, I see they rotate different items instead of the breadsticks and lasagna they have had meatloaf and mashed potatoes and tacos. Today they had meatballs, stuffing and potatoes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Danielle Schmitt

Absolutely the worst experience we've ever had anywhere. First time experience ended up having to wait Over 2 hours for 2 pizzas, boneless wings and a salad. The salad didn't have any dressing and after asking twice, it never came. We had to beg for beers and boxes to go. We sat in the booth by the patio and it was absolutely disgusting. They haven't dusted in at least 2 months by the amount of dirt on top of the booths..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Load More