I ordered Destined pizza with shrimp on the menu but got changed to chicken without any notice. Staff from the restaurant told us they just decided to change to chicken. If ingredients changed, don’t you need to update your menu and website?
Chris Svarstad, J.D. (NorthShoreGuy07)
Dan is the best server/bartender imaginable. Great service.
Amber Cunningham
A really good wood fired pizza place.
Mark Eckman
The crust is wonderful. Super thin & baked in the wood fired oven. But they are understaffed.
Forrest Fearington
I've been to just about every pizza place in Rochester, and Tilda's is hands down the best pizza in town. On par with wood-fired pizza I've had in LA, Portland, and other metro areas. Reasonable prices as well.
Michelle Dougherty
Love the Idaho Sun!!! 🥔🍕🩵
Cory Jenson
Maybe the pizza I've ever eaten. Seriously Great service as well. Definitely going back.
jim lane
Thoroughly enjoyed our time and meal. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Meaty
Jamie Alban
My family agrees that this would be a weekly staple if Tilda’s was close to our house in Maryland. Even my 3-year-old (who has an incredibly picky palate) ate a whole cheese pizza by himself.
We visited Tilda’s twice during our week visit to Rochester. You can tell that everything is made from scratch - the Caesar salad is TOP notch. The staff have been absolutely marvelous and the kitty robot is an added bonus. If there’s ever a reason to be in Rochester again, I will absolutely be coming back to Tilda’s.
Last night our salad was definitely old, the lettuce was rusty. What really upset us was that we were charged extra for additional salad dressing and a tablespoon of extra pizza sauce. The waitress was rude, said they are under new owners! Very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Bill Miller
Great meal and excellent friendlly service. Wood fired pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynn McMahon
Good pizza, generous salads, good, friendly service. Drink refills usually arrive without asking. Always get a Mr. Meaty and split a half salad, so haven't explored most of the menu.
Parking: Plenty of parking in lot on Sunday when the restaurant in the basement is closed. Haven't been there on other nights. Street parking is free after 5 and on weekends.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Mr Meaty
P H
The Destin Pizza easily was the most disgusting Pizza ever!!! Despite the dough being fine it was covered in raw(!!!) garlic. I ate half a slice before I had to puke.
Food: 1
Evelina Popov
First time ever I tried pizza with goat cheese and blackberries. Cooking on the wood made it especially delicious.
Great food, good price.
I ordered Destined pizza with shrimp on the menu but got changed to chicken without any notice. Staff from the restaurant told us they just decided to change to chicken. If ingredients changed, don’t you need to update your menu and website?
Dan is the best server/bartender imaginable. Great service.
A really good wood fired pizza place.
The crust is wonderful. Super thin & baked in the wood fired oven. But they are understaffed.
I've been to just about every pizza place in Rochester, and Tilda's is hands down the best pizza in town. On par with wood-fired pizza I've had in LA, Portland, and other metro areas. Reasonable prices as well.
Love the Idaho Sun!!! 🥔🍕🩵
Maybe the pizza I've ever eaten. Seriously Great service as well. Definitely going back.
Thoroughly enjoyed our time and meal. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Meaty
My family agrees that this would be a weekly staple if Tilda’s was close to our house in Maryland. Even my 3-year-old (who has an incredibly picky palate) ate a whole cheese pizza by himself.
We visited Tilda’s twice during our week visit to Rochester. You can tell that everything is made from scratch - the Caesar salad is TOP notch. The staff have been absolutely marvelous and the kitty robot is an added bonus. If there’s ever a reason to be in Rochester again, I will absolutely be coming back to Tilda’s.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Last night our salad was definitely old, the lettuce was rusty. What really upset us was that we were charged extra for additional salad dressing and a tablespoon of extra pizza sauce. The waitress was rude, said they are under new owners! Very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Great meal and excellent friendlly service. Wood fired pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza, generous salads, good, friendly service. Drink refills usually arrive without asking. Always get a Mr. Meaty and split a half salad, so haven't explored most of the menu.
Parking: Plenty of parking in lot on Sunday when the restaurant in the basement is closed. Haven't been there on other nights. Street parking is free after 5 and on weekends.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Mr Meaty
The Destin Pizza easily was the most disgusting Pizza ever!!!
Despite the dough being fine it was covered in raw(!!!) garlic. I ate half a slice before I had to puke.
Food: 1
First time ever I tried pizza with goat cheese and blackberries. Cooking on the wood made it especially delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...