Gary's Pizza

$$ • Pizza, Salad, Italian

17 College Ave N, St Joseph
(320) 363-7261


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Gary's Pizza

Online ordering sucks! Ordered a half and half pizza... the jalapeños that were to be on HALF, were on the WHOLE pizza. The order specifically said: Left: sausage and Right: pepperoni & jalapeño when I checked out. The ticket on the pizza when we got it was: Large, traditional Sausage, Pepperoni, Jalapeño. Will not be ordering from Gary's again.

I celebrated my graduation today in this great place. happy to tell that we passed a tremendous evening and the venue was definitely the reason for this outstanding event. The team contributed in a graceful way, the cooking was delicious and my guests were very cheerful. We shall no dout visit again for more celebrations. thanks very much.

Food was really good, service was quick to the door. I mixed up my cash payment and the gentleman with the awesome beard knocked back on the door a few minutes later and told me I gave him too much money ($100 worth) now that is a stand up guy! We will order again.

More Reviews(44)


Monday 3:30 - 11PM
Tuesday 3:30 - 11PM
Wednesday 3:30 - 11PM
Thursday 3:30 - 11PM
Friday 3:30PM - 2:30AM
Saturday 11AM - 2:30AM
Sunday 11AM - 11PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.