The mini cone was the perfect size for a 3 year old. The Mango Mania smoothie was refreshing and delicious.
Will Bryan
Fun little neighborhood place with tons of character. Promptly greeted, generous serving, and nice place to sit and eat it.
Margaret Edwards
Great neighborhood fun! Lots of different community events and very good cheese curds
Kat Drude
A great spot in a great neighborhood. I love taking a walk and stopping for a smoothie here; everyone is always friendly and the location is very accessible. If you live in West Side consider taking your kids here for a treat instead of a chain!
Andrea Weber
So delicious! Great service! Such a special and wonderful neighborhood gem. The churro sundae will blow your mind. Customers need to chill, tho! Moms always be getting mad that like their burgers and fries aren't instantaneous, or that people's soft serve is ready before their hot foods come out. Cmon bro, that's not how food works.
Benjin Vogel
Love this place, we highly recommend it to all of our friends and family that visit!
Ericka s.
Always wonderful here. Quick and efficient service and adorable patio to relax and eat your delicious food and ice cream
been’there
A tiny restaurant with many flavors. Literally 5 menus to choose from. Coffee, ice cream, treats, drinks, smoothies and limited food. It’s like a Dairy Queen but better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Issa Baker
We live on the other side of town but love this place so much we make the trek over! We really love the affogato!! Highly recommended
Icy Cup is always great. We live in Highland and wish we had a place like this in our ‘hood. Check out the farmers market on their lot. So many good, local offerings.
And the owners are fantastic! They truly care about the local community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Reviewer
We all had ice cream cones and they were good. The ice-cream seemed really creamy and nice. Would recommend coming and checking this place out.
Susan Price
Indy ice cream parlor with modest food menu and delicious milkshakes and malts. Our favorite is the Chai milkshake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
P C
Love this neighborhood gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beef Tacos, Waffle Cone with Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, Raspberry Sundae, Blue Raspberry, Affogato, Churro Sundae, Cream Sandwich, Soft Serve Ice Cream, Hot Dog
Andrea Troiano
Icy Cup is a great local hole in the wall. We ordered the churro cups and they were amazing. Could not finish as it was so big. The atmosphere is eclectic and more akin to a greasy spoon.
The mini cone was the perfect size for a 3 year old. The Mango Mania smoothie was refreshing and delicious.
Fun little neighborhood place with tons of character. Promptly greeted, generous serving, and nice place to sit and eat it.
Great neighborhood fun! Lots of different community events and very good cheese curds
A great spot in a great neighborhood. I love taking a walk and stopping for a smoothie here; everyone is always friendly and the location is very accessible. If you live in West Side consider taking your kids here for a treat instead of a chain!
So delicious! Great service! Such a special and wonderful neighborhood gem. The churro sundae will blow your mind. Customers need to chill, tho! Moms always be getting mad that like their burgers and fries aren't instantaneous, or that people's soft serve is ready before their hot foods come out. Cmon bro, that's not how food works.
Love this place, we highly recommend it to all of our friends and family that visit!
Always wonderful here. Quick and efficient service and adorable patio to relax and eat your delicious food and ice cream
A tiny restaurant with many flavors. Literally 5 menus to choose from. Coffee, ice cream, treats, drinks, smoothies and limited food. It’s like a Dairy Queen but better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We live on the other side of town but love this place so much we make the trek over! We really love the affogato!! Highly recommended
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Affogato, Soft Serve Ice Cream
Nice place. Retro vibes. Tasty coffee & ice cream
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Icy Cup is always great. We live in Highland and wish we had a place like this in our ‘hood. Check out the farmers market on their lot. So many good, local offerings.
And the owners are fantastic! They truly care about the local community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We all had ice cream cones and they were good. The ice-cream seemed really creamy and nice. Would recommend coming and checking this place out.
Indy ice cream parlor with modest food menu and delicious milkshakes and malts. Our favorite is the Chai milkshake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this neighborhood gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Beef Tacos, Waffle Cone with Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, Raspberry Sundae, Blue Raspberry, Affogato, Churro Sundae, Cream Sandwich, Soft Serve Ice Cream, Hot Dog
Icy Cup is a great local hole in the wall. We ordered the churro cups and they were amazing. Could not finish as it was so big. The atmosphere is eclectic and more akin to a greasy spoon.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Churro Sundae
Loading...