After several return trips to Pino's, I need to modify my review. Our first experience was great. However, after several more visits, I have not found the consistent quality. Pizzas are often overcooked and one time the crust was partially burned. There is usually a couple high school kids inside making the pizzas accounting for the inconsistent quality. I have lost interest in returning.
Rachel M
This pizza was wonderful. I stuck with a simple cheese pizza, and really enjoyed it. My toddler went crazy for the crust. The crust was crispy and flavorful. The sauce was very good, zesty, and tasted homemade. The staff was very kind as well. Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Penny Berg
We never even ordered because this place appeared so filthy. The first red flag should have been the collection of empty drink bottles, cans, and food wrappers piled up in the corner right outside the entrance. Walked in and couldn’t help but notice the floor looked like it hadn’t been swept in weeks. Tables were not cleaned off. Women’s restroom had a sign taped to the door that read “out of order“. It left a really bad first impression and we left.
McEnvoy Moue
Great group of guys working. Constantly putting together pizzas that keep me coming back! Love pinos, something to tell the grandkids about
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Patty Sullivan
Not happy! Called for delivery and was given a 50 minute wait. That turned into 1 hour and 45 minutes. Called twice to see what was happening and was told it would arrive any minute--wrong! When it finally arrived it was lukewarm and had the wrong toppings! We live five minutes away!!!!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Aaron K.
If I could give a half star to make it 4.5 I would. Great NY 🍕 Pizza! The Gravy/ Sauce needs some work. The crust...It's almost perfect! Light crisp! Toppings...Cheese was great but for veggies/fruit they use canned not fresh. If that could change it would Help. The Pizza next Day Cold....is almost as good when it's Hot! Will come back again! Oh...Did I say the Slices are nice and Huge! Especially with the 16-inch 🍕!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Julian Ocampo
We got 9 pizzas for our daughter’s 4th birthday and everyone loved it and we had no pizza leftover. 10 out of 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Coury
Nice little shop with some great pizza!
Ryan Franus
This place has been a staple in my life ever since I was a kid. From ERHS lunches off campus, to now a quick bite to eat with my wife, Pinos has been here for me. Phenomenal food, and the owner is always a hoot. Highly recommend anyone give your business to this community staple.
Carlin Murphy
Dirty floor, dirty tables, and garbage was overflowed. The crust was very soft, you could roll it up like a burrito and not that good compared to other pizza joints. Had to throw the pizza back in the oven at home just to get the crust to where it was cooked completely.
Local pizza is the best pizza. Pino is the man, top tier pizza and calzones.
Dellessio Properties
Best pizza in the area by a mile. Next time you’re on break and you forgot your lunch, go here and get the 2 slices and pop. Ready in like 2 minutes, best price in Woodbury and you’re not just paying for the giant slices, but also for a one of a kind experience😂. Attracts regular people who don’t want the manufactured design fake service chain corporate feel that seems to be everything coming up in our town now a days. The owner is an absolute legend, when he retires they should really make a statue, he’s everything to that place. I never write reviews, but you would not regret checking it out!
Joseph Paffel
Owner is awesome, he brings his New York “get outta here” energy with him every day to woodbury. Pizza is great, but personally I enjoy the atmosphere, maybe not for everyone but, the place is authentic as it gets!
Michael Kelly
This place has a lot of hate based on the 'atmosphere', but the truth is we need to focus on the pizza! It's fantastic! First bite reminded me of some of my past favorite pizza joints from across the country. I grew up in a military family and have been all over the place, I really really liked the flavor of this pie! The sauce was perfectly savory, rich, and well-balanced.
I came in on a Monday night for a couple of slices, no one was here around 6:30, there were a couple of guys behind the counter. Very straight forward, came in, paid around $10.75 for two slices and a soda. One guy heated it up and placed them into a styrofoam box. Took them home and gobbled them up, 10/10 recommend the pepperoni pizza by the slice at Pino's! Pleased to have found this local gem in my very own neighborhood of Woodbury!
Ashley Rodriguez
Just picked up our pizza, it was given to the wrong customer. He came back in and told the employees It was wrong, we noticed it was ours but didn't want to wait another 45 minutes. It was burnt and cold. We took it anyways but while waiting, we saw one of the employees in the back rolling the dough with his shirt off. Absolutely disgusting. Edit: Called to talk to a manager due to disrespect at the store on top of that and we were put on hold and then hung up on.
After several return trips to Pino's, I need to modify my review. Our first experience was great. However, after several more visits, I have not found the consistent quality. Pizzas are often overcooked and one time the crust was partially burned. There is usually a couple high school kids inside making the pizzas accounting for the inconsistent quality. I have lost interest in returning.
This pizza was wonderful. I stuck with a simple cheese pizza, and really enjoyed it. My toddler went crazy for the crust. The crust was crispy and flavorful. The sauce was very good, zesty, and tasted homemade. The staff was very kind as well. Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
We never even ordered because this place appeared so filthy. The first red flag should have been the collection of empty drink bottles, cans, and food wrappers piled up in the corner right outside the entrance. Walked in and couldn’t help but notice the floor looked like it hadn’t been swept in weeks. Tables were not cleaned off. Women’s restroom had a sign taped to the door that read “out of order“. It left a really bad first impression and we left.
Great group of guys working. Constantly putting together pizzas that keep me coming back! Love pinos, something to tell the grandkids about
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Not happy! Called for delivery and was given a 50 minute wait. That turned into 1 hour and 45 minutes. Called twice to see what was happening and was told it would arrive any minute--wrong! When it finally arrived it was lukewarm and had the wrong toppings! We live five minutes away!!!!
Food: 1
Service: 1
If I could give a half star to make it 4.5 I would. Great NY 🍕 Pizza! The Gravy/ Sauce needs some work. The crust...It's almost perfect! Light crisp! Toppings...Cheese was great but for veggies/fruit they use canned not fresh. If that could change it would Help. The Pizza next Day Cold....is almost as good when it's Hot! Will come back again! Oh...Did I say the Slices are nice and Huge! Especially with the 16-inch 🍕!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
We got 9 pizzas for our daughter’s 4th birthday and everyone loved it and we had no pizza leftover. 10 out of 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice little shop with some great pizza!
This place has been a staple in my life ever since I was a kid. From ERHS lunches off campus, to now a quick bite to eat with my wife, Pinos has been here for me. Phenomenal food, and the owner is always a hoot. Highly recommend anyone give your business to this community staple.
Dirty floor, dirty tables, and garbage was overflowed. The crust was very soft, you could roll it up like a burrito and not that good compared to other pizza joints. Had to throw the pizza back in the oven at home just to get the crust to where it was cooked completely.
Restaurantji Recommends
Local pizza is the best pizza. Pino is the man, top tier pizza and calzones.
Best pizza in the area by a mile. Next time you’re on break and you forgot your lunch, go here and get the 2 slices and pop. Ready in like 2 minutes, best price in Woodbury and you’re not just paying for the giant slices, but also for a one of a kind experience😂. Attracts regular people who don’t want the manufactured design fake service chain corporate feel that seems to be everything coming up in our town now a days. The owner is an absolute legend, when he retires they should really make a statue, he’s everything to that place. I never write reviews, but you would not regret checking it out!
Owner is awesome, he brings his New York “get outta here” energy with him every day to woodbury. Pizza is great, but personally I enjoy the atmosphere, maybe not for everyone but, the place is authentic as it gets!
This place has a lot of hate based on the 'atmosphere', but the truth is we need to focus on the pizza! It's fantastic! First bite reminded me of some of my past favorite pizza joints from across the country. I grew up in a military family and have been all over the place, I really really liked the flavor of this pie! The sauce was perfectly savory, rich, and well-balanced.
I came in on a Monday night for a couple of slices, no one was here around 6:30, there were a couple of guys behind the counter. Very straight forward, came in, paid around $10.75 for two slices and a soda. One guy heated it up and placed them into a styrofoam box. Took them home and gobbled them up, 10/10 recommend the pepperoni pizza by the slice at Pino's! Pleased to have found this local gem in my very own neighborhood of Woodbury!
Just picked up our pizza, it was given to the wrong customer. He came back in and told the employees It was wrong, we noticed it was ours but didn't want to wait another 45 minutes. It was burnt and cold. We took it anyways but while waiting, we saw one of the employees in the back rolling the dough with his shirt off. Absolutely disgusting.
Edit: Called to talk to a manager due to disrespect at the store on top of that and we were put on hold and then hung up on.
Loading...