Food and service were great as always! Disclaimer says prices in store and in advertisements are cash prices and subject to an up charge. A petty money grab, in my opinion, but at least it's upfront. Nothing is said about online prices, and since cash payment is not an option, one would assume the upcharge is included, but it is not. It's only $1, but it's the idea of sneaking in a bs charge that is annoying. Just be upfront and honest about pricing and stop adding in additional charges and price your menu accordingly.
Good pizza, excellent Friday night special. Great pizza joint atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Baertlein
Ordered online from the Stillwater location. Got a text that said order was received at 544pm.The pickup time on my confirmation said 603pm (doesn't say estimated, says ready for pickup at). Got there about 607pm, told the guy my name, he asked again what it is, then asked if it was an online order. I said yes and he shouted my name to the MANY people in the kitchen (although only looked like a few were actually doing anything). The one guy says it's not quite ready, will be a few minutes. 4 more people walked in for their pickup orders, one guy asked if they had bottled water- guy at the desk says idk,the bar might. Then a few mins later says we have it we just don't know where it is. Then a few mins later, comes out with 2 cold bottles of water...very odd. I waited as those 4 people, along with 3 more after them, received their food and left. At 20 mins, the guy says, it's almost up, just a couple mins, sorry for the wait (yes he apologized, no it was not sincere- more of a formality). A different guy calls my name and says have a good night. I was missing half of my order, which I said to him. He looked at me confused and the guy making the food says it's in the bag over there. Get to my car to double check everything is there, and the "meatball dinner" I ordered is leaking sauce out all over the bag and 2 other boxes of food. It's meatballs in red sauce, baked with cheese on top. They literally dumped the sauce into the Styrofoam container, put the meatballs in and put the cheese on. It was slightly melted, more so like the hot sauce had melted it, rather than actually putting it in the oven before boxing it up. I did end up putting it in the oven at home, however, it was absolutely disgusting tasting and I ended up throwing it out. The cheese bread had 2 cups of sauce,since I ordered extra- but looked like they put the sauce cups in the box, Then the hot cheese bread around/on the bottom cup, which then melted the lid on the bottom cup. The pizza was mediocre- def doesn't taste like Carbones from back in the day. I sent the company as a whole a message on fb, to see how I can message that location, as there is not an email or contact us page on the site,only a.phone number. Judging by the way they acted in person, I don't think I'll get far with calling. Also after reading alot of these reviews, doesn't look like I'll get far either way. Such a bummer, terrible service, bad food but speedy. Really sucks that they don't think customer service and decent food are priorities.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
L Metz
Good service. Friendly neighborhood bar atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
John Lessard
Did not expect a bar to be here, but did not get into that as we were working nearby and went for lunch. Will go back for the wings and pizza. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pizza
Rich Tomasini
Kid-friendliness: The bartender is bad. Took 10 mins to get a drink. Phone volume was at 1 bartender said it was to loud. The music in the bar is to loud. I recommend not to go to carbones in stillwater. If u go there and have a blonde older bartender leave or don't tip her.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Lasagna, Pizza
Mike Paulson
Service is always outstanding and pizza is excellent!!
Had a fantastic Pizza today at the Carbone's in Stillwater, First time trying the pan pizza house special. I do enjoy Minnesota style pizza. The only critique is I like to have the toppings above the cheese instead of under but it was so tasty it didn't really matter. I will definitely be returning to this Carbone's again and recommended it to my friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Petersen
The pizza is fantastic. We try and pair it with a salad for additional veggie options. Staff very friendly.
Parking: Plenty of parking. Make sure you hold the hands of any little ones as the lot is pretty busy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pizza, Salad, Italian Cheese Bread
CJ Parker
The waitress was clean, friendly & patient. She didn't hurry us & any questions we have, she smiled & answered them + she gave suggestions. The place was extremely clean & so was the parking lot. Fantastic location. It was my first time eating @ a Carbone's Pizza. Great pizza. It was very calming & relaxing. I'm definitely going bk even though I live around an hr away. I'm looking forward to meeting the owner. Everything was excellent & extremely clean.
Food and service were great as always! Disclaimer says prices in store and in advertisements are cash prices and subject to an up charge. A petty money grab, in my opinion, but at least it's upfront. Nothing is said about online prices, and since cash payment is not an option, one would assume the upcharge is included, but it is not. It's only $1, but it's the idea of sneaking in a bs charge that is annoying. Just be upfront and honest about pricing and stop adding in additional charges and price your menu accordingly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Sausage Pizza, Garlic Cheese Bread, Pizza
Delicious fresh hot pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Not good
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Very satisfied and the pizzas are very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza, excellent Friday night special. Great pizza joint atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered online from the Stillwater location. Got a text that said order was received at 544pm.The pickup time on my confirmation said 603pm (doesn't say estimated, says ready for pickup at). Got there about 607pm, told the guy my name, he asked again what it is, then asked if it was an online order. I said yes and he shouted my name to the MANY people in the kitchen (although only looked like a few were actually doing anything). The one guy says it's not quite ready, will be a few minutes. 4 more people walked in for their pickup orders, one guy asked if they had bottled water- guy at the desk says idk,the bar might. Then a few mins later says we have it we just don't know where it is. Then a few mins later, comes out with 2 cold bottles of water...very odd. I waited as those 4 people, along with 3 more after them, received their food and left. At 20 mins, the guy says, it's almost up, just a couple mins, sorry for the wait (yes he apologized, no it was not sincere- more of a formality). A different guy calls my name and says have a good night. I was missing half of my order, which I said to him. He looked at me confused and the guy making the food says it's in the bag over there. Get to my car to double check everything is there, and the "meatball dinner" I ordered is leaking sauce out all over the bag and 2 other boxes of food. It's meatballs in red sauce, baked with cheese on top. They literally dumped the sauce into the Styrofoam container, put the meatballs in and put the cheese on. It was slightly melted, more so like the hot sauce had melted it, rather than actually putting it in the oven before boxing it up. I did end up putting it in the oven at home, however, it was absolutely disgusting tasting and I ended up throwing it out. The cheese bread had 2 cups of sauce,since I ordered extra- but looked like they put the sauce cups in the box, Then the hot cheese bread around/on the bottom cup, which then melted the lid on the bottom cup. The pizza was mediocre- def doesn't taste like Carbones from back in the day. I sent the company as a whole a message on fb, to see how I can message that location, as there is not an email or contact us page on the site,only a.phone number. Judging by the way they acted in person, I don't think I'll get far with calling. Also after reading alot of these reviews, doesn't look like I'll get far either way. Such a bummer, terrible service, bad food but speedy. Really sucks that they don't think customer service and decent food are priorities.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good service. Friendly neighborhood bar atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Did not expect a bar to be here, but did not get into that as we were working nearby and went for lunch. Will go back for the wings and pizza. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Pizza
Kid-friendliness: The bartender is bad. Took 10 mins to get a drink. Phone volume was at 1 bartender said it was to loud. The music in the bar is to loud. I recommend not to go to carbones in stillwater. If u go there and have a blonde older bartender leave or don't tip her.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Lasagna, Pizza
Service is always outstanding and pizza is excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Italian Cheese Bread
Had a fantastic Pizza today at the Carbone's in Stillwater,
First time trying the pan pizza house special.
I do enjoy Minnesota style pizza.
The only critique is I like to have the toppings above the cheese instead of under but it was so tasty it didn't really matter. I will definitely be returning to this Carbone's again and recommended it to my friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is fantastic. We try and pair it with a salad for additional veggie options. Staff very friendly.
Parking: Plenty of parking. Make sure you hold the hands of any little ones as the lot is pretty busy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pizza, Salad, Italian Cheese Bread
The waitress was clean, friendly & patient. She didn't hurry us & any questions we have, she smiled & answered them + she gave suggestions. The place was extremely clean & so was the parking lot. Fantastic location. It was my first time eating @ a Carbone's Pizza. Great pizza. It was very calming & relaxing. I'm definitely going bk even though I live around an hr away. I'm looking forward to meeting the owner. Everything was excellent & extremely clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Good pizza and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...