The Trophy Room At Old Kinderhook

This was our second time dining at The Trophy Room for our business conference dinner. Our experience was, once again, nothing less than excellent! We had 13 in our party and everyone was taken care of as if there were just a few of us. The ladies that served our group treated us like they knew us and even made our birthday guest feel like he was the most important person there. All of the food was delicious, the atmosphere was welcoming and the outdoor firepit was a nice break in between apps and dinner! This might be our new tradition while at our conference.

It took over 45 minutes after we ordered to get our food. There was just two of us and we were there for almost 2 hours. Very slow and food was average for the price. Very noisy as well.

We had a wonderful server Robin who was very kind and got us everything we needed

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

We are new to the area, found the restaurant via iPhone restaurant search near where we are staying. The ambiance of the building and the view of the restaurant were very relaxing. The service was spot on, not too pushy, not having to hunt for our waitress. We split the special of the day Prime Rib, with the crab cake appetizer. More than enough for both of us. We will be coming back to the area and the restaurant again.

The prime rib special was perfectly cooked with excellent flavor. Loved the truffle fries appetizer. Will definitely go back.

We attended the trophy room on Valentine's Day to celebrate a birthday as well as Valentines. I made the reservation four weeks prior to the day however, when we got there, we were seated in the bar and not in the main dining room. This is a very disappointing evening for our party.

The food was wonderful. The wait staff all answered my questions (I had many!), and they did so with immediate knowledge. We walked away stuffed and enjoyed the junior hockey team outside playing a game.

Had a nice dinner with my husband. He had the cheeseburger and I had the pork chop. Both were tastey and seasoned well. Unfortunately both were also quite overcooked compared to how we ordered and it made them a bit dry. I would expect a place like this to know how to cook meat to the right temperature. I should add it was not very busy.
We split a brownie dessert and that was sumptuous!

The atmosphere is nice but the finishes are rather dated. Very 90's. I will say the bathroom is very clean and nice.

I will go again, but have lower expectations for the food and ambience.

The star was Sara, our server. She was friendly, knowledgable, attentive - timing our salad/soup, anticipating our drinks, and getting things quickly. She's a delight!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Food was good. The staff are exceptionally attentive and friendly. Disappointed they do not offer calamari anymore though.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lisa is the best!

Went with party of six. After 1 hour finally brought order for 5 of the group and the last order came after everyone one else had finished their meal. The manager never came out to apologize. The waitress tried to apologize but the manager just hung her out to dry. Not a great experience.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

I ordered the ribeye and my wife ordered the short ribs. The presentation was great and the food was amazing. Great service as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anniversary dinner was fabulous! Crab cakes were worth it! Robin (5*)made me a hot chocolate with whipped cream and as I sat by the fire, I knew I’d be back next week! Thank you to the lovely Robin for her making us feel so special!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Connie is a wonderful server. She was always very pleasant treated each of with great respect.

Food: 5

Amazing service and food was out of this world amazing highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes, Truffle Fries, Bone in Pork Chop, Trophy Burger, Blackened Chicken Pasta