Cave Gang Pizza & Pub
910 S Garrison Ave, Carthage
(417) 313-8558
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Love this place! Drive ~50 miles one way to eat here. Upsetting, that drive this evening for some great pizza... Ended up to no one/cars, doors locked, no sign. Yet when I looked up online to check out today special... said open.
My family tried 3 small pizzas on our first visit: cheese, pepperoni, and The Hobo. The sauce is a sweet version, which is more similar to a tomato paste than a bright marinara. The crust was like a bar style cracker crust. With the menu advertising local, house smoked meats, i expected more pepperonis. We weren't huge fans of their style, but the service was great and the restaurant itself had nice atmosphere. We sat outside.
The BEST pizza I’ve had in a fat minute! Baked in a stone oven pizza, that you can watch from the bar. Smackin joint really, we live near an hour away and it’s worth going to Carthage alone just for this pizza. The Pigfeather to dead for, no joke. Love the atmosphere and aesthetic of the location and and building. We will be back, it was also a great stop before heading over to the Drive-In theater in Carthage as well!
You May Also Like
Alim Hibachi Grill and Sushi Japanese Express - 502 S Garrison Ave
![]()
Asian, Japanese, Noodles, Food Trucks
Braum's Ice Cream & Dairy Store - 325 S Garrison Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream