Hereford House - Independence

We 2 adults dined in. We picked the 99 duo. 4 course meal. I'm gf and there's not a gf option for the first course so my other half got to choose. Spinach artichoke dip was all his. I chose the gf desert. Your 2nd and 3rd courses are chose per person. The salad was great he got the prime rib stew. It was a thick gravy while tasted store bought. We both got the kc strip. Cooked and seasoned well. Should have melted in the mouth. The steaks were tough and did not have the texture of a kc strip or any other good cut off meat. I'd compare it to un-marinated or not tenderized London broil tough. Then the kicker was the ticket. I did not look at it before my date paid. We got duped bad. 49.50 a person plus my 10 dollar drink = $109.00 plus tax. Nope 153.61. That's for dinner and drink $140.00 + $13.61 in tax. We had gift cards but chose to only use 1. If you can't purchase certain meals with a gift card my waiter should of said something when I got it out. Also the rules and instructions DOES NOT exclude gift cards. See photos please. Note he paid cash for the rest of the ticket. My review on the gf desert is not good either. I'll be calling to see if I can resolve the situation. If not I've got gift cards to get rid of.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

GREAT all the way around! We actually had just left the restaurant (Feb 11, 2026), and everything and everyone was amazing! The server, Melissa I believe, was very knowledgeable about the menu. She was extremely personable, kind, and all around fantastic. With her knowledge of the menu, we ended up getting a very delicious appetizer (something Hogs, and also got calamari). Thanks chefs! Oh that was scrumptious! You all cooked our meals perfectly. <3
Everyone loved their meals.
And Melissa talked us into deserts.
We all left very happy with every aspect of the experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First of all we had reservations for 6:30 pm We were seated in the bar which I was really displeased with. Waitress was slow took my order incorrect, appetizer were burnt. Main menu items were below average

Jasiah, was our server and he was a great one! We enjoyed him so much. He was very attentive, yet not overly so. My prime rib was cooked to perfection and our food was served promptly. The restaurant is a pleasurable place to be. We will certainly be back again!

Food was great. The service was slow ... we had to watch to grab the server for water, etc. It was a very busy night ... so I give grace. Based on the service issues I suspect they were down a few.

Wasn't very good will not do that again. There are so many more places to go the food has gone downhill.

The service was prompt, courteous' and accurate. I've had disappointments with The Hereford House in the past, But this visit was greatly improved. The steaks, sides, and salads were all great. The spend was a bit high, but I don't blame the restaurant for that. Everything is high. Hereford House is competitive.

Excellent food & excellent server! Herf & turf was delicious. 9 oz filet very good, perfectly cooked, just needed a touch more seasoning. Somewhat overpriced. Baked potato a bit overcooked.

Cocktails were averaging price and above averaging taste. Spinach artichoke dip was amazing. Salad with the House dressing was excellent. Beef stew was excellent. Steak was well seasoned and cooked correctly. Did not need any sauce. French fries and roasted potatoes were just OK. Bread pudding knocked my head into the dirt, it was so good.

I don't want to diss the food or the waiter with an open comment so am sending a private note.

Our server Jennifer was wonderful! Not our first year, and we look forward to future returns. The food was delicious, and plenty of leftovers for Friday night too!!!

We went for Thanksgiving dinner and the service was amazing. The price was perfect and the portions were huge. My only complaint is they put two proteins and all three sides on the same plate. It was a mess. All the gravy spilled onto other dishes that I did not want it on and all the food (picky kid) touching everything.

Sunday afternoon for burgers and salads. We had a terrific server, Andrew, who was attentive without hovering, friendly and very professional. The food was great. Salads with crisp lettuce and fresh ingredients and a meaty prime rib stew to start. Two of us had the seasonal burger with poblano chiles, onions, siracha mayo, and pepperjack cheese. One was requested without the poblanos, which was no problem for the kitchen to accomodate. Another with blue cheese and bacon, the fourth person had the salmon BLT. Everyone agreed the sandwiches were delicious. A beautiful fire and good music also contributed to a wonderful lunch. We will all be back again@!

Our waiter was exceptional! He was very familiar with the menu and offered suggestions that we used. He had a wonderful demeanor and was extremely polite. We will request that he's our waiter the next time we visit!

Took our friends out for their birthday and had bragged out about the prime rib at Hereford House only to have 4 servings of super tough cuts of $43.00 per person crappy meat. What a total waste of money, not mention embarrassing. Would have sent it back but didn't want to embarrass our friends.