Nastiest pizza I’ve ever had. Ordered two NYC style pizzas (one cheese and one sausage). Cheese was NOT NYC pizza. Was thin and crust tasted like a saltine cracker and was underbaked. Sausage pizza was hardly baked and very doughy. Looked more like a raw hand tossed pizza.
sean scally
Best pizza spot in town by far. We really enjoyed the NY hand tossed.
Dotty Manns
We took the grands and it was just perfect!!! Delicious!!! Can’t wait to go back‼️‼️A+++++++++++
Amber Nichole Thiessen
pulled up, saw extremely off-putting and very political signage, left. yeah, yeah, freedom of speech or whatever—you guys do you—but when even politically uninvolved people feel weird about entering your establishment maybe you should lay off the unnecessary posturing? we went to j vietnamese cafe in the same strip instead (5 stars), lmao.
Brittany Richardson
omg the pizza
Collin G.
Just not very good. We got a large NY style pizza and an order of toasted Ravs. The ravs were complete mush and the pizza looked like it had been sitting out on the counter. The cheese was cold and some of the slices didn't even have crust while others were 1/3 crust. Even the "normal" looking slices just did not achieve that balance between big, foldable slices and a slightly crisp bottom that the best NY style pizzas have. I really wanted to like this place because I'd heard it was the best NY style pizza in mid MO but I was massively disappointed
Tim Place
Good, foldable NY style pizza. Good stuff.
Terry J.
The absolute best Italian food I've eaten in years! The lasagna was layered perfectly. Sweet sauce with just the right amount of seasoning to balance it out. The shrimp Alfredo was creamy and delicious! Everything made from scratch. The Italian dressing, I wanted to lick the bowl!! Will definitely be going back to try the rest of the menu! Two full ontres with salads and an appetizers for less than 40 bucks. Great food! Great service! Home Run!
Shelley N. Chruma
My pizza tonight was delicious! I ordered NY style Alfredo sauce with olive oil, tomato’s, basil, garlic and mozzarella cheese. Definitely ordering again!
The Chicago Pizza was not a Chicago Pizza, or really even a deep dish pizza for that matter. The NY pizza we got was OK but not worth what we paid ($20) We also ordered the 4 piece garlic bread and only received 3. The Garlic bread was also lacking in flavor. This really bums me out as it's been a while since I've eaten here and I remember it being VERY good.
Robyn Lindsay Wall
Pizza is the best in Jefferson City MO
Roseanne P.
When we heard that Kate & Ally's was under new management we had to try them. I confess, I'm a thin crust New York style pizza person even though I was raised in Chicago. They make a very good pie--much better than the franchised pizza places in town, and almost as good as Aris Pizza. If I had advice to give them, I'd say, work on your sauce. Real Italian sausage has fennel in it and don't use any other cheese than fresh mozzarella. It's one of the better pizza restaurants in Jefferson City. If they do their homework and use simple, fresh, authentic Italian ingredients, you can't go wrong.
Bob Long
Passing through Jefferson City on vacation. It's Saturday evening and my wife and I were looking for a local pizza place close to our hotel. Kate and Ally's looked good, so checked how late it was open. Website listed open until 10pm. We get there at 8:25pm. The lights are on, but as soon as we get out of the car all the lights were turned off. At 8:25pm, when sign said 10pm! Not a great way to impress customers.
Nastiest pizza I’ve ever had. Ordered two NYC style pizzas (one cheese and one sausage). Cheese was NOT NYC pizza. Was thin and crust tasted like a saltine cracker and was underbaked. Sausage pizza was hardly baked and very doughy. Looked more like a raw hand tossed pizza.
Best pizza spot in town by far. We really enjoyed the NY hand tossed.
We took the grands and it was just perfect!!! Delicious!!! Can’t wait to go back‼️‼️A+++++++++++
pulled up, saw extremely off-putting and very political signage, left. yeah, yeah, freedom of speech or whatever—you guys do you—but when even politically uninvolved people feel weird about entering your establishment maybe you should lay off the unnecessary posturing? we went to j vietnamese cafe in the same strip instead (5 stars), lmao.
omg the pizza
Just not very good. We got a large NY style pizza and an order of toasted Ravs. The ravs were complete mush and the pizza looked like it had been sitting out on the counter. The cheese was cold and some of the slices didn't even have crust while others were 1/3 crust. Even the "normal" looking slices just did not achieve that balance between big, foldable slices and a slightly crisp bottom that the best NY style pizzas have. I really wanted to like this place because I'd heard it was the best NY style pizza in mid MO but I was massively disappointed
Good, foldable NY style pizza. Good stuff.
The absolute best Italian food I've eaten in years! The lasagna was layered perfectly. Sweet sauce with just the right amount of seasoning to balance it out. The shrimp Alfredo was creamy and delicious! Everything made from scratch. The Italian dressing, I wanted to lick the bowl!! Will definitely be going back to try the rest of the menu! Two full ontres with salads and an appetizers for less than 40 bucks. Great food! Great service! Home Run!
My pizza tonight was delicious! I ordered NY style Alfredo sauce with olive oil, tomato’s, basil, garlic and mozzarella cheese. Definitely ordering again!
The owner is an unkind racist.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza and fabulous service!
The Chicago Pizza was not a Chicago Pizza, or really even a deep dish pizza for that matter. The NY pizza we got was OK but not worth what we paid ($20) We also ordered the 4 piece garlic bread and only received 3. The Garlic bread was also lacking in flavor. This really bums me out as it's been a while since I've eaten here and I remember it being VERY good.
Pizza is the best in Jefferson City MO
When we heard that Kate & Ally's was under new management we had to try them. I confess, I'm a thin crust New York style pizza person even though I was raised in Chicago. They make a very good pie--much better than the franchised pizza places in town, and almost as good as Aris Pizza. If I had advice to give them, I'd say, work on your sauce. Real Italian sausage has fennel in it and don't use any other cheese than fresh mozzarella. It's one of the better pizza restaurants in Jefferson City. If they do their homework and use simple, fresh, authentic Italian ingredients, you can't go wrong.
Passing through Jefferson City on vacation. It's Saturday evening and my wife and I were looking for a local pizza place close to our hotel. Kate and Ally's looked good, so checked how late it was open. Website listed open until 10pm. We get there at 8:25pm. The lights are on, but as soon as we get out of the car all the lights were turned off. At 8:25pm, when sign said 10pm! Not a great way to impress customers.