Pizza Underground

202 E High St, Jefferson City
(573) 636-2162

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bekkah Lillie Harris

This place is freaking amazing! Came here with my husband tonight to have a little date night while we were in Jefferson City, and this place definitely did not disappoint. The flavor of the food was amazing, the staff was friendly and this restaurant is seriously the cutest!! I hope nothing for the best for the owner!! If the owner and Gordon Ramsey were in a pizza making competition this guy would take first and blow Gordon’s mind!!! Definitely will be coming back next time we’re out this way!!

Closet 217

We visited from St Louis and needed dinner. Unanimous vote for pizza. 🍕 We are pizza snobs and this didn’t disappoint. Staff was courteous and welcoming. let us know that they were about to sellout of dough!
Ordered the pepperoni, margarita and lots of toppings (my favorite) 🤤all amazing, crispy and savory. I like that the sausage is crumbled not nuggets, pepperoni is bite sized and onions are diced not stringy.
Dough is made fresh daily and they do sell out!! So come early.
Outside dining for pups and kiddos. Free Parking on street. Valet available too. This place is definitely a return trip for us. I hope it flourishes and brings business to the downtown area. 🙏🏼💕

Crista McLain

Best Pizza in town. The crust is nice and chewy and hold up well to the toppings. Love the atmosphere and the staff was sweet!

Aaron Dickey

Why are you constantly running out of dough?!

Elisha Busby

Ruby, our waitress kept our glasses filled up and the food was fresh and delicious! Thank you

blkmadonna_

Ordered the monthly special 😄Very delicious handmade pizza! Perfectly crispy crust, great quality ingredients! Look forward to coming more often!

Jermarcus Perkins

I don’t recommend coming here. The pizza was burnt on the bottom and we had a long wait time.

Bent B

Best pizza in town but bad dining experience. The music is so loud that we couldn’t see each other and the seats are not comfortable. The tables were sticky too.

John Sweeny

Slow service... ran out of dough on Friday night. Pizza place Friday night... you had one job!!! Been here an hour+... no food. It's a dream... you should definitely check out. Also ran out of the beer we ordered. Must be the tariffs..

Jason Morff

6:40 Saturday evening....OUT OF DOUGH....WTF....GO TO HELL.. IF you ask me... that's poor planning and bad business....see ya

James Barker

Pretty chill place to grab some pizza and cold beverage, food and service was fantastic…would recommend

Charles Labedz

good made from scratch food. Flour from Italy, so no glycophosphates (I know it's misspelled) I had zero boat after eating this pizza. I've loved the vodka sausage monthly special. The meats are good. The "too many toppings" delivers on the name. And it's so good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Monthly Special, Meat Pizza, Pizza Margherita, Lots of Toppings, Caesar Salad

Heather Showers

Excellent pizza! Lots of flavor and great service! The atmosphere was fun and would definitely recommend the fry bread and honey sriracha pizza!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sriracha Honey Chicken

Michael Toomey

I was really hoping for something amazing on this one, based on the pictures I saw. However, all I got was disappointment.

The first restaurant doesn't have a sign on the outside so I had to guess that I was going into the right place. The inside decor was also minimalist. I could also hear a dog barking from the kitchen area. Oh well, food is what's most important.

The pizzas only come in 1 size, expensive. I thought with a $20 price tag I would be getting something big, but it was actually a medium sized pizza. It wasn't a good one either. The toppings instantly slid off the flimsy crust as soon as I tried to pick up a slice. I had to resort to eating the pizza with a fork in order to consume it. The taste was ok, but I had to go through a horrible construction to get there.

The people seemed nice, but I wont be back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

Joseph Loeffelmann

Really great pizza. Def try the lava bread

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...