Pizza Underground

219 Madison St #3229, Jefferson City
(573) 636-2162

Recent Reviews

Mrs. K. (Mrs. K)

What a GREAT place for dinner! It was our first time there, our daughter and her family wanted to meet there to celebrate a birthday.Taylor our server and Zoee who backed her up were absolutely wonderful! They were cheerful, professional and on point, so unlike most young servers these days.The place has a great vibe, it was Friday and the place was ?. The staff looked happy to be there, the energy of the place was festive, upbeat and welcoming.But the real star here is the pizza!! You can watch the chef make it right in front if you and it is A+++. The dough is hand stretched, chewy, cooked perfectly and was topped w/ delicious ingredients.We also had a fantastic cesar salad and an incredible cheesy garlic bread. What made it so good was the bread they covered in a delicious, stretchy mozzarella.A wonderful dinner all around, definitely A++++ experience! Thank you Pizza Underground, JC is lucky to have you!Vegetarian options: My granddaughters were very happy w/their cesar salad and veggie pizza.Kid-friendliness: Lots of kids there and lots of happiness and good energy in there!Parking: Street parking is very tight, just park in the parking garage right next door. It's FREE and there's lots of disable parking.Wheelchair accessibility: Wide opening to the restaurant, the restaurant is very expansive, lots if room.

Denise Chapman (Nisi or Steph)

I cannot say enough great things about this place. The food was fantastic. The wine was on point. The dessert is homemade by the owner. Our server Zoe was so amazing. If I could give this place 10 stars, I would. You must come here if you're in Jeff City.

Brian Weishahn

Recently moved to Jefferson City and have tried several local pizza places and this place is by far the best. I really liked the chewy crust. Will definitely be going again. The staff was very friendly as well and they took special care to not cross contaminate my daughter's gluten free pizza.

Jason Ozenberger

Some of the best pizza I've ever had! The dough/crust is excellent, the toppings are always fresh and plentiful, and the pizza is perfectly cooked. They also have very generous salads perfect for sharing. And....the staff is beyond amazing. One of my all the favorites!

Lisa Strejcek

Our table had a variety of pizzas and desserts, they were all delicious!!! The crust, the toppings, all were amazing!

Josh Bray

We went there for the first time tonight with our neighbors and absolutely loved the unique varieties of their pizzas. Must try the honey Sriracha chicken!! ???

Eric J. Obmann

I've sampled a lot of pizza in my time. All kinds of pizza. But, Pizza Underground, I say, is the most authentic, delicious pizza you can find. It's a gem within downtown Jefferson City, serving fresh ingredients, good people and pizza that tastes so fresh and mouth-watering, you'll think you cooked it yourself!The pizza, I literally devoured, was unlike any other I've ever experienced. The staff were very friendly and courteous.All in all, I would give this 20 stars, if I could. Pizza Underground, thank you for letting me experience pizza, in a way that I will remember, for a very long time!

karn leby

First time there & had a big group. They were so helpful & kind to accommodate our group & time constraints. We absolutely love the pizza and salads. So so good, lots of toppings, & healthy with a fun atmosphere. The workers are very kind & friendly … the food is outstanding & let’s keep our family business booming. Will be back !!

Thomas L.

Had a pepperoni pizza. Scorched crust, but good. Wonderful cheese. A little stingy on the pepperoni. Nice evening, so we ate outside. Friendly staff. We will be back.

Nelson P.

This is probably the best pizza in town. Crust is just like Naples: chewy where it should be, crisp on the top and delightfully uneven, meaning it is hand made. Sriracha chicken with honey is our favorite. But the real treat : desserts, handmade by Tabitha. Cupcakes and no-bake cookies are our favorites in both gluten-free and regular.

Tiff Wignall

This is a cute little place nestled in downtown Jeff City. They offer a good variety of homemade pizza and they have new flavors of cupcakes all the time! They do have adult beverages if your interested in that. It would be a good spot for most occasions. It’s accessible and the staff is phenomenal. You can really tell they put efforts into adding that special touch. They can also do take n bake or order to go which is nice! The appetizer cheesy bread is yummy- the only thing I’d do differently is to have warm marinara for dipping (it’s cold). We’ve thoroughly enjoyed both visits and plan to be back!

Misty M.

We stopped at the bar next door for some drinks after a wedding around the corner. We ordered a pepperoni and a margarita. They were both very good. The crust was amazing. Service was excellent, they brought it out to us at our table outside. It really hit the spot.

Zach Paul (WeatherZach)

We've been coming to this family run place for a while and I've never had anything that I didn't like. The pizza toppings are fresh. That was my first thought as I was eating the "Lots of Toppings" pizza. Their pizza crust is made from Italian flour and you can taste the difference. The salads are large enough to share or make it an entire meal. It's all so good! We love this place!!

Jeffrey Thomas

The pizza we ordered both looked exactly like what I think a pizza should; the crust was thin with air blisters and a little char on it and the toppings looked great. The sauce is very different than anything else in town with a unique and unusual sweetness. We all enjoyed it but some may not. This is definitely a stand out pizza joint in Jeff City.

Lisha Womack

The only way to describe is… Fabulous!We enjoyed the full meal experience… salad, cheesy bread, and pizza! Amazingly fresh and crispy pizza!Pizza Underground is my new favorite pizza place!!

Load More