Theo's Midtown

620 W McCarty St, Jefferson City
(573) 893-6969

Recent Reviews

Jacob Sones

This is a wonderful, professional casual environment. The servers are pleasant, communicative, and actually care. The food is great, and the prices are fair. What's not to love?Food: 5/5

linda peters

First time at this place. Parking lot was full. Which I can see why. Food was so good . Service was also wonderful at comfortable atmosphere. Would highly recommend there Greek pizza.Parking: Average spots for parking. Place was full. Definitely a little tricky in the corner.

Candice Sheppard

Never had anything I didn't like from Theos! Great customer service, hot fresh food and Amazing Drink Selection for a small town Restaurant!Food: 5/5

Debra Atkinson

We love Theo's cauliflower pizza - it is the bomb!! I love the diversity of the menu also - fits with any mood you are in!Great staff and cooks!

Chris Butel

Stopped in to Theo's for drinks with friends. Football game was on the televisions, but volume wasn't overly loud so you could still hold a conversation. Staff were very friendly.Service: 5/5

Roy Batty

Ordered a calzone and bone in garlic butter wings. Calzone was soggy and came apart when lifting it up. Did not taste good at all. The wings were bland as could be. I have more flavor in my p*nis than there was in this food which cost $40. Skip this place. Not good at all.

Ahmad Hinds

I will say this the place looks nice. I ordered two extra large pizzas one pepperoni and one pepperoni & chicken and a order of boneless buffalo wings this total came to $59.61. I picked my order and tipped the staff 4 bucks even though the person seemed very timid and uncomfortable serving me. Well I was fine with all the but then when we got hoke and tasted the pizza it was awful not sure how you mess up pizza but that was it. The pizza was too salty and the quality of the cheese was terrible. Toppings tasted old ot just wasn't good my entire family didn't like and my youngest will usually eat anything especially pizza but even he wasn't having it I literally still have 85% of both pizzas left and the boneless wings. I tried to speak with management about it but was told it's nothing they can do about it and when I called back the manager was too busy to talk needless to say that will be my first and last time ever patronizing Theo's I just wish I would not have wasted 60 bucks to learn this lesson.Dietary restrictions: Too salty

Bruce Wylie

Great service and quality food! Too loud for decent meet up conversations with friends when crowded. Need some type of wall /ceiling sound dampening treatment.

James M.

Food was delishish and our server was topnotch. Try their new grinder, it was creamy and cheesy and the Sriracha was the perfect amount of flavor without the spice

Dustin Barrett

This place is great! The staff was very friendly, the beer was cold and delicious and the pizza was to die for! I am coming here every time I come to Jeff City, it's a must!

George Roach

After looking at the menu online we were so looking forward to getting a gyro and the Hellas gyro pizza. We arrived just over an hour before close on a Saturday night. Beer selection was great and our waitress was prompt then the wheels came off. No gyro meat because they didn’t want get more out so late. Ugh. We quickly selected plan B items from the menu and waited and watched our waitress bus tables for 10 minutes. When I went to find a waitress I was scolded for using the employee patio door, but I’m guessing a manager stepped in and put our order in. Our Greek salad and Fredo pizza were amazing.

Theresa West

Delicious gyros! Beautiful building, outdoor seating, nice bar. Looking forward to dining here. Our take home order was just what we hoped for.

Kenny Robins

Been going for a while and been very good. Always ask for not burnt. Had they worst blackest burnt pizza I can remember in a long time from anywhere. F'n horrible

Brianna Swartz

Great atmosphere and great food! Mel is the best waitress - she is already pouring our drinks right when she sees us come in. I always order the gyro and have also tried the pizza - all the food is authentic and tasty! Highly recommend!

Lucia Pink

We have come to enjoy this great locally owned restaurant. Service is usually good. Cauliflower Crust Pizza was amazing. Regular pizzas great too. And my dad loves the gyro.

Load More