Ordered the Italian Beef sandwich and a canolli, both were great. Nice spot to stop in and chow on some Italian favorites with an extensive menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Mozzarella
Paul Hagler
Another favorite in the city. Old style Italian Deli with anything you could want. Best cold deli sandwich in KC.I usually get the #2 because i like mortadella, but they are all amazing.A must go to place if you are in the river market area.
Foogie W.
I have been a lifetime customer of the City Market and have always enjoyed patronizing various vendors and stores over the years, however for some reason or another, it has taken me almost a lifetime to stop in Carollo's. Maybe a year or more ago I went in to purchase Italian Sausage as I like mixing the ground sausage for spaghetti, baking the Italian sausage roll with peppers/onions and the meatballs for subs. I must say, I enjoy the fresh, homemade sausage over store-bought any day. There's actually no comparison and since first going, I haven't looked back. Oddly, I have yet to eat a sandwich there, but it's generally plenty of customers buying them...especially at lunchtime so that's saying something. They sell an assortment of meat, sandwiches, pasta, seasonings, olive oil, desserts and other grocery items. It's a small store-front grocer, deli and meat market that has an area out front where meat is grilled for sandwiches during the warmer months. There's also patio seating to enjoy a tasty Italian sausage sub or whatever you choose. If you're in search of a local grocer to purchase fresh Italian food/groceries from this could be the answer for you. Check it out.
Taylar Crist
There isn’t anything I’d change about this place. Tiramisu was the best I had in my life. All of the entrees were incredible and prices were reasonable. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a great authentic Italian lunch.
Cutest little Italian grocery store in the city market. Has some of the best bacon around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Foster Steward
The sandwiches were nothing special but the bread was good. The grocery part had a lot of options at a good price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mike D.
My favorite sandwich in KC, the #1 classic Italian. Crave it once per month minimum. They have a lot of other choices but I always go for the #1. Also a great specialty Italian grocery. Kansas City icon.
B. Matthews
Love the selection of products but there was a baby roach near the olive bar. Not a great look
Hands down the best Italian market you can go to. We travel from OKC area to KC 2-3x per year and always stock up on fresh sliced pepperoni and prosciutto (the best I've ever had). We also bring back some Italian sausage for meatballs and will continue to come back for much more.
Jake Forbeck
Just got a cannoli, but it was delicious!
MelissaWP
We stopped here for a quick bite to eat after walking around the Arabia Steamboat museum across the street. The line was a bit long for a Thur early afternoon but it was a beautiful early Sep summer day on a day lots of tourists were in town for the big NFL opener that night. The Italian sandwich we ordered was fresh and delicious.
Austin Wiggins
Always ate at chain restaurants and therefore never cared for subs. Then I visited this place. So good! Fresh food and helpful staff. My mind has been opened to a whole different variety of food!
Charissa O.
One of a few really great reasons that I miss N. Kansas City, MO. The food and service was and is always very fresh and authentically delightfully flavorful. Thanks and a shout out to the wonderful two brothers (Anthony & Frankie) that always made my favorite #4 Caprese sandwich just right with my 2 cannoli's that got me through 2020. ps. I will always remember Frankie for replacing my cookies that apparently the delivery driver helped himself too!
Great Italian cookies & GelatoWish we had one in
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
It's a nice family like atmosphere, the same friendly faces and helpfulness everytime I drop in for lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Napolitano Sandwich, Fresh Mozzarella
Ordered the Italian Beef sandwich and a canolli, both were great. Nice spot to stop in and chow on some Italian favorites with an extensive menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Mozzarella
Another favorite in the city. Old style Italian Deli with anything you could want. Best cold deli sandwich in KC.I usually get the #2 because i like mortadella, but they are all amazing.A must go to place if you are in the river market area.
I have been a lifetime customer of the City Market and have always enjoyed patronizing various vendors and stores over the years, however for some reason or another, it has taken me almost a lifetime to stop in Carollo's. Maybe a year or more ago I went in to purchase Italian Sausage as I like mixing the ground sausage for spaghetti, baking the Italian sausage roll with peppers/onions and the meatballs for subs. I must say, I enjoy the fresh, homemade sausage over store-bought any day. There's actually no comparison and since first going, I haven't looked back. Oddly, I have yet to eat a sandwich there, but it's generally plenty of customers buying them...especially at lunchtime so that's saying something. They sell an assortment of meat, sandwiches, pasta, seasonings, olive oil, desserts and other grocery items. It's a small store-front grocer, deli and meat market that has an area out front where meat is grilled for sandwiches during the warmer months. There's also patio seating to enjoy a tasty Italian sausage sub or whatever you choose. If you're in search of a local grocer to purchase fresh Italian food/groceries from this could be the answer for you. Check it out.
There isn’t anything I’d change about this place. Tiramisu was the best I had in my life. All of the entrees were incredible and prices were reasonable. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a great authentic Italian lunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli and Tiramisu, Tiramisu, Philly Cheese Steak, Siciliano Sandwich, Meatball Sandwich
Cutest little Italian grocery store in the city market. Has some of the best bacon around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sandwiches were nothing special but the bread was good. The grocery part had a lot of options at a good price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
My favorite sandwich in KC, the #1 classic Italian. Crave it once per month minimum. They have a lot of other choices but I always go for the #1. Also a great specialty Italian grocery. Kansas City icon.
Love the selection of products but there was a baby roach near the olive bar. Not a great look
Restaurantji Recommends
Hands down the best Italian market you can go to. We travel from OKC area to KC 2-3x per year and always stock up on fresh sliced pepperoni and prosciutto (the best I've ever had). We also bring back some Italian sausage for meatballs and will continue to come back for much more.
Just got a cannoli, but it was delicious!
We stopped here for a quick bite to eat after walking around the Arabia Steamboat museum across the street. The line was a bit long for a Thur early afternoon but it was a beautiful early Sep summer day on a day lots of tourists were in town for the big NFL opener that night. The Italian sandwich we ordered was fresh and delicious.
Always ate at chain restaurants and therefore never cared for subs. Then I visited this place. So good! Fresh food and helpful staff. My mind has been opened to a whole different variety of food!
One of a few really great reasons that I miss N. Kansas City, MO. The food and service was and is always very fresh and authentically delightfully flavorful. Thanks and a shout out to the wonderful two brothers (Anthony & Frankie) that always made my favorite #4 Caprese sandwich just right with my 2 cannoli's that got me through 2020. ps. I will always remember Frankie for replacing my cookies that apparently the delivery driver helped himself too!