New Haven Ice Cream Shoppe

9442C MO-100, New Haven
(573) 237-1535

Recent Reviews

Randy Mueller

They always make sure Macey has her

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Tracy Evans

I would not recommend this place to anyone the employees are rude and unfriendly. The food is to high priced for how overcooked it is.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason

The best ice cream in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aaron Montgomery

Service was fast and friendly. And you can't beat the prices. What a hidden gem for anyone heading back to St. Louis from Pin Oak Pumpkin Patch.

Cynthia Day

We were in town at Astral Glass and stopped in for ice cream. My husband and I got a Carmel sundae with Reese's and they were one of the best sundaes I have ever had. My only issue was the bathroom toilet was pretty gross and there were dirty tables. We were the only people there. Just need to clean a little more.

Ninett Falkenrath

The bacon cheeseburger was so yummy my husband had to order a second! The cheese balls were so crunchy and delicious. And the ice cream... Wow!!! Definitely coming back again!!!

Amy West

Seriously, good!! Fast service also.

Linda Kleinheider

Best steak Sandwich

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Rice

Quaint ice cream shop in New Haven that offers both food and cold treats. We had the hot fudge sundae, cookie dough concrete, and mint chocolate chip ice cream and it was all delish!

Anne Taylor

Good food and ice cream!

Nora Winters

Had lunch with my BFF. Cheese burger and friesThen I had the very best marshmallow/hot fudge Sunday. I love this place it is home spun.

Jon Diaz

Monday patty melt and club sandwiches were awesome!

Douglas Grindstaff

My first visit. Friends said to order the Deluxe Banana Split. Egad....a monster. Loved every bite. Then found out that Weds.'s were 1/2 price burgers. Gotta try that on the next visit. Friendly worker(s) and nice quaint little place. We'll be back. KOOL!

Kristin Hagedorn

Love their grilled cheese! Hamburgers and cheese balls are delicious too. And of course, you can't go wrong with ice cream.

Justin Noble

Pretty tasty ice cream and the food smelled delicious. Just one glaring issue.....You have a young girl working hard, doing everything up front, a young boy taking money and chatting and another boy doing whatever in the back of the building beyond sight. 1 by 1 the orders got accomplished BECAUSE OF HER! The boys did near zero, save for briskly wiping down a table here and there. While they all were polite, this style of work is not efficient or effective. Many hands make light work and the girl is the star here. I'll be in again soon. Let's see if this changes....

Load More