I absolutely love this restaurant. It’s my favorite place to eat. I’ve never had a bad meal there or a bad experience. And, as someone who loves history the ambience is top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LeafTheFox
Such an awesome experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy Williams
What an amazing place! The home is so beautiful and the food is 10 out of 5 stars, it is so amazing. Wonderful atmosphere, amazing hosts, and food! If you haven't been here, you need to!Definitely will be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joan Grace
Excellent! This place is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michaela Anderson
My husband and I received a $150 gift certificate from out of state friends Christmas 2022. Wanted to save it for our first date anniversary in December, and attempted to make reservations the Saturday after Thanksgiving 2023. Emailed, then called and left a voicemail after their message said they’d be in business, and emailed again, trying to compliment them whilst trying to grab a reservation 3 weeks in advance. Instead, I was questioned on my personal life choices with “why did you wait so long”, argued with and even mocked believe it or not, with no attempt to ever “check for availability” for me. I tried to just respond back with “thank you for checking” instead of getting in a fight. Never heard back and here it is a week later. Very disappointed because I’d heard nice things about them before even though looking through reviews now, you're paying “fine dining” prices for a scoop of boxed mashed potatoes, frozen vegetables, and a thawed roll with meat that is not filet mignon cuts. Something I’d serve in the elementary cafeteria. Money wasted all around for false advertisement with rude and unprofessional behavior.In response to the chef, you chose to make this personal topic public and again as stated in my email, I am sorry for your loss. That had NOTHING to do with this and you know that! Too bad I’m unable to post our conversation here. Want to talk about selfish behavior when you’re using your father’s passing as an excuse for your rude behavior?! You had no intentions of letting me extend as your certificate states “JC Wyatt House will NOT extend this date.” Also, not hearing back from you an entire week after I was so rudely spoken to, I assumed you made yourselves “unavailable”. The least you could do would be to refund, sure that won’t happen. I have every right to leave an opinion just as you do and everyone else. Can’t please everyone I suppose.
Food: 1
John Steen
Legitimately one of the most delicious meals we've had on a night out. Very warm and inviting atmosphere while still giving an air of exclusivity. Our table felt private despite other tables being nearby. The proprietor was really nice and took a few minutes to chat with us. Make your reservations early and call ahead to choose your main entree! Great place to make your date feel special. We'll happily return in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Choice Orthodontics
We have been coming to JC Wyatt House for over 10 years now. Jeff and Jim are phenomenal and take care of us like family. We have never once had a bad meal and the service is impeccable. If you are looking for delicious, quality food and an atmosphere that can’t be beat, then look no further.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shannon F
This place is amazing! Halloween is the best time to go with the decorations. Service and food can’t be beat. We go every year in October.
Ian C
After visiting tonight, I see why it is far and away the best rated dining experience in St. Joseph. The Halloween decor was amazing (and some of it even a little creepy!) but the food was even better. The owner was very gracious and happily answered every question our group asked and you could tell the restaurant is his passion, and the staff provided excellent service; We are already working on a return visit to take our families….it truly is an absolute hidden gem, as I’d never heard of it until our friends invited us. Worth every single cent!
Maggie W
This place is top notch! The decorations for Halloween are as well. The food though is off the charts!
I absolutely love this restaurant. It’s my favorite place to eat. I’ve never had a bad meal there or a bad experience. And, as someone who loves history the ambience is top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such an awesome experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What an amazing place! The home is so beautiful and the food is 10 out of 5 stars, it is so amazing. Wonderful atmosphere, amazing hosts, and food! If you haven't been here, you need to!Definitely will be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent! This place is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I received a $150 gift certificate from out of state friends Christmas 2022. Wanted to save it for our first date anniversary in December, and attempted to make reservations the Saturday after Thanksgiving 2023. Emailed, then called and left a voicemail after their message said they’d be in business, and emailed again, trying to compliment them whilst trying to grab a reservation 3 weeks in advance. Instead, I was questioned on my personal life choices with “why did you wait so long”, argued with and even mocked believe it or not, with no attempt to ever “check for availability” for me. I tried to just respond back with “thank you for checking” instead of getting in a fight. Never heard back and here it is a week later. Very disappointed because I’d heard nice things about them before even though looking through reviews now, you're paying “fine dining” prices for a scoop of boxed mashed potatoes, frozen vegetables, and a thawed roll with meat that is not filet mignon cuts. Something I’d serve in the elementary cafeteria. Money wasted all around for false advertisement with rude and unprofessional behavior.In response to the chef, you chose to make this personal topic public and again as stated in my email, I am sorry for your loss. That had NOTHING to do with this and you know that! Too bad I’m unable to post our conversation here. Want to talk about selfish behavior when you’re using your father’s passing as an excuse for your rude behavior?! You had no intentions of letting me extend as your certificate states “JC Wyatt House will NOT extend this date.” Also, not hearing back from you an entire week after I was so rudely spoken to, I assumed you made yourselves “unavailable”. The least you could do would be to refund, sure that won’t happen. I have every right to leave an opinion just as you do and everyone else. Can’t please everyone I suppose.
Food: 1
Legitimately one of the most delicious meals we've had on a night out. Very warm and inviting atmosphere while still giving an air of exclusivity. Our table felt private despite other tables being nearby. The proprietor was really nice and took a few minutes to chat with us. Make your reservations early and call ahead to choose your main entree! Great place to make your date feel special. We'll happily return in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been coming to JC Wyatt House for over 10 years now. Jeff and Jim are phenomenal and take care of us like family. We have never once had a bad meal and the service is impeccable. If you are looking for delicious, quality food and an atmosphere that can’t be beat, then look no further.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is amazing! Halloween is the best time to go with the decorations. Service and food can’t be beat. We go every year in October.
After visiting tonight, I see why it is far and away the best rated dining experience in St. Joseph. The Halloween decor was amazing (and some of it even a little creepy!) but the food was even better. The owner was very gracious and happily answered every question our group asked and you could tell the restaurant is his passion, and the staff provided excellent service; We are already working on a return visit to take our families….it truly is an absolute hidden gem, as I’d never heard of it until our friends invited us. Worth every single cent!
This place is top notch! The decorations for Halloween are as well. The food though is off the charts!
Restaurantji Recommends
A hidden Gem in St. Joseph! The atmosphere the owner presents is outstanding! Definitely want to return!
It’s a wonderful private dinner experience with an amazing food and an elegant background. Highly recommended!
Intimate antique atmosphere. Well hosted. Out of this world desserts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a delightful piece of history. The food was terrific, and the owner was lovely to boot! Thank you for having us!
Good and service wonderful!