Went at 7:30- place was lit on inside with a few still eating inside. Sign on door said closed. Truly believe workers were probably too lazy to stay until 9 and are getting away with closing shop early. Disappointing
Tim Benedict
Build your own pie. Enough ingredients to satisfy you but I wouldn't rave about it. Subway style set up. Takes a few minutes for your pizza to be ready.
Dennis J.
If you like a custom made pizza exactly how you want it without paying more for each topping then you'd love this place. Pizzas are cooked in a rolling oven rack to perfection every time. It's very similar to MOD pizza or Blaze pizza but without the fire oven baking. The place is clean and empty each time I've been there.
JeremyandShay Albright
We love Pie Five so we stopped by to pick up dinner. The sign was on, but it was dark inside and they were closed. There was not a sign stating why they were closed and it is not a holiday. Very disappointing ?
Ashley Carver
They have good pizza and the set up in there is neat. But I felt uncomfortable while in there. For one I had never been in there and didn't know how things worked and for two one of the employees had laughed at a question I had about what salad dressings they had available. I had never been there so I didn't know what dressings they had and so when he asked what salad dressing I wanted I asked what kind do you have and he laughed at me and named off a few. I felt very uncomfortable and awkward. If I eat there again I will more than likely use DoorDash or do carryout.
Matt McDonald
The pizza here is pretty good. I'd wish the staff was friendlier. It seems like every time I go in whomever is working seems upset or mad. Not a real warm and fuzzy feeling going in here. The drink/condiment area always seems to be messy and in need of cleaning.
Jared Tyes
Manger she was very rude and not helpful over the phone , never will I order from there again , besides that the pizza is fantastic , one of the best I had in st joe!! But that lady manger very rude in professional...
Howard Cohen
Our first stop at Pie Five Pizza. Great selection of crusts and toppings and overall a very good pizza and bread sticks. I had to ding them a star for what seems like a staffing issue. They only had two people working the counter and since they are making individual personal pizzas it was a very slow process and by the time we got each of our five entrees made, there was a line of about fifteen people behind us. In a nutshell, really good pizza, but not if you're in a hurry.
Rick Liberty
Pizza was great.Took a while to make pizzas and cook. More than the 5 minutes they claim.If there are no customers ordering, employees disappear and don't come from out back. We tried to get a to-go box and they never came out.
Valarie Russell
Absolutely amazing.Pizza was amazing, staff was amazing.I wish they would get new tables as they need redone. Feel sticky, but we literally watched them wipe them and the chairs.It's just the overlay.All in all hands down, great service and job!!
First time trying this place.My pizza craving was satisfied This is the best way to get a pizza just the way you want it ! We've tried every pizza place out there and they're all a huge disappointment. They use a quality mozzarella here. Pie Five Pizza is our new pizza place.
Glenda Kelly
Terrible pizza. Everything slide off crust & crust not thoroughly cooked. Side salad had a lot of spoiled lettuce. Will not order again
Cassie Nixdorf
Went with my mom & daughter today, Alyssa was the only one that showed up to work. She did amazing at keeping up with all the customers & was running her tail off. She kept a good attitude the entire time as the line got longer. She definitely deserves a raise based off her work ethic. Good job Alyssa ??
Miles Di Camillo
Found a hidden gluten free gem ? Try Pie Five. They have these delicious gluten free crusts that taste completely normal. I used to get tons of DoorDash orders there. I've been dying to try it and was sad originally with my diagnosis until I learned that have gluten free options. Would highly recommend it. Just tried delivering it myself and the food got here early.
Ria Diaz
Newly gluten free? That's not a problem here! They're gluten-free pizza is so amazing I questioned for a moment if it was actually gluten free! My order was right and it tasted the same as gluten pizza. I was recently diagnosed with celiac disease, in other words I can't have gluten. One thing I was saddest about was missing pizza, then I discovered this place had gluten free crust???? I'd highly recommend it. I'm a hardcore reviewer so if I hate a place, you'll know, but this place was amazing. Good food, quick service and any place that can overwhelm DoorDash drivers with orders and is still ok by the health department must be a good place to eat at. They made this transition far less miserable. I loved it loved it loved it. My first time ordering delivery since everything and it couldn't have gone more perfect! This order took about a total of 10-15 minutes in total! I ordered it around 8-8:15 and not long after had the order in my hands. Ten minutes later I was stuffed! ??
Went at 7:30- place was lit on inside with a few still eating inside. Sign on door said closed. Truly believe workers were probably too lazy to stay until 9 and are getting away with closing shop early. Disappointing
Build your own pie. Enough ingredients to satisfy you but I wouldn't rave about it. Subway style set up. Takes a few minutes for your pizza to be ready.
If you like a custom made pizza exactly how you want it without paying more for each topping then you'd love this place. Pizzas are cooked in a rolling oven rack to perfection every time. It's very similar to MOD pizza or Blaze pizza but without the fire oven baking. The place is clean and empty each time I've been there.
We love Pie Five so we stopped by to pick up dinner. The sign was on, but it was dark inside and they were closed. There was not a sign stating why they were closed and it is not a holiday. Very disappointing ?
They have good pizza and the set up in there is neat. But I felt uncomfortable while in there. For one I had never been in there and didn't know how things worked and for two one of the employees had laughed at a question I had about what salad dressings they had available. I had never been there so I didn't know what dressings they had and so when he asked what salad dressing I wanted I asked what kind do you have and he laughed at me and named off a few. I felt very uncomfortable and awkward. If I eat there again I will more than likely use DoorDash or do carryout.
The pizza here is pretty good. I'd wish the staff was friendlier. It seems like every time I go in whomever is working seems upset or mad. Not a real warm and fuzzy feeling going in here. The drink/condiment area always seems to be messy and in need of cleaning.
Manger she was very rude and not helpful over the phone , never will I order from there again , besides that the pizza is fantastic , one of the best I had in st joe!! But that lady manger very rude in professional...
Our first stop at Pie Five Pizza. Great selection of crusts and toppings and overall a very good pizza and bread sticks. I had to ding them a star for what seems like a staffing issue. They only had two people working the counter and since they are making individual personal pizzas it was a very slow process and by the time we got each of our five entrees made, there was a line of about fifteen people behind us. In a nutshell, really good pizza, but not if you're in a hurry.
Pizza was great.Took a while to make pizzas and cook. More than the 5 minutes they claim.If there are no customers ordering, employees disappear and don't come from out back. We tried to get a to-go box and they never came out.
Absolutely amazing.Pizza was amazing, staff was amazing.I wish they would get new tables as they need redone. Feel sticky, but we literally watched them wipe them and the chairs.It's just the overlay.All in all hands down, great service and job!!
Restaurantji Recommends
First time trying this place.My pizza craving was satisfied This is the best way to get a pizza just the way you want it ! We've tried every pizza place out there and they're all a huge disappointment. They use a quality mozzarella here. Pie Five Pizza is our new pizza place.
Terrible pizza. Everything slide off crust & crust not thoroughly cooked. Side salad had a lot of spoiled lettuce. Will not order again
Went with my mom & daughter today, Alyssa was the only one that showed up to work. She did amazing at keeping up with all the customers & was running her tail off. She kept a good attitude the entire time as the line got longer. She definitely deserves a raise based off her work ethic. Good job Alyssa ??
Found a hidden gluten free gem ? Try Pie Five. They have these delicious gluten free crusts that taste completely normal. I used to get tons of DoorDash orders there. I've been dying to try it and was sad originally with my diagnosis until I learned that have gluten free options. Would highly recommend it. Just tried delivering it myself and the food got here early.
Newly gluten free? That's not a problem here! They're gluten-free pizza is so amazing I questioned for a moment if it was actually gluten free! My order was right and it tasted the same as gluten pizza. I was recently diagnosed with celiac disease, in other words I can't have gluten. One thing I was saddest about was missing pizza, then I discovered this place had gluten free crust???? I'd highly recommend it. I'm a hardcore reviewer so if I hate a place, you'll know, but this place was amazing. Good food, quick service and any place that can overwhelm DoorDash drivers with orders and is still ok by the health department must be a good place to eat at. They made this transition far less miserable. I loved it loved it loved it. My first time ordering delivery since everything and it couldn't have gone more perfect! This order took about a total of 10-15 minutes in total! I ordered it around 8-8:15 and not long after had the order in my hands. Ten minutes later I was stuffed! ??