Amy's Cake Pop Shop/Alibi Cookies

I have had cake pops from Amy's Cake Pop Shop and they're delicious and artistically/cleverly designed. I'm leaving this review, though, after Amy did a birthday party for our six year old where she taught a room full of rising first graders how to make and decorate cake pops. It was such a fun and creative party and Amy and her assistants were so terrific working with a group of kids this age.

Can't recommend highly enough, and makes me want to continue to support her business. Thanks, Amy!

The cake pops themselves are wonderful but the girl you had working today was genuinely giving the worst customer service I’ve ever had. She didn’t say hello or welcome us, gave us dirty looks and barely spoke. She seemed mad we were there and this has happened twice. We won’t be back again

Amy is a MIRACLE worker!! I gave her the wrong date for an event by complete mistake, and she was still able to accommodate me and fill my order despite the last minute realization! 10/10 customer service. Her cakepops were a huge success for my sister’s graduation party! Everyone loved them. Thank you again Amy!!

We didn’t realize she had winter hours (closing at 8 instead of 9) and she was extremely delightful and let us come in anyway. The cookies we got were ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Amy has gained a forever customer!

We didn’t realize she had winter hours (closing at 8 instead of 9) and she was extremely delightful and let us come in anyway. The cookies we got were ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Amy has gained a forever customer!

Absolutely delicious and so very kind!

Fantastic gluten free options!!

We just hosted my 9-year-old daughter’s birthday party at Amy’s Cake Pop Shop, and it was fantastic! Amy was incredibly patient and engaging with the girls, making the entire experience fun and stress-free. The activities were perfectly suited for their age, and the cake pops turned out adorable. I can’t say enough good things. I highly recommend for a fun, creative, and memorable party experience!

We just hosted my 9-year-old daughter’s birthday party at Amy’s Cake Pop Shop, and it was fantastic! Amy was incredibly patient and engaging with the girls, making the entire experience fun and stress-free. The activities were perfectly suited for their age, and the cake pops turned out adorable. I can’t say enough good things. I highly recommend Amy’s Cake Pop Shop for a fun, creative, and memorable party experience!

My wife and I went through the Best of Missouri Festival at the Missouri Botanical Gardens about a week ago. We saw Amy’s Cake Pops tent at opening and went over. She had a stack of great looking Caramel Apples. Being a huge fan I bought one. $10… no worries. She even held it for me until we were done shopping. I put it in the fridge when we came home and promptly forgot it because we had so much else going on that evening. Today, 6 days later, I cracked it open. This may be the BEST Caramel Apple I have ever had in my life. A layer of caramel under a layer of chocolate. The apple was perfectly sweet and crisp! WOW - Just WOW! Huge shoutout to Amy’s Cake Pops and Amy herself. Please go visit her shop in Wester Groves! My wife and definitely will! 🎃👍🍁🍂❤️

Four year old approved! Delicious strawberry shortcake cake pop in celebration of the first day of school. The new shop is so adorable, and my kiddo loved it!!! The pop was doughy, sweet and beautiful. We will be back!

The service and products we received were great! The original company we ordered from was destroyed by the tornado, so we found Amy’s Cake Pop Shop online. She was very hospitable and helped make our event a success.

If you’re looking for a sweet treat that won’t completely break the bank or your pant buttons, Amy’s Cake Pop Shop is an ideal spot to indulge yourself!

Both the cookie dough and the birthday cake pops were great, and I think either of them is a good choice depending on your personal flavor preferences.

We had a great birthday celebration with the adorable, yummy cake pops and amazing chocolate covered Oreos! We will definitely be back for more!

These cake pops were a hit at my sister's baby shower! They were so cute, tasted delish, and she even had a gluten free option! Amy was easy to work with and I feel the value is amazing. I would order for any future event without hesitation!