We love this restaurant! The cocktails were delicious! I had lobster bisque and my husband had clam chowder - both were wonderful! My husband had a buttery lobster roll while I had the summer wedge salad - did not disappoint!! My husband loved the peel & eat shrimp and we shared hush puppies - again, delicious! We’ve never been disappointed at this place! And Jacob our server - wow! He was awesome!! The nicest guy! He was so busy but he always made sure we had what we needed! A+ Peacemaker! (Oh and I LOVE the atmosphere!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
bradley combs
It was way too overpriced for what you got and it was not anything to waste that kind of of money on
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jonathan Fleming
Great happy hour specials! Fresh tasty oysters. Lobster rolls were amazing. Second round of eating-great gumbo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Echavarria
Man this was the bommmb the poorboy shirmp hit the spot great service from Erika .B at #stlairport # gotta try this food won’t be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Jane Burrows
the french fries were good, and the roll itself was nice but the lobster itself and the service left more to be desired. the lobster was unseasoned - i expected more butter or flavoring but maybe thats my curse as a girlie who lived in new orleans for years. eben though i orderef it warm, the lobster felt kinda lukewarm… i also dislike sitting myself down, going up to a counter/using qr code to order and then you having the gall to ask for a tip? before ive even gotten the food? i don’t even like tipping before my item for coffee, never mind for a sit down restaurant with expensive sandwiches. it wasnt awful, but i do find it grossly ovepriced and dont plan to return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Tedd Trabert
☠️ “A Salty Shanty at Peacemaker Lobster Shack” ☠️
Arrr, me hearties, I set sail fer Peacemaker in Soulard, A lobster shack so fine it caught me off guard. The food be grand, aye, fit fer a king, But salty as the ocean—by thunder, that sting! 🌊🦞
The bartender, bless ’em, a star at the bar, Pourin’ grog and rum like a true buccaneer star. Attentive, quick, with a wink in his eye, Kept me tankard full ‘til the tide ran dry. 🍺⚓️
The atmosphere’s dreamy, fer romance on shore, A place fer yer sweetheart, or a lass ye adore. Ye’ll dine by lanterns, with love in the air, But beware o’ the salt—it lurks everywhere! 💘🧂
So if ye be seekin’ a fine night away, With seafood and charm at the end o’ the bay, Hoist up yer sails and give Peacemaker a try, Four stars I be givin’, with a salty sigh. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Yarrr… bring a parrot and maybe some fresh water. 🦜💦
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mina Zamanpour
I just visited the Peacemaker restaurant. I liked the live atmosphere there. I ordered a hamburger with double patties. I asked them to remove the cheese as I don't eat greecy food. I didn't like my food as it was oily. The chips were salty and too much pepper on it. I had to share my food with my father. I think this place is good for drinking, not eating food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
John Shadley
Amazing seafood,shellfish, and oysters. Lobster Mac n cheese is a meal itself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sushma Kola
Peacemaker Lobster & Crab is an absolute gem! The portions are solid—definitely satisfying without leaving you hungry. The food is straight-up delicious, with every bite packed with fresh, bold flavors. Their lobster rolls? Absolute perfection and my go-to every single time! Buttery, loaded with tender lobster, and just the right amount of seasoning—they’re a total dream. If you’re a seafood lover, Peacemaker is a must-visit spot that’ll leave you hooked!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Mullins
Terrible service by the waitress on two occasions and the food is extremely pricey for Average seafood at best.
We had a table reserved and arrived a few minutes early. The place was packed but they immediately seated us and were very attentive. We were quickly waited on, drinks showed up, order taken and food was on our table very timely. Friendly staff, excellent food and great prices. We could not have had a better experience. I highly recommend!
Yania Rivero
My kid ordered Grilled Cheese and after 30 minutes was not delivered yet! Even cooked it!! My plate was on my table, of course, after 30 minutes but not the best taste, the food comes with a lot of spices and hot flavor and the menu never mentioned it. The server was nice but the only thing I wanted was eating and it was terrible.
Beth Jacob
I really wanted to like this place because I love seafood and it was on our bucket list. It was very underwhelming and very pricey for meal. The home chips I felt were super hard and stale. The hush puppies didn’t taste right. The oil they must have used was old and they really didn’t have good flavor, just doughy. The only redeeming thing was the cashier at the beginning, she was super nice. But food was not good and I would not recommend this place to anyone. We will not be back.
Aaron Doss
First time visiting and everything was delicious! My wife said it was the most lobster she ever had on a lobster roll. The shrimp Po Boy was fantastic and the lobster bisque and clam chowder along with the homemade chips were great. Everything was fresh not frozen. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Porsha Key
The food and service are always amazing.
They have the best assortment of half shell oysters in town. Their lobster roll is unmatched. We also enjoy their crab legs; they are always super fresh.
The fresh seafood combined with the photography on the walls really adds to the ambiance and makes it feel special. Almost like you're on the East Coast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Connecticut and Maine Lobster Roll, Oysters on the Half Shell, King Crab, Gumbo, Crab Legs
We love this restaurant! The cocktails were delicious! I had lobster bisque and my husband had clam chowder - both were wonderful! My husband had a buttery lobster roll while I had the summer wedge salad - did not disappoint!! My husband loved the peel & eat shrimp and we shared hush puppies - again, delicious! We’ve never been disappointed at this place! And Jacob our server - wow! He was awesome!! The nicest guy! He was so busy but he always made sure we had what we needed! A+ Peacemaker! (Oh and I LOVE the atmosphere!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
It was way too overpriced for what you got and it was not anything to waste that kind of of money on
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Great happy hour specials! Fresh tasty oysters. Lobster rolls were amazing. Second round of eating-great gumbo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Man this was the bommmb the poorboy shirmp hit the spot great service from Erika .B at #stlairport # gotta try this food won’t be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
the french fries were good, and the roll itself was nice but the lobster itself and the service left more to be desired. the lobster was unseasoned - i expected more butter or flavoring but maybe thats my curse as a girlie who lived in new orleans for years. eben though i orderef it warm, the lobster felt kinda lukewarm… i also dislike sitting myself down, going up to a counter/using qr code to order and then you having the gall to ask for a tip? before ive even gotten the food? i don’t even like tipping before my item for coffee, never mind for a sit down restaurant with expensive sandwiches. it wasnt awful, but i do find it grossly ovepriced and dont plan to return.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
☠️ “A Salty Shanty at Peacemaker Lobster Shack” ☠️
Arrr, me hearties, I set sail fer Peacemaker in Soulard,
A lobster shack so fine it caught me off guard.
The food be grand, aye, fit fer a king,
But salty as the ocean—by thunder, that sting! 🌊🦞
The bartender, bless ’em, a star at the bar,
Pourin’ grog and rum like a true buccaneer star.
Attentive, quick, with a wink in his eye,
Kept me tankard full ‘til the tide ran dry. 🍺⚓️
The atmosphere’s dreamy, fer romance on shore,
A place fer yer sweetheart, or a lass ye adore.
Ye’ll dine by lanterns, with love in the air,
But beware o’ the salt—it lurks everywhere! 💘🧂
So if ye be seekin’ a fine night away,
With seafood and charm at the end o’ the bay,
Hoist up yer sails and give Peacemaker a try,
Four stars I be givin’, with a salty sigh. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Yarrr… bring a parrot and maybe some fresh water. 🦜💦
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I just visited the Peacemaker restaurant. I liked the live atmosphere there. I ordered a hamburger with double patties. I asked them to remove the cheese as I don't eat greecy food. I didn't like my food as it was oily. The chips were salty and too much pepper on it. I had to share my food with my father. I think this place is good for drinking, not eating food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Amazing seafood,shellfish, and oysters. Lobster Mac n cheese is a meal itself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peacemaker Lobster & Crab is an absolute gem! The portions are solid—definitely satisfying without leaving you hungry. The food is straight-up delicious, with every bite packed with fresh, bold flavors. Their lobster rolls? Absolute perfection and my go-to every single time! Buttery, loaded with tender lobster, and just the right amount of seasoning—they’re a total dream. If you’re a seafood lover, Peacemaker is a must-visit spot that’ll leave you hooked!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible service by the waitress on two occasions and the food is extremely pricey for Average seafood at best.
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a table reserved and arrived a few minutes early. The place was packed but they immediately seated us and were very attentive. We were quickly waited on, drinks showed up, order taken and food was on our table very timely. Friendly staff, excellent food and great prices. We could not have had a better experience. I highly recommend!
My kid ordered Grilled Cheese and after 30 minutes was not delivered yet! Even cooked it!! My plate was on my table, of course, after 30 minutes but not the best taste, the food comes with a lot of spices and hot flavor and the menu never mentioned it. The server was nice but the only thing I wanted was eating and it was terrible.
I really wanted to like this place because I love seafood and it was on our bucket list. It was very underwhelming and very pricey for meal. The home chips I felt were super hard and stale. The hush puppies didn’t taste right. The oil they must have used was old and they really didn’t have good flavor, just doughy. The only redeeming thing was the cashier at the beginning, she was super nice. But food was not good and I would not recommend this place to anyone. We will not be back.
First time visiting and everything was delicious! My wife said it was the most lobster she ever had on a lobster roll. The shrimp Po Boy was fantastic and the lobster bisque and clam chowder along with the homemade chips were great. Everything was fresh not frozen. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service are always amazing.
They have the best assortment of half shell oysters in town. Their lobster roll is unmatched. We also enjoy their crab legs; they are always super fresh.
The fresh seafood combined with the photography on the walls really adds to the ambiance and makes it feel special. Almost like you're on the East Coast.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Connecticut and Maine Lobster Roll, Oysters on the Half Shell, King Crab, Gumbo, Crab Legs
Loading...