Best pizza ive ever had my husband and I love going here to get our favorite pepperoni and roasted garlic with a salad.
My only criticism stems from the fact that they are never open. Ive tried so many times to get my favorite pizza and today being my only day off ive planned everything with rewarding myself and husband with our favorite pie. So I drove and after the gym and the doors are locked, ive called, and tried to order online and nothing worked. This is not the first time this has been our experience.
I understand that they are going through a hard time so I give you all the grace I can muster. Being loyal a loyal customer I would love to support you and the business. I would hate for such a wonderful business to disappear but I need a little help in that support. Please give me, if you can, the operating hours so me and every one of my friends, that I won't shut up to when discussing pizza, can come and experience the greatness of your business.
Thanks and I hope to see you soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua D
I’m torn because this place truly has amazing pizza, but the business operations are a total mess. We tried to order for pickup after a SLU game on the 7th. The online ordering process is confusing with too many redundant platforms, and the wait times are extreme—even 5 minutes after opening, the 'custom' wait was 90 minutes.
We settled for a 'standard' topping order to get it in 45 minutes. Despite receiving a text saying it was ready, I went inside to find an employee goofing off with a friend. He hadn't checked for the order, couldn't find it, and then couldn't find his phone to look it up. When I asked for a refund, he couldn't find his phone for that either, nor a pen and paper to take my name.
We used to love getting this at City SC games until they stopped showing up there. Great pizza isn't worth this level of unprofessionalism. Hard to justify going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Neha Sutariya
I loved the atmosphere, and the staff were very nice. I had the cheese pizza slice and the garlic knots, and I can confidently say everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michael
Best New York slice in STL. Fair prices, kind staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
June Roach
Hey 👋🏾 give yourself a treat and stop by for a slice! Have a sip! Wet your lip!! The vibes are extra awesome when it’s event night with local vendors showing off their new creations.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Tia
No vegan pizza when I stopped by.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Paige Campbell
very rude bartender. thanks for the nasty pizza. I’ll eat it because I’m hungry and a little out of it. otherwise i wouldn’t recommend. at least be a little nice. that’s why ur filter is migrating girl.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Greg James
Best Pizza I’ve had in had, lived in Vegas, LA, Tampa. Missouri might not offer much exciting but this Pie Guy joint will be one I miss when I move! Great everything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alice Jones
I attended the grovefest last night and decided to grab pizza just like last year but left disappointed. I'm disappointed with paying 10 dollars FOR ONE SLICE OF PIZZA! I just sat in disbelief and couldn't imagine myself paying 20 dollars for two slices of pizza! Ridiculous
Unfortunately, this place has gone down hill. Used to be my favorite pizza restaurant, but now it is nearly impossible to place an order online or over the phone. Online ordering is disabled every time I check (been trying several weekends in a row in case it was a fluke) and no one picks up the phone when I call. Very dissapointing
Fiona S
This weekend was a weekend to remember at this establishment. The atmosphere here felt tense and unprofessional. While one bartender was clearly doing the bulk of the work to keep service moving, another kept snapping at them and making petty comments — even in front of customers. At one point, I was directly spoken to about their coworker in a negative way, which was shocking. I have never in my life had a bartender talk badly about another staff member to me while I was being served.
It was uncomfortable and embarrassing as a guest, and it took away from the experience completely. Management needs to address this, because the only reason service held together that night was the effort of the bartender actually working, not the one creating drama.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
Evan Anderson
We love the bartender narada fr! He made our experience here so much fun. Whoever was cooking the pizza this night burnt it tho. Was not boots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Terry Tatum
The sign says they serve pizza until 1am but the cook refused to make a vegan slice or pizza at 7:50pm on a Saturday!!!!! We drove a long way just to buy the vegan pizza “that’s on the menu” and to be met with that response is ridiculous! It’s bad enough that there aren’t a lot of vegan options in the city but to not serve your full menu at 7:50pm may not be the best way to do business.
Pie Guy is our favorite pizza in St Louis.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza ive ever had my husband and I love going here to get our favorite pepperoni and roasted garlic with a salad.
My only criticism stems from the fact that they are never open. Ive tried so many times to get my favorite pizza and today being my only day off ive planned everything with rewarding myself and husband with our favorite pie. So I drove and after the gym and the doors are locked, ive called, and tried to order online and nothing worked. This is not the first time this has been our experience.
I understand that they are going through a hard time so I give you all the grace I can muster. Being loyal a loyal customer I would love to support you and the business. I would hate for such a wonderful business to disappear but I need a little help in that support. Please give me, if you can, the operating hours so me and every one of my friends, that I won't shut up to when discussing pizza, can come and experience the greatness of your business.
Thanks and I hope to see you soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m torn because this place truly has amazing pizza, but the business operations are a total mess. We tried to order for pickup after a SLU game on the 7th. The online ordering process is confusing with too many redundant platforms, and the wait times are extreme—even 5 minutes after opening, the 'custom' wait was 90 minutes.
We settled for a 'standard' topping order to get it in 45 minutes. Despite receiving a text saying it was ready, I went inside to find an employee goofing off with a friend. He hadn't checked for the order, couldn't find it, and then couldn't find his phone to look it up. When I asked for a refund, he couldn't find his phone for that either, nor a pen and paper to take my name.
We used to love getting this at City SC games until they stopped showing up there. Great pizza isn't worth this level of unprofessionalism. Hard to justify going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
I loved the atmosphere, and the staff were very nice. I had the cheese pizza slice and the garlic knots, and I can confidently say everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best New York slice in STL. Fair prices, kind staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hey 👋🏾 give yourself a treat and stop by for a slice! Have a sip! Wet your lip!! The vibes are extra awesome when it’s event night with local vendors showing off their new creations.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
No vegan pizza when I stopped by.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
very rude bartender. thanks for the nasty pizza. I’ll eat it because I’m hungry and a little out of it. otherwise i wouldn’t recommend. at least be a little nice. that’s why ur filter is migrating girl.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Best Pizza I’ve had in had, lived in Vegas, LA, Tampa. Missouri might not offer much exciting but this Pie Guy joint will be one I miss when I move! Great everything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I attended the grovefest last night and decided to grab pizza just like last year but left disappointed. I'm disappointed with paying 10 dollars FOR ONE SLICE OF PIZZA! I just sat in disbelief and couldn't imagine myself paying 20 dollars for two slices of pizza! Ridiculous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was slow and pizza was alright
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Unfortunately, this place has gone down hill. Used to be my favorite pizza restaurant, but now it is nearly impossible to place an order online or over the phone. Online ordering is disabled every time I check (been trying several weekends in a row in case it was a fluke) and no one picks up the phone when I call. Very dissapointing
This weekend was a weekend to remember at this establishment. The atmosphere here felt tense and unprofessional. While one bartender was clearly doing the bulk of the work to keep service moving, another kept snapping at them and making petty comments — even in front of customers. At one point, I was directly spoken to about their coworker in a negative way, which was shocking. I have never in my life had a bartender talk badly about another staff member to me while I was being served.
It was uncomfortable and embarrassing as a guest, and it took away from the experience completely. Management needs to address this, because the only reason service held together that night was the effort of the bartender actually working, not the one creating drama.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 5
We love the bartender narada fr! He made our experience here so much fun. Whoever was cooking the pizza this night burnt it tho. Was not boots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
The sign says they serve pizza until 1am but the cook refused to make a vegan slice or pizza at 7:50pm on a Saturday!!!!! We drove a long way just to buy the vegan pizza “that’s on the menu” and to be met with that response is ridiculous! It’s bad enough that there aren’t a lot of vegan options in the city but to not serve your full menu at 7:50pm may not be the best way to do business.
Service: 1
Loading...