I went to Pizzeoli last night with a group of friends and had an amazing dining experience. We started off with the Deep Fried Chanterelles and Chili-kissed Garlic Knots - the chantrellles were delicious and came with a chili ranch sauce that I would love bottled for home use. The garlic knots were a cut above your normal pizza place fare - melted in my mouth and garlic to butter proportions were perfectly balanced.
It should be noted that their drink menu is extensive (along with their pizza menu - so many great options!). I chose the Athletic Cerveza - a great Non-alcoholic beer that ranks as a personal fav. I also like that Pizzeoli had multiple NA options as a non-drinker.
On to the main course - my group chose the Andy (a current special with white sauce and mushrooms), the Lumberjack Snack (pep and bacon on red sauce) and the Meatball pizza (as recommended per their chef - meatballs on white sauce!). All three were delicious and cooked to perfection - the right amount of bubbles in the perfectly thin curst. I kept trying to choose a favorite and couldn't decide - would personally recommend a white sauce pizza but the red was also awesome!
The grand finale was a banana split dessert pizza and ice cream sandwiches. A hot dessert pizza with the perfect cool toppings, I'd stop in just for an after meal treat some time. The ice cream sandwiches were delectable and fun to share with the table too.
The atmosphere of Pizzeoli transported me to a simpler time when going to a neighborhood pizza place meant a friendly staff, unique decorations (check out the light shades over the tables!) and quality craftsmanship.
A new favorite - highly recommend!
Theresa McIntyre
It’s so refreshing to eat such quality ingredients that are safe and healthy! Best chicken wings I’ve ever had and the fresh flavors of all the homemeade pizza toppings are to die for! Oh, and the affaogato is a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Habanero Wings
Brian McIntyre
Hands down the best wings we’ve ever had. The service is second to none. Incredible food and drinks. This is a home run spot, and we will be back many many times! This establishment also does not use SEED OILS, a huge plus in my book! Real food, real ingredients, keep up the excellent work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Wings
Jakki Mann
Our air bnb host recoomend Pizzeoli for dinner and we are so glad she did! The food, service and atmosphere was fantastic and it was a perfect way to end our weekend stay in the historic Soulard Neigbhourhood. It will be our first stop next time we visit St Louis!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Ivy
Awesome atmosphere. Great beer, outstanding wings, and delicious pizza. Wings fried in tallow are a must have recommend the flight sauces as they are all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Wm Spencer
We had an incredible meal with great service and atmosphere! Highly recommend the sweet chili wings! Be prepared to park a ways away but it’s absolutely worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chili-Kissed Garlic Knots, Wings, Napoli Pizza
Marco Tamayo
Amazing! Best pizza in Saint Louis! Outstanding staff! The staff is always moving and on a mission to keep customers to the top of satisfaction.
JR Arostegui
We were visiting from Nashville and couldn't have been happier with our experience at Pizzeoli. The atmosphere is great, the staff is friendly and the food is perfection. My wife is gluten-free and has never found gluten-free pizza crust to be very good, but Pizzeoli's was superb. I ate her leftovers and couldn't even tell it was gluten-free. This will be a staple for all future STL visits!
ABRIEAN THOMAS
Let me start by saing the customer service was ok, he never came back to check on us but let me get into the food geesh omg it was horrible 1st the chicken came out full of oil. It was so much oil we couldn’t taste the flavor in the chicken. 2nd the pizza came out cold & i seen my pizza sitting there but i didn’t think it as mine because i just knew they wouldn’t leave my pizza sitting there that long to where it would be cold asf whn it came out. Im goin. To say this if u want pizza jus order from imos, dominoes, papa John, or any other food place but this place bc it is not good at all. I dnt leav reviews but i had too bc the customer service was ok & the food was horrible.
Kaime Stuart
I recommend the pineapple habanero wings and the golf cart pizza!
Our experience is great every time we drive through St. Louis, we stop here! Sees oil free, organic options, and delicious food!
We are happy with every aspect of our experience at Pizzeoli, but we are particularly pleased with how great our bartender, Daniel. His service is top notch, and he deserves a raise! Thank you, Daniel!
We will be sure to come back in and see you guys again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Mr. Mediocre
Here from out of state for a quick stay and decided on pizza. Read a ton of good reviews on this place and I just hope this was an off day. A pizza(thin but floppy), wings (consistency of tyson microwaveable) and breaded cheese balls( absolutely come in frozen). Just shy of $70. In Indiana we call this Little Caesars and it would have been $25. I truly hope this was just an off night and this isnt the normal quality because it was honestly luke warm garbage. The family and myself are disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
AWM
5+ stars! All of the positive reviews are accurate. Great wood fired pizza (we had the Nappoli and Golf Cart), great service (we sat at the bar), and great environment (vibrant but comfortable). There was a wait, but well worth it. Special place. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Timothy Wilson
Excellent wood fired pizza with great crust and ingredients. Friendly staff and nice romantic atmosphere. Will be back for seconds!
I went to Pizzeoli last night with a group of friends and had an amazing dining experience. We started off with the Deep Fried Chanterelles and Chili-kissed Garlic Knots - the chantrellles were delicious and came with a chili ranch sauce that I would love bottled for home use. The garlic knots were a cut above your normal pizza place fare - melted in my mouth and garlic to butter proportions were perfectly balanced. It should be noted that their drink menu is extensive (along with their pizza menu - so many great options!). I chose the Athletic Cerveza - a great Non-alcoholic beer that ranks as a personal fav. I also like that Pizzeoli had multiple NA options as a non-drinker. On to the main course - my group chose the Andy (a current special with white sauce and mushrooms), the Lumberjack Snack (pep and bacon on red sauce) and the Meatball pizza (as recommended per their chef - meatballs on white sauce!). All three were delicious and cooked to perfection - the right amount of bubbles in the perfectly thin curst. I kept trying to choose a favorite and couldn't decide - would personally recommend a white sauce pizza but the red was also awesome! The grand finale was a banana split dessert pizza and ice cream sandwiches. A hot dessert pizza with the perfect cool toppings, I'd stop in just for an after meal treat some time. The ice cream sandwiches were delectable and fun to share with the table too. The atmosphere of Pizzeoli transported me to a simpler time when going to a neighborhood pizza place meant a friendly staff, unique decorations (check out the light shades over the tables!) and quality craftsmanship. A new favorite - highly recommend!
It’s so refreshing to eat such quality ingredients that are safe and healthy! Best chicken wings I’ve ever had and the fresh flavors of all the homemeade pizza toppings are to die for! Oh, and the affaogato is a must!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Habanero Wings
Hands down the best wings we’ve ever had. The service is second to none. Incredible food and drinks. This is a home run spot, and we will be back many many times! This establishment also does not use SEED OILS, a huge plus in my book! Real food, real ingredients, keep up the excellent work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Wings
Our air bnb host recoomend Pizzeoli for dinner and we are so glad she did! The food, service and atmosphere was fantastic and it was a perfect way to end our weekend stay in the historic Soulard Neigbhourhood. It will be our first stop next time we visit St Louis!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome atmosphere. Great beer, outstanding wings, and delicious pizza. Wings fried in tallow are a must have recommend the flight sauces as they are all good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
We had an incredible meal with great service and atmosphere! Highly recommend the sweet chili wings! Be prepared to park a ways away but it’s absolutely worth it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chili-Kissed Garlic Knots, Wings, Napoli Pizza
Amazing! Best pizza in Saint Louis! Outstanding staff! The staff is always moving and on a mission to keep customers to the top of satisfaction.
We were visiting from Nashville and couldn't have been happier with our experience at Pizzeoli. The atmosphere is great, the staff is friendly and the food is perfection. My wife is gluten-free and has never found gluten-free pizza crust to be very good, but Pizzeoli's was superb. I ate her leftovers and couldn't even tell it was gluten-free. This will be a staple for all future STL visits!
Let me start by saing the customer service was ok, he never came back to check on us but let me get into the food geesh omg it was horrible 1st the chicken came out full of oil. It was so much oil we couldn’t taste the flavor in the chicken. 2nd the pizza came out cold & i seen my pizza sitting there but i didn’t think it as mine because i just knew they wouldn’t leave my pizza sitting there that long to where it would be cold asf whn it came out. Im goin. To say this if u want pizza jus order from imos, dominoes, papa John, or any other food place but this place bc it is not good at all. I dnt leav reviews but i had too bc the customer service was ok & the food was horrible.
I recommend the pineapple habanero wings and the golf cart pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Easily our favorite pizza place in St. Louis.
Our experience is great every time we drive through St. Louis, we stop here! Sees oil free, organic options, and delicious food!
We are happy with every aspect of our experience at Pizzeoli, but we are particularly pleased with how great our bartender, Daniel. His service is top notch, and he deserves a raise! Thank you, Daniel!
We will be sure to come back in and see you guys again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Here from out of state for a quick stay and decided on pizza. Read a ton of good reviews on this place and I just hope this was an off day. A pizza(thin but floppy), wings (consistency of tyson microwaveable) and breaded cheese balls( absolutely come in frozen). Just shy of $70. In Indiana we call this Little Caesars and it would have been $25. I truly hope this was just an off night and this isnt the normal quality because it was honestly luke warm garbage. The family and myself are disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
5+ stars! All of the positive reviews are accurate. Great wood fired pizza (we had the Nappoli and Golf Cart), great service (we sat at the bar), and great environment (vibrant but comfortable). There was a wait, but well worth it. Special place. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent wood fired pizza with great crust and ingredients. Friendly staff and nice romantic atmosphere. Will be back for seconds!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...