Pizzeria Tivoli

5861 S Kingshighway Blvd, St. Louis
(314) 832-3222

Recent Reviews

Shannon Headley

This was our first visit and I was disappointed. The pizza was soggy. The server didn’t write down my husband’s order so he didn’t get his pizza. She never came back so we couldn’t tell her we didn’t get it. By the time she came to the table we were done eating. There were only 2 tables so it wasn’t busy. The salad was good.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Susie Jan

Used to be a regular but things have slipped for past few yrs. Last week I ordered a pizza from here that has arugula and it was served with mixed greens on it instead. Not worth it, so many other great places to eat in stl.Vegetarian options: No vegan options, and veg options are not marked as such on menu.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Nick G.

DO NOT ORDER FROM THEIR WEBSITE. They claim to not have a website, but you'll still get charged. I ordered on their website ( and I got a text message that said I'd get an email when the order was accepted. After 20 minutes, I never got an email, not even in junk folder. I called them to ask about my order, in broken English, they told me they don't even have a website. I looked at my credit card account and the charge was already on there. I drove to the restaurant and again, they told me they don't have a website. Sitting on their soda machine behind the bar, right when you walk in, there is a table card with their web address advertising online ordering. They wouldn't do anything so I demanded to talk to the manager. They finally called him, after speaking Spanish to him, they made me talk to him. He told me he didn't get any online orders. I told him the stupid card advertising their site an online ordering was right there in the restaurant. I mentioned it saying "powered by Ordello" or something and hes like "Oh! Yeah we have that. What did you order? We will make your pizzas now." I said that I don't want the stupid pizzas anymore, I just want my money back. He told me he never got an email for my order so he cant refund me. He told me to talk to Ordello. I was like "How is that on me? It was on YOUR website!" He said he'd look into it and call me back. He asked for my name and number. He never called me back. Now I'm trying to deal with Ordello. If that doesn't work I'll dispute it with my credit card company. This place sucks and I will absolutely never go back.

Meredith R.

This place is a hidden gem! According to the owners they literally flew in their pizza oven from Italy and I believe it! They have wonderful pizza! Easily some of the best pizza in STL, and that is coming from a pizza lover!

Bryan DiMarco

The pizza is usually burnt and the outside music is riddled with way too loud ads, quite

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Suzanne Chisum

Nice dining experience. Pizza was good. Parking is street parking.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Suzane C.

Pizza was good. I intend on ordering the Mediterranean pizza next time. We had a delightful waiter who made sure we were well cared for. Casual vibe. Street parking.

Rachel Tate

Been wanting to try them for a while. I always think it looks so cute when I drive by, but I don't drive by there too often. Decided to stop and have dinner the other night and the pizza was great! If you like wood fire style pizza, this is a must try. Server was delightful as well and very reasonably priced!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nick Wheeler

The food was pretty good. The antipasto charcuterie board could have come out of a microwaved lunchables tray, but the bread was toasted and tasty. The pizza certainly wasn’t the best I’ve had in St. Louis, but it was average for a neopolitan style. Service was slow, and, as other reviewers have mentioned, they run out of beers on their drink menu, which is frustrating. Overall, a decidedly average experience.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ryan Garber

Amazing small neighborhood restaurant, very friendly staff

K M

pizzas were great - their beverage selection isn't being restocked... second time there and they haven't had the first 3 selections (wine or beer) we order... you make a lot of $ on alcohol sales ! ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Quattro Formaggi

L Nelson

Ordered online through the Slice app, since it was “preferred by the business.” One hour later, I called to check on the status of the order. After verifying what I ordered THREE times (setting the phone down on the counter several times in between), the woman still could not tell me if the food was made, or if it had been picked up. I asked to speak to someone else (hoping that it was a language barrier); she hung up on me. I called again and asked to speak to a manager. She said “ok” and set the phone down for approx four minutes (talking to people in the background) before I gave up and hung up. Currently trying to get my money refunded, but of course now they’re closed ……?‍♂️

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brittney Nast

Horrible experience. Would prefer to give less than one star. Called to verify if food had been picked up since they have delivery time up to 33 minutes. Gave and hour before calling to check, was hung up on several times. Lost $60.00.. wanted to support local business... but not with service like

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brittney Lauren

ordered food. it was over 1 hour late. called to o ly check on status. was hung up on 7 times. lost $60. tried to support local business.. won't do that for this place agin

Latrice Collins

Not friendly to the neighbors. Refused to sell ice to a little girl. She was told they don’t have ice lol. No designated customer parking. Overfilled dumpsters. O yeah pizza is not good watery cheese.

Load More