Paisano's 2nd Street Pizza

The pizza is amazing! Definitely recommend

We just returned from a trip to Italy and thought we would have to give up pizza in America. We found Paisanos in Whitefish and decided to try. Turns out they make everything from scratch including their sausage and red sauce. There is a vertical hydroponic basil garden as you enter, which is a nice welcome. It is clean, friendly and delicioso!

I tried the pizza with the new owners not quite the same New York style pizza that was there before. So they had Chicago beef sandwiches thought maybe there's a place I can go for those but but ordered a hot wet Chicago beef was asked whether I want it sweet peppers and said no and I got Chicago beef with only sweet peppers. Also, was asked if i wanted the sauce on side but I had to explain that wet meant on the sandwich which is on the menu. Unfortunately I took it to go so didn't know that until I was miles down the road don't know what else I could do to be clear on ordering so I guess I'll mark this one off my list. On a side note the owners seemed like pleasant people.

Always has amazing customer service! The cheese blend is amazing. This pizza is substantially built with quality ingredients, we always order two so we can have left overs. I also love that you can order half-baked.

We were on vacation to Glacier and decided to spend a day in Whitefish. My husband had a hankering for pizza and googled what pizza places were around in Whitefish. Thank heaven he decided on Paisano's! Absolutely THE BEST pizza we have ever had. And the staff and atmosphere were great as well! Wish we had one closer here in Washington!

This was the best pizza ever. I spoke to the owners who said everything is made from scratch. They were extremely sweet. Oh and did I say it was the best pizza ever!!! We will definitely eat here again.

Love this place! The pizza is authentic and full of quality. You can grab a quick bite or stay for awhile…The pictures around the place tell a story, and the environment is casual and welcoming. The owners personally greet and serve their guests. Try it! You won’t be disappointed

We had car trouble and had to wait for a tow and lyft while returning from Waterton Side of Glacier National Park. This restaurant was open and made a wonderful pizza for us to wait for our ride and to grab an excellent dinner. The staff was so nice and let us stay until after they closed as they were doing a catered event after the store closed.

Great Sicilian Pizza……haven’t had one in a long time! Highly recommend. Also, yes they have remodeled the inside since taking over the business from 2nd Street Pizza, but the atmosphere is great. The seating is much better than the old dining area. Hats off to the new owners, we will be back!

Great ingredients, prepared well.Pizza by the slice is available, or full pizzas.Pepsi products.Service is a little casual or unorganized, but still super helpful and cordial and friendly. (Addendum: these post-COVID days during non-peak season, one should be understanding of businesses hiring and training--no prob! Hence 5 stars)

Remodel is beautiful and the food was delicious always. We got pepperoni pizza and garlic knots and we decided to take an order of knots home for a late night snack. Prices are incredibly reasonable too which is rare to find right now. Whether your local or visiting, it's a great food option. When you stop in, don't forget to leave them a review to let them know how great they're doing and help support local businesses!

The remodel looks great and offers more dining space than the original set up which is awesome! The staff is also very friendly and helpful. We ordered a few pizzas here on several occasions to give it a try, unfortunately each time they were all very salty, covered in Italian seasonings, and had very little toppings for the price you pay for them.It's hard to compare this place to the old 2nd street we knew and loved, so we likely won't be ordering from here again.Worth trying out though as we all have different pizza preferences :)

Came to town for work so I asked the hotel attendant for the best pizza place she sent me to paisano’s. Barb waited on me and was happy that I wanted to dine in. She shared her family’s history from the photos on the wall. I almost felt like I was sitting at her family table making small talk. The pizza and garlic balls were amazing. I will be back there every time I come to Whitefish.

Really good New York style pizza. New owners just bought Second Street Pizza and added Paisano’s to the name. They’re making their own sausage with locally sourced pork and the attention to detail, getting the crust and the sauce just right and then using quality toppings makes for some of the best pizza in Montana. It’s hard to find such good pizza and these folks know what they’re doing! We can’t wait to try more!

Amazing NY style pizza! The closest thing we’ve found to NY pizza west of NJ. The Sicilian is awesome with fresh basil and the plain cheese is perfection right out of the oven. Happy to live in the neighborhood because this is becoming one of our mid-week and weekend go-to stops!