Bella's New York Pizza
$ • Pizza, VegetarianAbout Bella's New York Pizza
Customers' Favorites
White Pizza with Mushrooms
Philly Cheese Steak Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Turkey Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
All Meat Pizza
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm
Absolutely
Stromboli
Bella's New York Pizza Reviews
WOW! I called and asked for a steak and cheese sandwich ( no peppers or onions bc my wife won’t eat it that way). I asked for American cheese and if the young lady taking my order would ask them to sautee it with the steak and mix in in. She said oh yes we always do that. I said perfect!
Let me tell you. I gave my wife half of my steak n cheese and I wish I had gotten her her own!
Best steak n cheese sandwich we have had since moving here in May 2025. And we have had...read full review
Let me tell you. I gave my wife half of my steak n cheese and I wish I had gotten her her own!
Best steak n cheese sandwich we have had since moving here in May 2025. And we have had...read full review
This place is nice but I made an order and they only got a half right. I ordered a pizza and a sub and I told her three times what type of pizza I wanted I still only got the sub. Feel sorry for the manager or the owner
., who just lost about $20
., who just lost about $20
Food was super fresh and tasted just like home NY that is they did great!
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
Bella's New York Pizza is a small, clean restaurant located in a strip mall in Calabash. It offers authentic New York-style pizza that many customers find very good and filling. The pizza, including popular items like the Soprano pizza and garlic knots, is praised for its fresh ingredients and great flavor. Customers especially enjoy the soft garlic knots with marinara sauce and the generous, satisfying slices. The staff is generally friendly and welcoming, making guests feel at home, and the service is often appreciated. The proprietor is described as hardworking and attractive, contributing to a positive atmosphere.
Recent reviews highlight that the pepperoni and cheese specials come out super quick and super fresh, with a thin crispy crust that is not too greasy. The steak n cheese sandwich is also noted as very good, made with the right way on a roll. While most reviews are positive, there are some concerns about the service, with a few customers mentioning rude behavior from certain staff members or orders being incorrect. Overall, Bella's New York Pizza is considered the best NY pizza in Calabash and the surrounding strand, and many plan to return. Despite some minor issues, the restaurant remains a favorite for those craving authentic, delicious pizza close to home.