Sauce is evenly distributed, great topping proportions, this pizza was amazing. Give me more, give me more.
Emma B.
I work right across the street and the first time I wanted to order for me and my co workers the guy was so rude on the phone we went to Mellow mushroom instead. Today we called and he was rude again but we really wanted to try the white pizza so we ordered. When I went to pick it up, same thing. Just rude. The food is average but the service definitely is what is lacking. And for the place to only have one table occupied, you would think they would want more business. But ya win some ya lose some. Way too many good pizza places to put up with that.
P H.
Went here twice. The first time was a fours star and the next time I went back, 5 months later, there was a whole new staff and the pizza went from "not too bad" to "did they get this from Jet Pizza?" The guys I originally met there were actually from NYC (Jamaica Queens specifically) and the pizza was ok. It can only be so good when you leave NYC. I'm a snob, take it for what it's worth. The water is different here and some ingredients are much more difficult to get here. The pizza I ate last weekend was not good. It was like something you would get at a stadium or a bad franchise. It was almost like it was cooked in a machine. If that wasn't bad enough, it was expensive. I think I paid about $35 for a large pie, a 2 liter of soda, and a "Greek" salad (hint: it was the farthest thing from). The guys there seem nice, although not all that personable, but they need to make some serious adjustments or this place will not be around much longer.
Colette S.
Terrible. $9.00 for a hero that each was burnt. Bought three!!!! Had to cut off all the ends. Spent $40.00 and we're still hungry. Never again. Calzone not so bad
Jay K.
Surprised with the low scores I'm seeing here. I first came across this pizza via their food truck which happened to be at the Easter egg hunt at Bond Park. I was starved, energy depleted from the chaos that ensued from the egg hunting activities, but even the steep $5 price for a slice did not dissuade me from my search for the best slice this town has to offer. As an original New Yorker it has been really tough to find a great slice. But not on this day. When I least expected it my taste buds were treated to flavors that were missing for far too long. It was almost a religious experience I kid you not. Months went by. Life gets busy. Finally made it out to their establishment proper and was greeted with the same taste of NY that I was craving. The decor is nothing fancy but what will keep me coming back again and again is the pizza itself. Already looking forward to my next visit.
Andrea McLelland
Awesome NY style pizza, ravioli, and pasta! We eat here at least once a week and they offer free delivery!
Curtis R.
Complete garbage, my daughter's paid $5 per slice for 2 slices of pizza from their Food Truck in Wake Forest. After taking a few bites they complained how burnt the crust was. The bottom was completely black. I took the slices back to show the truck and they simply said sorry. No offer to refund me or the 3/4 full slices. They did offer to give another slice, but who wants to eat that after having the burnt taste in your mouth?? What a joke, not a respectable business....stay away
Melanie Hampton
Awesome pizza, very quaint little place. We are out of town on work but felt right at home having dinner here. Friendly and efficient staff.
Joe L
I have been going to this place for about 4 years. They used to be really good but I have noticed a steady decline in the quality of food and service over the last year. I'm not sure if ownership has changed hands or not but I have finally given up on this place. The final straw was after my last order which was a takeout for an eggplant parm sub and baked ziti. When I got home I found that the sandwich was burned so bad on the ends I couldn't eat it and the tray of baked ziti was only half full. When I called about it the owner, who was seriously lacking in communication skills, told me oops that was a mistake. He offered to redo the order but at my inconvenience of driving back out there to get it. How it could be a mistake to half fill a tray is beyond me. Would the cook make half a pizza and not notice? Steer clear of this place it is not worth it.
Bobby Paine
Amazing NY style pizza by the slice or pie. The other food on the menu is great as well. One of my favs is the philly cheese steak and the French fries aren't some crappy ones, they're seasoned and taste great. Be careful in later afternoon though if you're looking for just a slice as they usually sell out during lunch so you'll need to get a pie if they sold out of slices with their 5.99 lunch special. Overall very authentic NY style pizzeria
This is a great place for pizza. Delivery is quick and we have only had 1 incident , in 3 years, where our order was messed up and they were quick to fix it. They get super busy on the weekends so be patient if you call and it rings busy...there is a good reason why that happens sometimes.
Carol Houle
First rime in. Had two appetizers delicious. The calzones were amazing! The staff was friendly and efficient. Definately going back.
Rachel G.
Of all the NY style pizza joints in Cary, they are the most consistent and make a solid pie. I quit going years ago as their pies went downhill, but I have been getting one every other week for the last 6 months and they have been really good!
Chris N Vanessa Maldonado
I've been in NC for 2 years and everyones gimmick is "NY Style" pizza and NOBODY has delivered on the taste of a NY slice.... I went into Brookly Boys after driving passed it numerous times and to my great surprise I finally found that NY taste. It was the best pizza I have eaten since moving to NC and going forward will be the only place I go to for pizza..... Good job fellas
Derrick W.
Great pizza and staff. The place it's really good about having your pizza ready when needed. I would definitely be a gust pick.
Sauce is evenly distributed, great topping proportions, this pizza was amazing. Give me more, give me more.
I work right across the street and the first time I wanted to order for me and my co workers the guy was so rude on the phone we went to Mellow mushroom instead. Today we called and he was rude again but we really wanted to try the white pizza so we ordered. When I went to pick it up, same thing. Just rude. The food is average but the service definitely is what is lacking. And for the place to only have one table occupied, you would think they would want more business. But ya win some ya lose some. Way too many good pizza places to put up with that.
Went here twice. The first time was a fours star and the next time I went back, 5 months later, there was a whole new staff and the pizza went from "not too bad" to "did they get this from Jet Pizza?" The guys I originally met there were actually from NYC (Jamaica Queens specifically) and the pizza was ok. It can only be so good when you leave NYC. I'm a snob, take it for what it's worth. The water is different here and some ingredients are much more difficult to get here. The pizza I ate last weekend was not good. It was like something you would get at a stadium or a bad franchise. It was almost like it was cooked in a machine. If that wasn't bad enough, it was expensive. I think I paid about $35 for a large pie, a 2 liter of soda, and a "Greek" salad (hint: it was the farthest thing from). The guys there seem nice, although not all that personable, but they need to make some serious adjustments or this place will not be around much longer.
Terrible. $9.00 for a hero that each was burnt. Bought three!!!! Had to cut off all the ends. Spent $40.00 and we're still hungry. Never again. Calzone not so bad
Surprised with the low scores I'm seeing here. I first came across this pizza via their food truck which happened to be at the Easter egg hunt at Bond Park. I was starved, energy depleted from the chaos that ensued from the egg hunting activities, but even the steep $5 price for a slice did not dissuade me from my search for the best slice this town has to offer. As an original New Yorker it has been really tough to find a great slice. But not on this day. When I least expected it my taste buds were treated to flavors that were missing for far too long. It was almost a religious experience I kid you not. Months went by. Life gets busy. Finally made it out to their establishment proper and was greeted with the same taste of NY that I was craving. The decor is nothing fancy but what will keep me coming back again and again is the pizza itself. Already looking forward to my next visit.
Awesome NY style pizza, ravioli, and pasta! We eat here at least once a week and they offer free delivery!
Complete garbage, my daughter's paid $5 per slice for 2 slices of pizza from their Food Truck in Wake Forest. After taking a few bites they complained how burnt the crust was. The bottom was completely black. I took the slices back to show the truck and they simply said sorry. No offer to refund me or the 3/4 full slices. They did offer to give another slice, but who wants to eat that after having the burnt taste in your mouth?? What a joke, not a respectable business....stay away
Awesome pizza, very quaint little place. We are out of town on work but felt right at home having dinner here. Friendly and efficient staff.
I have been going to this place for about 4 years. They used to be really good but I have noticed a steady decline in the quality of food and service over the last year. I'm not sure if ownership has changed hands or not but I have finally given up on this place. The final straw was after my last order which was a takeout for an eggplant parm sub and baked ziti. When I got home I found that the sandwich was burned so bad on the ends I couldn't eat it and the tray of baked ziti was only half full. When I called about it the owner, who was seriously lacking in communication skills, told me oops that was a mistake. He offered to redo the order but at my inconvenience of driving back out there to get it. How it could be a mistake to half fill a tray is beyond me. Would the cook make half a pizza and not notice? Steer clear of this place it is not worth it.
Amazing NY style pizza by the slice or pie. The other food on the menu is great as well. One of my favs is the philly cheese steak and the French fries aren't some crappy ones, they're seasoned and taste great. Be careful in later afternoon though if you're looking for just a slice as they usually sell out during lunch so you'll need to get a pie if they sold out of slices with their 5.99 lunch special. Overall very authentic NY style pizzeria
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a great place for pizza. Delivery is quick and we have only had 1 incident , in 3 years, where our order was messed up and they were quick to fix it. They get super busy on the weekends so be patient if you call and it rings busy...there is a good reason why that happens sometimes.
First rime in. Had two appetizers delicious. The calzones were amazing! The staff was friendly and efficient. Definately going back.
Of all the NY style pizza joints in Cary, they are the most consistent and make a solid pie. I quit going years ago as their pies went downhill, but I have been getting one every other week for the last 6 months and they have been really good!
I've been in NC for 2 years and everyones gimmick is "NY Style" pizza and NOBODY has delivered on the taste of a NY slice.... I went into Brookly Boys after driving passed it numerous times and to my great surprise I finally found that NY taste. It was the best pizza I have eaten since moving to NC and going forward will be the only place I go to for pizza..... Good job fellas
Great pizza and staff. The place it's really good about having your pizza ready when needed. I would definitely be a gust pick.