Seemingly Overzealous Ice Cream

Self proclaimed ice cream lover here that is also ironically lactose intolerant. I normally don't like non-dairy ice cream but this is all so good!

The ice cream is phenomenal and the staff are kind and helpful!

Great dairy and gluten free ice cream! The apple pie and pumpkin cheesecake together was incredible! Great service too! Bought some pints to go!

As someone who is gluten and dairy free I was stoked to find this place. Their ice cream is AWESOME and the fact that I could get a waffle cone was amazing. Keep up the great work.

Best ice cream in Charlotte ❤️

Absolutely INCREDIBLE ice cream. You wouldn’t even know it’s gluten or dairy free. Their customer service is great, their flavors perfect, and their vibes immaculate. A lifelong customer!!!!

Clean and spacious shop with activities for kids. The butter pecan and lemon blueberry cheesecake ice cream were delicious. Will come back again!

Love the vegan ice cream!!

A tadpole Italian ice award coupon for a free junior sized Italian ice cup brought myself to Jeremiah's. My grandson received a chocolate tadpole cup and My wife and I ended purchasing two medium cups for ourselves. Great treat mixing both Italian ice and ice cream together is a nice pairing.

It was good.

I love this place, there are not many vegan ice cream places in the Charlotte area. I live in Concord and we drive to this or the Camp North End location from time to time. I love their ice cream, it has a creamy consistency and it’s not overly sweet.

We had a short visit to NC (Concord/Charlotte area). Hubby did some research on places to eat. He found a dairy free ice cream shop, Seemingly Overzealous! I am lactose intolerant, so this was a GREAT BONUS! So much so, I had a double scoop. Plus, gluten-free for him so he could eat the little crisp that comes with a cup of ice cream. My hubby and son had their ice cream before I could snap a photo. My daughter in law had the earl gray and it tasted like drinking tea.

🍨 single scoop- Grey blobbin
🍨 double scoop- people first (coffee) & can't all be cookie (cookies & cream)
🍨 bag of crisp to go

I'm not sure what all the hype is about. Because of the weird names I can't remember what I got, the main issue was the flavors were weak and not impressive. My wife agreed with her two flavors. But, I'm happy for their success.

We’ve been die hard fans since opening day at CNE and have hit the openings for both PM and Dilworth. We mostly frequent CNE and PM locations and PM is our favorite. The employees are always sweet to my two kiddos and the owners who we cross paths with from time to time are warm and smiley and help get extra prizes from the sprinkle machine to brighten their day. That said even if the ice cream was mediocre, that’s enough to keep us coming back. Alas, the ice cream is heavenly, so creamy and decadent and heals apart of my Celiac, Dairy allergy soul. They really hit the nail on the head and I aspire to be in the income bracket someday where I can budget weekly ice cream dates in. 🙂 Thanks guys!

Holy smokes, this ice cream is so good. The fact that it’s vegan is even more impressive! I got a pint of the legendary dunks to take home and it was terrific. Love all of the mix-ins and the overall flavor profile of this ice cream. Friendly employees and clean and welcoming facility. Well definitely be back!