Had a great time and people there were fantastic. We’ll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
A P Hargreaves
Worthless....online orders don't work. Text the number you are told when you call...doesn't work. Wait on hold while calling... Been 15 min. It's 530pm. Nobody is this busy.
Service: 1
A G.
service was exceptional best pizza in the area, we are local and love eating here regularly over other options hand tossed is exceptional, delicious, red sauce.
Jeffrey Cohen
We had takeout so I can only comment on the pizza. It was ok, not great, not bad. I wasn't a fan of the crust but the rest was ok.
Food: 3
Monica Venne
The pizza was delicious. Sean, our server was very welcoming and efficient.We went her for a late lunch and had two pizzas, the Corolla Classic (highly recommend) and our kids had a pepperoni pizza. Overall great experience! 5/5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House
Laura S.
The pizza is the best in Corolla. The service was great. Will definitely be going back.
Joli Leimkuehler
Edit: I upped the star rating because the flavor of the pizza is good. If this were cooked correctly the first time, I would consider coming back here but unfortunately I'm just glad I tried it but will not return.Pretty disappointing to spend $35 dollars on a large, undercooked, over sauced pizza plus an order of the world's smallest knots. $10 dollara for knots that tasted like they were cooked from a frozen pack. The dipping sauce wasn't terrible. Wish I could review the taste of the pizza but I have to wait until I get home to recook a pizza that should have just been cooked the first time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
David Danner
The pizza here was delish & cooked tender - no hard crust. Had two pies & filled up. Take home box was needed.White crab pizza was super nice with crab meat mozzarella, tomato & basaltic drizzle - like a cáptese salad on the pie crust. ?Nice selection of beers on tap & in cans. Beach theme here - why not?But barman is a rugby league guy from Philly and was getting into the game. Nice chatty fella.Certainly would like to have this place around the corner from me. Genuinely good food & people.
Recommended dishes: White Crab Pizza
Rebecca W.
The first place we stop when we hit the Outer Banks. Best food & amazing staff! The menu is great and food is consistently outstanding.
Jennifer Taveras
EDIT: YIKES! So you’re just going to flat out lie now? ? I was the only person standing in line in front of you when I asked the question at the time and you damn well know this. And even if that happened to be the case (which it wasn’t), I asked a simple yes or no question that you could have answered in 2 seconds. I had asked if my name had been called because I wanted to make sure that my food wasn’t sitting on the counter getting cold, especially after spending +$80 on it. I wasn’t asking if you “could” call my name. And the guy who eventually gave me my food called out my name anyway, so I don’t get the point you’re even trying to make right now. ? But at this point I can tell you’d just rather envelop yourself in lie after lie instead of taking accountability for the sake of your own business. -1 star.Ordered food for pickup and then we stepped away for a bit to walk around while they were preparing the order. We came back a little later and asked the cashier, Matthew, if they had called me (as in called my name). Matthew proceeded to pop an attitude and say “No we’re not going to call you.” Trying to figure out where the attitude was coming from, I realized he thought I was asking if they called my phone. I tried to clarify what I meant the second time and he just repeated what he told me before. And it wasn’t until I gave him the same attitude he was giving me back that he finally gave me the answer I was looking for; an eta of when it would be ready. Dude’s anger was blinding his common sense. If he didn’t have such a nasty attitude to begin with, it wouldn’t have taken him 4 tries to answer my question. He wasn’t the only worker in there that seemed to hate his job either, because I noticed a couple of instances of workers mumbling passive aggressive things under their breath about customers.Food was alright (only reason this is getting a 2 star instead of 1) but Mathew’s petty attitude left a bad taste in my family and I’s mouth. Would not recommend this place unless you’re getting delivery.
We got a Greek salad to share and then we ordered the house specialty pizza. It was good!I enjoyed the crust a lot! The bartender and the server were very nice and made out visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Meaty Pizza
Clyde E.
Really cool spot. The food is definitely worth it. The pizza was our favorite. Self serve beverages. Staff is a little rough around the edges, but they get the job done. Cash discount too! We liked it so much we ate here twice in a week.
Bob M.
Damn good pizza. That being said not easy to get your pizza. Very busy place and somewhat stressed staff. Parking a little crazy. The unique crab pizza is a great hit. Everyone was pleased. Prices ok.
Steve T.
Wonderful pizza, great pizza. Staff was super nice. All 3 pizzas I got were great. PB whiskey milkshake
Jerry Beyer
Pizza was average. Cost was outrageous. I should have asked to see a print out of the bill in advance. Also, I didn't ask for a copy because we were in a hurry. Would never go there again. $$$$$$$ Better to go hungry.
Had a great time and people there were fantastic. We’ll be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Worthless....online orders don't work. Text the number you are told when you call...doesn't work. Wait on hold while calling... Been 15 min. It's 530pm. Nobody is this busy.
Service: 1
service was exceptional best pizza in the area, we are local and love eating here regularly over other options hand tossed is exceptional, delicious, red sauce.
We had takeout so I can only comment on the pizza. It was ok, not great, not bad. I wasn't a fan of the crust but the rest was ok.
Food: 3
The pizza was delicious. Sean, our server was very welcoming and efficient.We went her for a late lunch and had two pizzas, the Corolla Classic (highly recommend) and our kids had a pepperoni pizza. Overall great experience! 5/5
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House
The pizza is the best in Corolla. The service was great. Will definitely be going back.
Edit: I upped the star rating because the flavor of the pizza is good. If this were cooked correctly the first time, I would consider coming back here but unfortunately I'm just glad I tried it but will not return.Pretty disappointing to spend $35 dollars on a large, undercooked, over sauced pizza plus an order of the world's smallest knots. $10 dollara for knots that tasted like they were cooked from a frozen pack. The dipping sauce wasn't terrible. Wish I could review the taste of the pizza but I have to wait until I get home to recook a pizza that should have just been cooked the first time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
The pizza here was delish & cooked tender - no hard crust. Had two pies & filled up. Take home box was needed.White crab pizza was super nice with crab meat mozzarella, tomato & basaltic drizzle - like a cáptese salad on the pie crust. ?Nice selection of beers on tap & in cans. Beach theme here - why not?But barman is a rugby league guy from Philly and was getting into the game. Nice chatty fella.Certainly would like to have this place around the corner from me. Genuinely good food & people.
Recommended dishes: White Crab Pizza
The first place we stop when we hit the Outer Banks. Best food & amazing staff! The menu is great and food is consistently outstanding.
EDIT: YIKES! So you’re just going to flat out lie now? ? I was the only person standing in line in front of you when I asked the question at the time and you damn well know this. And even if that happened to be the case (which it wasn’t), I asked a simple yes or no question that you could have answered in 2 seconds. I had asked if my name had been called because I wanted to make sure that my food wasn’t sitting on the counter getting cold, especially after spending +$80 on it. I wasn’t asking if you “could” call my name. And the guy who eventually gave me my food called out my name anyway, so I don’t get the point you’re even trying to make right now. ? But at this point I can tell you’d just rather envelop yourself in lie after lie instead of taking accountability for the sake of your own business. -1 star.Ordered food for pickup and then we stepped away for a bit to walk around while they were preparing the order. We came back a little later and asked the cashier, Matthew, if they had called me (as in called my name). Matthew proceeded to pop an attitude and say “No we’re not going to call you.” Trying to figure out where the attitude was coming from, I realized he thought I was asking if they called my phone. I tried to clarify what I meant the second time and he just repeated what he told me before. And it wasn’t until I gave him the same attitude he was giving me back that he finally gave me the answer I was looking for; an eta of when it would be ready. Dude’s anger was blinding his common sense. If he didn’t have such a nasty attitude to begin with, it wouldn’t have taken him 4 tries to answer my question. He wasn’t the only worker in there that seemed to hate his job either, because I noticed a couple of instances of workers mumbling passive aggressive things under their breath about customers.Food was alright (only reason this is getting a 2 star instead of 1) but Mathew’s petty attitude left a bad taste in my family and I’s mouth. Would not recommend this place unless you’re getting delivery.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We got a Greek salad to share and then we ordered the house specialty pizza. It was good!I enjoyed the crust a lot! The bartender and the server were very nice and made out visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Meaty Pizza
Really cool spot. The food is definitely worth it. The pizza was our favorite. Self serve beverages. Staff is a little rough around the edges, but they get the job done. Cash discount too! We liked it so much we ate here twice in a week.
Damn good pizza. That being said not easy to get your pizza. Very busy place and somewhat stressed staff. Parking a little crazy. The unique crab pizza is a great hit. Everyone was pleased. Prices ok.
Wonderful pizza, great pizza. Staff was super nice. All 3 pizzas I got were great. PB whiskey milkshake
Pizza was average. Cost was outrageous. I should have asked to see a print out of the bill in advance. Also, I didn't ask for a copy because we were in a hurry. Would never go there again. $$$$$$$ Better to go hungry.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1