I've been here many times, no longer live in the area. My wife and I had our first date here in 2012, revisited last night (2025) and the place was still excellent. For lunch I'd usually get a burger and fries (excellent fries), or the lobster bisque or clam chowder soups (both fantastic). For our first date (and again last night) we had the Filet Mignon - mine with a loaded baked potato and her's with sweet potatoes. Both meals were absolutely delicious. To top it off we each got a small slice of cake (their slices are very big), also delicious. Our server, Eric, was incredibly nice and attentive. Can't wait to go back again! Great place for a date or for a family outing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tj
They never make anything bad
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jessie Zettler
Great seafood, even better deserts!
Terri Wiggins
I have never had a bad meal here. The best service our waitress name Sue was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D B
Grill and Seafood place with attached bakery- Get a slice of cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noel Stewart
I love Nantucket Grill. Eat there often. When my family comes to town its there go to restaurant for seafood. I placed a food order last night. While the hamburger was delicious as always the pumpkin cheesecake was terrible. It was so dry and was unable to take more then 2 bites. I ended up throwing it away. I have tried just about every dessert Nantucket offers and that was the first time i experienced a terrible dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Devon Shubin
The food at Nantucket Grill is very good, but the desserts is where it’s at.
Never ate there but the strawberry shortcake NEVER disappoints. I have introduced plenty of people here that are all returning customers if only for the cake. OUTSTANDING!!! The owner even “loaned” me a piece of cake one day, they were not open for business yet and I was in area and door was open. He gave it to me and trusted me to come pay later. I did but it was a week or two. Brought tears to my eyes. Thank you Nantucket Now I need to revise today 10/17/2025 I finally ate here and they did NOT disappoint. The tea was fantastic, the jambalaya was fantastic and the service from Sukanda was outstanding !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Triniprincess716
The food is delicious and high quality. I love the BBQ chicken sandwich, just wow. 10/10. I’m salivating just thinking about it! Don’t get me started on the strawberry shortcake. I love coming to this restaurant, it’s always delicious and consistent!!!
Jay Hand
Consistently excellent food, outstanding service. Miguel or Amelia are both servers of such extraordinary, ability, personality; but most of all they just make you feel like home.
This is our go to restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Wallace
The Nantucket Grill in Durham offers a dining experience steeped in New England tradition, featuring a sprawling menu of seafood, steaks, and classic American dishes. However, what truly defines a visit here isn't the entree—it's the infamous, sky-high, multi-layer cakes displayed prominently upon entry.
The Atmosphere and Service Nantucket Grill leans into a classic, established ambiance, which some may find charmingly old-school, while others might view it as slightly dated. The setting is generally comfortable, with outdoor seating often available.
The menu is extensive, offering everything from Filet Mignon and Cajun Ribeye to New England staples like the Maine Lobster Roll, Crab Cakes, and various stuffed seafood preparations (like the Nantucket Island Stuffed Tilapia). Popular savory choices include the Atlantic Grilled Salmon and the Jambalaya Pasta, which is described as a flavorful, zesty Creole dish. For lunch, the French Dip sandwich and the Blackened Salmon Salad are reliable options.
If there is one non-negotiable reason to visit Nantucket Grill, it is for the bakery case. The restaurant is universally known for its massive, multi-layered cakes—truly impressive feats of pastry engineering. The favorites are consistently the Strawberry Shortcake (often cited as the best) and the Coconut Vanilla Cake (Coconut Cloud). The cakes are decadent, moist, and enormous; a single slice is often substantial enough to serve two or three people. Many regulars opt for sandwiches or salads for their meal just to save room for this signature dessert, or simply stop by for a slice to take home.
Nantucket Grill is an institution that successfully serves a niche. It is the perfect choice for family dinners, those craving classic New England comfort food, or anyone who values a spectacular dessert above all else. Just make sure you save room for it!
Nice outdoor space
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Always good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been here many times, no longer live in the area. My wife and I had our first date here in 2012, revisited last night (2025) and the place was still excellent. For lunch I'd usually get a burger and fries (excellent fries), or the lobster bisque or clam chowder soups (both fantastic). For our first date (and again last night) we had the Filet Mignon - mine with a loaded baked potato and her's with sweet potatoes. Both meals were absolutely delicious. To top it off we each got a small slice of cake (their slices are very big), also delicious. Our server, Eric, was incredibly nice and attentive. Can't wait to go back again! Great place for a date or for a family outing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They never make anything bad
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great seafood, even better deserts!
I have never had a bad meal here. The best service our waitress name Sue was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grill and Seafood place with attached bakery- Get a slice of cake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love Nantucket Grill. Eat there often.
When my family comes to town its there go to restaurant for seafood.
I placed a food order last night. While the hamburger was delicious as always the pumpkin cheesecake was terrible. It was so dry and was unable to take more then 2 bites.
I ended up throwing it away.
I have tried just about every dessert Nantucket offers and that was the first time i experienced a terrible dessert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food at Nantucket Grill is very good, but the desserts is where it’s at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service and great desserts
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Never ate there but the strawberry shortcake NEVER disappoints. I have introduced plenty of people here that are all returning customers if only for the cake. OUTSTANDING!!! The owner even “loaned” me a piece of cake one day, they were not open for business yet and I was in area and door was open. He gave it to me and trusted me to come pay later. I did but it was a week or two. Brought tears to my eyes.
Thank you Nantucket
Now I need to revise today 10/17/2025 I finally ate here and they did NOT disappoint.
The tea was fantastic, the jambalaya was fantastic and the service from Sukanda was outstanding !!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is delicious and high quality. I love the BBQ chicken sandwich, just wow. 10/10. I’m salivating just thinking about it! Don’t get me started on the strawberry shortcake. I love coming to this restaurant, it’s always delicious and consistent!!!
Consistently excellent food, outstanding service.
Miguel or Amelia are both servers of such extraordinary, ability, personality; but most of all they just make you feel like home.
This is our go to restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Nantucket Grill in Durham offers a dining experience steeped in New England tradition, featuring a sprawling menu of seafood, steaks, and classic American dishes. However, what truly defines a visit here isn't the entree—it's the infamous, sky-high, multi-layer cakes displayed prominently upon entry.
The Atmosphere and Service
Nantucket Grill leans into a classic, established ambiance, which some may find charmingly old-school, while others might view it as slightly dated. The setting is generally comfortable, with outdoor seating often available.
The menu is extensive, offering everything from Filet Mignon and Cajun Ribeye to New England staples like the Maine Lobster Roll, Crab Cakes, and various stuffed seafood preparations (like the Nantucket Island Stuffed Tilapia). Popular savory choices include the Atlantic Grilled Salmon and the Jambalaya Pasta, which is described as a flavorful, zesty Creole dish. For lunch, the French Dip sandwich and the Blackened Salmon Salad are reliable options.
If there is one non-negotiable reason to visit Nantucket Grill, it is for the bakery case. The restaurant is universally known for its massive, multi-layered cakes—truly impressive feats of pastry engineering. The favorites are consistently the Strawberry Shortcake (often cited as the best) and the Coconut Vanilla Cake (Coconut Cloud).
The cakes are decadent, moist, and enormous; a single slice is often substantial enough to serve two or three people. Many regulars opt for sandwiches or salads for their meal just to save room for this signature dessert, or simply stop by for a slice to take home.
Nantucket Grill is an institution that successfully serves a niche. It is the perfect choice for family dinners, those craving classic New England comfort food, or anyone who values a spectacular dessert above all else. Just make sure you save room for it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is great. Vakes are out of this world!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...