NYC Deli & Cafe

346 N Reilly Rd, Fayetteville
(910) 835-3032

Recent Reviews

Jonathan Smith

Had the “Hungry Man’s Breakfast” It’s better to have either jelly, syrup or honey drizzled on the sandwich

Jesse Sellars

My sandwich was decent. The drink I wanted was not cold. The drink I purchased out of the fridge was barely chilled. I ordered my food to stay, but by the time I received it (to go) I had already decided I didn't want to stay in this place anyway. It was dark and untidy.

Alody Garcia

Ordered a hungry man's breakfast and a Italian sandwich. Breakfast sandwich was horrible, sausage was bad, the Italian sandwich wasn't made like I asked. Also the sandwich size in comparison to the price was to small. Might as well buy on the chain restaurants like JJ or Jersey Mike's. Thus store doesn't represent NY nor it's deli sandwiches. If I could give 0 stars I would.

Amber Praust

Didn’t even get to try it because it says they’re open, lights are on, someone is inside they just locked the door when I tried to go in. Crazy ?

Amber Kepford

My friend and I ate lunch here. I wanted a ham sandwich and they were out of ham. My friend got breakfast which was horrible. The frying oil needed to be changed. We were given no receipt and overcharged by 8 dollars.

Sarah Hadi

I visited for the first time today and ordered a steak and cheese panini. What I got was more of a fajita style pita sandwich with what looked like a few dollops of nacho cheese on the inside. Pretty pricey for not including any sides or a drink. Would try this place again one more time before completely writing it off.

Maria Macias

Sub was dry and something tasted spoiled, coffee was the worst. Paid $14 for breakfast

adelmary villegas

Frappe cookies and cream I do not recommend (made with ice), tripleta recommend it was good and Buffalo chicken panini was okay really greasy.

John Molborn

Great place to eat at. The atmosphere reminds me of a mom and pop sandwich shop. They have inside and outside seating which is great with this warm weather coming. Thank you for a great experience. I will be back!

R B

Got the hungry man breakfast and must say it was very delicious. I would definitely order that again. I also ordered a cafe mocha not realizing that I would receive just a basic coffee. There was nothing cafe mocha about it. It was just black coffee. Didn't realize this unill after I left. Definitely would not order that again. Wanted to try something that wasn't a chain while passing through the Fayetteville area.

Douglass Jeff

Breakfast pita sandwich wasn't the best I've every had but I still want to try their other stuff.

Mrs C

My husband had the Philly cheesesteak...it was so greasy...I had a Gyro and the sour cream they tried to pass of as taziki was spoiled...I had to throw it way...

Lynn McKinley

I love the family that owns this deli- their food is always fresh and delicious and they are very friendly! 10/10 recommend to anyone

Edwin C.

Got the Gyro. Give 2 stars. Meat was good but only 3 slices? Portion is small. Buddy had the Reuben. He rated it 4/5. It was good but again portion size is small.

Laura VanFleet

Drove 30 minutes to go to this deli…ordered a turkey, lettuce, and mayo sandwich. Got home and opened the sandwich and I got a prosciutto, salami, and ham sandwich with onions and lettuce. No clue where the order went wrong, but 100% not what I ordered. Super disappointed.

Load More