Good pizza. Good quality, fresh sauce, and tasty; even a New Yorker might buy a slice...
Taryn Newborne
Two words… Fried Zucchini. It was my favorite!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Henry Tyson
I can’t recommend this place enough! We had a pig party for my wife’s birthday and called spoke with the owner the same day he prepared more than enough food for our party. The food was hot and ready when we picked it up and the staff were great. Definitely will be picking up and dining in many more times!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
Daniel Akins
I came on a Sunday for lunch. I just got 2 meatlovers slices. I can tell that this place knows what they're doing- the crust and sauce are fantastic. The additional meats on my pizza were very cheap, store bought ingredients. I would rate 3 stars for my meal, but it's very clear how good this place could be if I ordered better. I'll try again for dinner one day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Jeremy C.
Stopped by on the recommendation of a friend. I thought it was delicious! I had the pepperoni pizza and it was great. My wife had the clams & mussels; she said that it was really good and tasted fresher than the seafood places in Fayetteville. I found it odd that you have to order at the window then they bring the food out in to-go containers; no big deal though. The staff was friendly & the prices were fair. The coffee & dessert place attached is nice too. Good selection but I tried the bakalava. It was delicious too. Overall great experience.
rosalyn evans
Had the original Stromboli, was not disappointed. Delicious from first bite to last.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stromboli
April H.
Absolutely amazing food. It seems to be family owned. Hubby and I went on Valentine's Day, not for date night, just for pizza. Service was great. Would recommend this pizza to anyone . Just ordered some on Uber eats too
Ceara D.
Everything is served in to go containers. They bring it to your table wrapped in a brown bag , other than that there is no waitress. Food was good though and the desserts look bomb. Would recommend and will go back again.
Courtney Williford
Since when did Elizabeth’s pizza on Skibo Road become to-go only??!! Came for date night and there is no wait staff, you order at the window, and it’s given to you in take out containers, even when you dine in. Signs posted to “clean up after yourself”. Come on man!! Wtf. Why is there not a sign on the door saying take out only cause that’s pretty much what it is. Ordered lasagna and received it in a brown bag and plastic container. It’s almost as if it was made ahead and heated in the microwave. This is definitely not the Elizabeth’s pizza I remember. We will not make the mistake of coming to this location again. We will go to Hope Mills.
Courtney W.
Mannn has Elizabeth's Pizza on Skibo Road changed. It's pretty much take out only. We were very disappointed when we came to this location for date night and found out there is no wait staff, you order at a window, your food comes out in take out containers and they have signs posted to "clean up after yourself". You want a refill on your drink...? You have to go to the window and ask for it. When we asked what happened or what's up with the change... they told us it was because of Covid. That was 4 years ago. I feel the owner discovered they save more money as a take out place and have made it this way. That's great, but post it on the doors outside so your customers don't get a surprise and are highly disappointed once inside. As for the food.... It must've went away with the staff. I ordered lasagna and as said above, it came in a brown bag and plastic take out container. Half warm. It's almost like it was premade and heated the microwave. Not much flavor and watered down marinara sauce. We will not come back to this location and will stick to Hope Mills Road instead.
I paid $25 for 4×6 cut lasagna that was nothing more than a piece of pasta and a slice of cheese layered about 4 layers high, tomato sauce and shredded cheese on top, cooked in a microwave. Please explain to me how my lasagna was dry and had little flavor. We ordered in, and they brought all our food in to go boxes and paper bags. Half the restaurant had boxes stacked up 6 to 8 feet high. And they wanted you to bust your own tables after you ate like you were in a cheap fast food restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Rick Paxton
Pizza is good but there is no service. I will go to Hope Mills next
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Steve O'Brien
Have eaten at the EP on Hope Mills Rd but never knew this one was here. We stopped in because we are in this side of town. Was a little confused about how to order at first but once we read the sign we figured it out. People were nice and food was good. Would recommend to eat here or take out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Reynaldo H
Please a order tonight. Worse ever! Veal was overcooked to the point it was like trying to establish rubber. First time I had bad food from this place. Totally disappointed!!Vegetarian options: Salad was okay.
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Side Salad
The Ge Baby
This pizza was THE BEST PIZZA i have ever tasted in my life woahhh it was FRESH right crunch perfect crust TEN OUT OF TEN (i was also high sooo lol)
Good pizza. Good quality, fresh sauce, and tasty; even a New Yorker might buy a slice...
Two words… Fried Zucchini. It was my favorite!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can’t recommend this place enough! We had a pig party for my wife’s birthday and called spoke with the owner the same day he prepared more than enough food for our party. The food was hot and ready when we picked it up and the staff were great. Definitely will be picking up and dining in many more times!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza
I came on a Sunday for lunch. I just got 2 meatlovers slices. I can tell that this place knows what they're doing- the crust and sauce are fantastic. The additional meats on my pizza were very cheap, store bought ingredients. I would rate 3 stars for my meal, but it's very clear how good this place could be if I ordered better. I'll try again for dinner one day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Stopped by on the recommendation of a friend. I thought it was delicious! I had the pepperoni pizza and it was great. My wife had the clams & mussels; she said that it was really good and tasted fresher than the seafood places in Fayetteville. I found it odd that you have to order at the window then they bring the food out in to-go containers; no big deal though. The staff was friendly & the prices were fair. The coffee & dessert place attached is nice too. Good selection but I tried the bakalava. It was delicious too. Overall great experience.
Had the original Stromboli, was not disappointed. Delicious from first bite to last.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Stromboli
Absolutely amazing food. It seems to be family owned. Hubby and I went on Valentine's Day, not for date night, just for pizza. Service was great. Would recommend this pizza to anyone . Just ordered some on Uber eats too
Everything is served in to go containers. They bring it to your table wrapped in a brown bag , other than that there is no waitress. Food was good though and the desserts look bomb. Would recommend and will go back again.
Since when did Elizabeth’s pizza on Skibo Road become to-go only??!! Came for date night and there is no wait staff, you order at the window, and it’s given to you in take out containers, even when you dine in. Signs posted to “clean up after yourself”. Come on man!! Wtf. Why is there not a sign on the door saying take out only cause that’s pretty much what it is. Ordered lasagna and received it in a brown bag and plastic container. It’s almost as if it was made ahead and heated in the microwave. This is definitely not the Elizabeth’s pizza I remember. We will not make the mistake of coming to this location again. We will go to Hope Mills.
Mannn has Elizabeth's Pizza on Skibo Road changed. It's pretty much take out only. We were very disappointed when we came to this location for date night and found out there is no wait staff, you order at a window, your food comes out in take out containers and they have signs posted to "clean up after yourself". You want a refill on your drink...? You have to go to the window and ask for it. When we asked what happened or what's up with the change... they told us it was because of Covid. That was 4 years ago. I feel the owner discovered they save more money as a take out place and have made it this way. That's great, but post it on the doors outside so your customers don't get a surprise and are highly disappointed once inside. As for the food.... It must've went away with the staff. I ordered lasagna and as said above, it came in a brown bag and plastic take out container. Half warm. It's almost like it was premade and heated the microwave. Not much flavor and watered down marinara sauce. We will not come back to this location and will stick to Hope Mills Road instead.
Restaurantji Recommends
I paid $25 for 4×6 cut lasagna that was nothing more than a piece of pasta and a slice of cheese layered about 4 layers high, tomato sauce and shredded cheese on top, cooked in a microwave. Please explain to me how my lasagna was dry and had little flavor. We ordered in, and they brought all our food in to go boxes and paper bags. Half the restaurant had boxes stacked up 6 to 8 feet high. And they wanted you to bust your own tables after you ate like you were in a cheap fast food restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Pizza is good but there is no service. I will go to Hope Mills next
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Have eaten at the EP on Hope Mills Rd but never knew this one was here. We stopped in because we are in this side of town. Was a little confused about how to order at first but once we read the sign we figured it out. People were nice and food was good. Would recommend to eat here or take out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Please a order tonight. Worse ever! Veal was overcooked to the point it was like trying to establish rubber. First time I had bad food from this place. Totally disappointed!!Vegetarian options: Salad was okay.
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Side Salad
This pizza was THE BEST PIZZA i have ever tasted in my life woahhh it was FRESH right crunch perfect crust TEN OUT OF TEN (i was also high sooo lol)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza