I used to work at my church a couple blocks away, and I ordered lunch here 1-2 times per week. Since retiring, I don't come as often, but my husband and I came last night. The food was good as usual. I was on a Zoom call and being distracted, I left my purse given to me by my daughter-in-law (a Coach). I only realized it when we pulled into our driveway, 10 miles away. We hurried back to NY Deli, and when I walked in, the lady rushed over to greet me. She'd placed my purse behind the counter but held my receipt in her hand. She'd tried to call me (my phone was dead), so she texted me. Not only that, she was trying to find my address bc she couldn't reach me. She'd planned to try to bring it to me after work if she could! That was extraordinary effort. Their sandwiches are great and my grands love the pizza and Philly Cheese Steak. Thank you so much!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jada P.
This place is incredible. I had the cold Italian sub and I can honestly say it's the best sub i've ever had. The bread was fluffy and light, but was able to hold all of the condiments and ingredients without everything falling out. My friend had the 12 inch Pizza that Jorge made and ate the entire thing by himself. He said that the crust was crispy but not hard (easy to bite into). You can tell they use low moisture, part skim mozzarella. We are only in town for a short time, and the fact that I can't have this pizza every day makes us want to kill ourselves. Monique was a treat, and had amazing customer service. I must say it is better than Brooklyn Pizzeria, and I will die on this hill.
Joey O.
Best pizza in North Carolina. Quick fast service. Only downside...I wasn't impressed with the decor.
Belinda Byrd
I can always expect a wide variety of food choices. The food is always fresh and the service friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, House Salad, Boneless Wings 10, Italian Sub 6, Tiramisu, Meat Lovers Pizza, Special Any 12 Sub with Fries & Drink
Allison Linn
My workplace orders here every Wednesday morning, recieved legit ROTTEN hashbrowns this morning. Cant speak for the rest of my team but I definitely wont be ordering from them again.
Karis B.
Delicious made-to-order food. My husband and I got the lamb gyro meal and they gave us an extra gyro!! Warm, fresh, flavorful, and delicious. The pita bread was nice and not dry, the tzatziki was nice and not over powering, decent amount of meat on the sandwiches, and the French fries were hot, seasoned with seasoned salt, and crispy. This is a nice little place to stop in for a quick lunch, they have lots of things to choose from, and good prices. We will have to come back to try their $1 pizza slices and more...
Stephen B.
Got the lamb gyro it was really good. It was a good price and fast service. Would recommend. Mr Mancini restored my faith in God. The gyro was an existential experience. As I bit into the succulent meat with tzatziki the heavens opened up and all of God's angels sang and rejoiced. Plus Mr Mancini gave me two for the price of one
Jonathan G
Sandwiches are really good, liked each I've tried so far. The pastrami is my fave so far
Geoffrey Caquias II
It’s been a couple years since I had breakfast here, still pretty ??
We go often now that we've discovered them. The $1 slice deal can't be beat. The pizza do knots are our go to. It's good and tastes very close to NYC pizza.
S T.
One of the worst pizzas I've ever had! Poor taste, not enough cheese, sauce, flavor...Grubhub got it to me too late...pizza was barely lukewarm. Never again!
Rodney L.
Ordered an XL meat stuffed pizza, and a ham and turkey sub meal. Was told 25 mins on the phone. Went and picked up other places based on 25 mins. Arrived after 30 mins and was told 7-8 more mins for pizza. 30 mins later, received pizza, sub, no fries.... This used to be my go-to spot for authentic NY Pizza.... Now, Chick-fil-a is cold, Wendy's is soggy and I need to find something to cut my pizza.... Hopefully my baitknife is clean...
Un K.
Great deal and great pizza! 2 slices of cheese pizza and a drink for $8. It was ready in about 5 mins and was straight out the oven fresh. Will definitely come back!
Ray L.
Best pizza in Fayetteville! If you are looking for a NY slice, this is the closest thing to it. A big greasy foldable slice of pizza, sold by the slice! No pork and great beef pepperoni. There wings are pretty good too.
I used to work at my church a couple blocks away, and I ordered lunch here 1-2 times per week. Since retiring, I don't come as often, but my husband and I came last night. The food was good as usual. I was on a Zoom call and being distracted, I left my purse given to me by my daughter-in-law (a Coach). I only realized it when we pulled into our driveway, 10 miles away. We hurried back to NY Deli, and when I walked in, the lady rushed over to greet me. She'd placed my purse behind the counter but held my receipt in her hand. She'd tried to call me (my phone was dead), so she texted me. Not only that, she was trying to find my address bc she couldn't reach me. She'd planned to try to bring it to me after work if she could! That was extraordinary effort. Their sandwiches are great and my grands love the pizza and Philly Cheese Steak. Thank you so much!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
This place is incredible. I had the cold Italian sub and I can honestly say it's the best sub i've ever had. The bread was fluffy and light, but was able to hold all of the condiments and ingredients without everything falling out. My friend had the 12 inch Pizza that Jorge made and ate the entire thing by himself. He said that the crust was crispy but not hard (easy to bite into). You can tell they use low moisture, part skim mozzarella. We are only in town for a short time, and the fact that I can't have this pizza every day makes us want to kill ourselves. Monique was a treat, and had amazing customer service. I must say it is better than Brooklyn Pizzeria, and I will die on this hill.
Best pizza in North Carolina. Quick fast service. Only downside...I wasn't impressed with the decor.
I can always expect a wide variety of food choices. The food is always fresh and the service friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, House Salad, Boneless Wings 10, Italian Sub 6, Tiramisu, Meat Lovers Pizza, Special Any 12 Sub with Fries & Drink
My workplace orders here every Wednesday morning, recieved legit ROTTEN hashbrowns this morning. Cant speak for the rest of my team but I definitely wont be ordering from them again.
Delicious made-to-order food. My husband and I got the lamb gyro meal and they gave us an extra gyro!! Warm, fresh, flavorful, and delicious. The pita bread was nice and not dry, the tzatziki was nice and not over powering, decent amount of meat on the sandwiches, and the French fries were hot, seasoned with seasoned salt, and crispy. This is a nice little place to stop in for a quick lunch, they have lots of things to choose from, and good prices. We will have to come back to try their $1 pizza slices and more...
Got the lamb gyro it was really good. It was a good price and fast service. Would recommend. Mr Mancini restored my faith in God. The gyro was an existential experience. As I bit into the succulent meat with tzatziki the heavens opened up and all of God's angels sang and rejoiced. Plus Mr Mancini gave me two for the price of one
Sandwiches are really good, liked each I've tried so far. The pastrami is my fave so far
It’s been a couple years since I had breakfast here, still pretty ??
Food is amazing
Restaurantji Recommends
We go often now that we've discovered them. The $1 slice deal can't be beat. The pizza do knots are our go to. It's good and tastes very close to NYC pizza.
One of the worst pizzas I've ever had! Poor taste, not enough cheese, sauce, flavor...Grubhub got it to me too late...pizza was barely lukewarm. Never again!
Ordered an XL meat stuffed pizza, and a ham and turkey sub meal. Was told 25 mins on the phone. Went and picked up other places based on 25 mins. Arrived after 30 mins and was told 7-8 more mins for pizza. 30 mins later, received pizza, sub, no fries.... This used to be my go-to spot for authentic NY Pizza.... Now, Chick-fil-a is cold, Wendy's is soggy and I need to find something to cut my pizza.... Hopefully my baitknife is clean...
Great deal and great pizza! 2 slices of cheese pizza and a drink for $8. It was ready in about 5 mins and was straight out the oven fresh. Will definitely come back!
Best pizza in Fayetteville! If you are looking for a NY slice, this is the closest thing to it. A big greasy foldable slice of pizza, sold by the slice! No pork and great beef pepperoni. There wings are pretty good too.