Not the best pizza around, but it’s not horrible.
Pizza dough is really chewy. We had the BBQ Chicken and Buffalo pies. We also ordered chicken parm.
Bbq and Buffalo were your standard jarred sauce. Chicken was a miss- 50% were dried out.
Chicken parm dinner wasn’t bad. Spaghetti noodles themselves were mushy to the touch and threw them out. Chicken itself was good.
Overall…. If you’re hungry and want a fast food pizza, not a bad spot.
Nathan Blanchard
Pick up order! In person! Made the pizza wrong, ordered no mushrooms, called the shop, expecting an apology and come back for the right pie, instead I was on hold for 5 mins while they discussed god knows what; they acted confused and disoriented until finally I asked for the manager and he didn’t want to come to the phone, finally the kid hands him the phone and the dude says call slice, the company that handles their online orders, linked to their website when you place an order. I said you’re gonna make me call slice when I’m holding the pizza you just made wrong? He said “you tell me who’s gonna pay for it?” lol I just paid you for this pizza, actually several overpriced low quality pizzas. And you messed one up, and you’re gonna be an A$$ now? Anyways, the pizza is not New York style, it’s a lie, this is typical southern imposter food claiming to be Italian or New York. They’re middle eastern dudes running a scam, and they wanna screw townies over a $20 pie that cost them probably $3 to make and give me a hard time. Well congrats, you bought yourself some honest reviews and I hope the townies see it. Karma always wins! Thank goodness for social media and online reviews exposing the cons!
John Bradshaw
Been coming here for years and ordered delivery 100s of times. Never again will I support this business. We came in to eat one-night and my wife ordered a sub. 1st half of sub had what looked to be an eyelash in it. No big deal, took it to the front and politely told them it had a hair in it. They acted like they couldn't see it. That's cool it was an eyelash so understandable. I pointed it out and they kindly made another one. Received the new half of sub and yet again another hair. This time a little longer like a beard hair. Several of the cooks had long beards ( could have been a beard hair ) no clue. Again I know this wasn't on purpose and took the sub back up front. This time I said keep it and I didn't want a replacement. The manager threw his hands up saying he couldn't see the hair again. I didn't ask for money back or to replace the sub after the 2nd hair was found. This so called manager got an attitude with me because he said he doesn't understand how they keep getting in there ( like we were putting them in there trying to get a free meal). I'm grateful that my wife came in to stop the boiling situation after putting our daughter in the truck. I will forever do my best to stop friends and family in the community from supporting this business. 1000's of dollars spent in the past but will never get a dime in the future from me. Owners you won't make it much longer with this guy working for you that's for sure.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Elizabeth Campbell
Poor quality wings and average tasting pizza. No crisp to the crust at all. Bready.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Tiffany Dillon
Delicious pizza! We made a pit stop on travel and we will be back next time we drive down 95S.
It’s worth it. Ate it on the tailgate.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jody Feuchter
Every time I order from here, something is always missing or wrong. It used to be not getting the marinara sauce with the garlic knots several times but now it's gone further than just sauce. I ordered and paid for 2 large 2 topping pizzas for pickup only to receive 2 mediums. When brought to their attention they would fix it, they took the 2 medium pizzas back and I waited longer for the pizzas to be remade. Not only did I not get my 2 large pizzas, but they turned around and gave me back the 2 medium pizzas I had previously gave back and just added another medium pizza. I would have sent it back but my children were hungry and I was already running behind because I had to wait for them to fix it only for them to not fix it. I order from here way too much my kids say but after this you have lost a loyal customer!!!
Madi Flanagan
10/10. We love Papa’s and prefer it over any other pizza in JoCo! Support local, Four Oaks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Supreme Pizza, Caesar Salad
Robert OShea
Night shift crew was fair. Needs to learn how to cut a pizza though. Had to use a scissor in order to cut it so I could eat it in my room. Papa Needs to show them what customer service really looks like.
Night shift crew was fair. Needs to learn how to cut a pizza though. Had to use a scissor in order to cut it so I could eat it in my room. Papa Needs to show them what customer service really looks like.
The absolute BEST gluten free pizza!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is terrible
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Not the best pizza around, but it’s not horrible. Pizza dough is really chewy. We had the BBQ Chicken and Buffalo pies. We also ordered chicken parm. Bbq and Buffalo were your standard jarred sauce. Chicken was a miss- 50% were dried out. Chicken parm dinner wasn’t bad. Spaghetti noodles themselves were mushy to the touch and threw them out. Chicken itself was good. Overall…. If you’re hungry and want a fast food pizza, not a bad spot.
Pick up order! In person! Made the pizza wrong, ordered no mushrooms, called the shop, expecting an apology and come back for the right pie, instead I was on hold for 5 mins while they discussed god knows what; they acted confused and disoriented until finally I asked for the manager and he didn’t want to come to the phone, finally the kid hands him the phone and the dude says call slice, the company that handles their online orders, linked to their website when you place an order. I said you’re gonna make me call slice when I’m holding the pizza you just made wrong? He said “you tell me who’s gonna pay for it?” lol I just paid you for this pizza, actually several overpriced low quality pizzas. And you messed one up, and you’re gonna be an A$$ now? Anyways, the pizza is not New York style, it’s a lie, this is typical southern imposter food claiming to be Italian or New York. They’re middle eastern dudes running a scam, and they wanna screw townies over a $20 pie that cost them probably $3 to make and give me a hard time. Well congrats, you bought yourself some honest reviews and I hope the townies see it. Karma always wins! Thank goodness for social media and online reviews exposing the cons!
Been coming here for years and ordered delivery 100s of times. Never again will I support this business. We came in to eat one-night and my wife ordered a sub. 1st half of sub had what looked to be an eyelash in it. No big deal, took it to the front and politely told them it had a hair in it. They acted like they couldn't see it. That's cool it was an eyelash so understandable. I pointed it out and they kindly made another one. Received the new half of sub and yet again another hair. This time a little longer like a beard hair. Several of the cooks had long beards ( could have been a beard hair ) no clue. Again I know this wasn't on purpose and took the sub back up front. This time I said keep it and I didn't want a replacement. The manager threw his hands up saying he couldn't see the hair again. I didn't ask for money back or to replace the sub after the 2nd hair was found. This so called manager got an attitude with me because he said he doesn't understand how they keep getting in there ( like we were putting them in there trying to get a free meal). I'm grateful that my wife came in to stop the boiling situation after putting our daughter in the truck. I will forever do my best to stop friends and family in the community from supporting this business. 1000's of dollars spent in the past but will never get a dime in the future from me. Owners you won't make it much longer with this guy working for you that's for sure.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Poor quality wings and average tasting pizza. No crisp to the crust at all. Bready.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Delicious pizza! We made a pit stop on travel and we will be back next time we drive down 95S.
It’s worth it. Ate it on the tailgate.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Every time I order from here, something is always missing or wrong. It used to be not getting the marinara sauce with the garlic knots several times but now it's gone further than just sauce. I ordered and paid for 2 large 2 topping pizzas for pickup only to receive 2 mediums. When brought to their attention they would fix it, they took the 2 medium pizzas back and I waited longer for the pizzas to be remade. Not only did I not get my 2 large pizzas, but they turned around and gave me back the 2 medium pizzas I had previously gave back and just added another medium pizza. I would have sent it back but my children were hungry and I was already running behind because I had to wait for them to fix it only for them to not fix it. I order from here way too much my kids say but after this you have lost a loyal customer!!!
10/10. We love Papa’s and prefer it over any other pizza in JoCo! Support local, Four Oaks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Supreme Pizza, Caesar Salad
Night shift crew was fair. Needs to learn how to cut a pizza though. Had to use a scissor in order to cut it so I could eat it in my room. Papa Needs to show them what customer service really looks like.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Night shift crew was fair. Needs to learn how to cut a pizza though. Had to use a scissor in order to cut it so I could eat it in my room. Papa Needs to show them what customer service really looks like.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
It's one of my favorites!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Knots, Steak, Pizza Sub, Pepperoni Supreme, Chicken Alfredo, Gyro
Wings were very small an over
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Needs to learn what no mustard please means. Will not go back an will not
Food: 1
Service: 1
FastNice and friendly employees food hit and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...