Absolutely phenomenal ice cream! The staff is extremely friendly and the sitting area was clean and well spaced out!! The music wasn't too loud and by the way did I mention the ice cream is delicious! You gotta try it, I know I'll be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parfait
Jessica Chen
Delicious Italian ice flavors with the perfect texture. Staff was friendly and helpful with getting us familiar with their menu options since it was our first time here. Love that they give you samples to try their big selection of flavors. The small size was plenty for me and were allowed 3 flavors per small cup. Honestly my daughter and I could’ve shared one together and still be full! Price was very reasonable at just over $3 per cup. We look forward to coming back for more!**bonus** they have a drive-thru!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice
Shawna B.
Ok now, a new ice cream place right up the road!! I'm beginning to think I live in the best location......but that can be dangerous for my sweet tooth. I love ice cream! The menu at Jeremiahs, seems simple, yet there are so many variations and mixes, especially with toppings and the added addition of Italian ice! You can get it layered, with any toppings, or just Italian ice or just ice cream. When I saw this place I want to sing "Jeremiah was a bullfrog" . I really need to look into why it's named Jeremiah's. I have visited Jeremiah's 3 times, 2 drive thru and once inside. I never took pictures and really wanted to see how consistent the service was. My very first visit I pulled in through the drive thru and was greeted with a very friendly smile. Service was quick and the ice cream was such an amazing treat. Tried the Grasshopper. So refreshing with the mint ice cream. On my second visit I went inside for just a small cup of vanilla ice cream. They were rather busy that night but service, again, was very friendly and quick and looking around noticed how clean the store was. My third visit, in the drive thru (pictures this time) and again was greeted with a very friendly welcome and smile, and service was quick. The mango tango was absolutely delicious and the sprinkles...... mwah....perfection. sprinkles make everything perfect. I love this place. The drive-thru is an awesome touch for a quick on the go treat. Just remember, they over-fill the cup, so if it's a very hot day, it may be best to pull aside and eat a bit before driving away. The ice cream is always delicious and today was a nice little treat on this warm, almost spring, day. Great place for a nice cold treat! Summer will be busy busy for sure! Ciao for now.
Joy Clifford
Fun atmosphere, great selection of flavors and selection of what kind of ice cream/ Italian ice combination you'd like! Large portions!! Definitely be ready to enjoy some sweets or share with a friend ?
Anny S.
I am a big fan of Italian ice. Jeremiah's Italian ice has to be one of the best by far!! Give them a try.
Abigail Peoples
Wonderful soft Italian ice and delicious gelati! Service was quick and friendly! Will be going back often! Love that there is a drive thru too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Medium Gelati
Wilbert Figueroa
Our school dropped by in a bus during a trip to get ice cream late, and they handled it extremely well. Some of the best ice crema Ive ever had. Amazing workers. Would recommend to everyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Price
Loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bronson Bryker
Love love love this place. Tried it for the very first time 3-3-24 with my pops my sister & my nephews & niece. I had the small chocolate gelati had chocolate chips in it and a small was more than enough. So so so amazingly good. Staff is awesome. Sure this place will be packed during the summers. But this will be the place to go. ????????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice, Small Italian Ice, Medium Gelati
Dallas A.
This place is unbelievably good. Seriously. I'm a big ice cream kind of guy, and Jeremiah's is as good as it gets. Choose between a variety of Italian ice flavors (pineapple, strawberry, cotton candy, and cookie butter to name a few), go with a classic, creamy custard, or get the best of both with a combination--you can either create your own or choose one of Jeremiah's signature creations. I got the animal cracker and loved every bite (it's a combo of cookie butter Italian ice, cotton candy Italian ice, vanilla custard, and sprinkles)! One of my favorite parts of Jeremiah's was the samples--I was expecting to be able to try the different Italian ice flavors, but you can try a sample of entire signature flavor combinations too! Such an awesome place!
I really enjoyed this place. I like that it's Italian ice and soft serve and there are so many options. The aesthetics are amazing and the workers were helpful when I was deciding what to get! They helped provide suggestions based off me saying I like peanut butter and chocolate. I ended up getting the Oreo one and it was delicious. I really like that they have multiple sizes too! Check it out! And make sure you download their app!
Anthony N.
It's good. It's better than I expected. It's great, even. With a wide selection of very good Italian ices and soft serve (with some dairy-free and sugar free ice options), you'll find something here to please anyone in the crew. I'm an instant fan of the horchata ice, with just the right amount of cinnamon sweetness. Even with a huge line (it was 96 cent promotion day), things flowed smoothly and the staff nailed it with service. I will be back many, many times. Good to see some new life filling out the New Garden shopping center after the loss of Feeney's.
LJ
There's a reason they have 5 solid stars. Product taste and quality is spot-on. But more amazing is the incredible level of C/S. So cheerful, helpful & personable without being smothering. It's jaw dropping. And REFRESHING. This kind is totally lost in our world today. I'm just... how do.. its... Just Wowww!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toni Wade
This spot has become one of my family’s favorite places for a sweet treat. The staff are friendly and seem happy to be there. Josie recently served us and she was so nice and helpful and even offered suggestions. The inside is very cute with a lovely mural on the wall. The Italian ice tastes great and they have so many flavors.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Meyers
Great place. Great ice cream and icies. Was very busy the day we were there.
Absolutely phenomenal ice cream! The staff is extremely friendly and the sitting area was clean and well spaced out!! The music wasn't too loud and by the way did I mention the ice cream is delicious! You gotta try it, I know I'll be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parfait
Delicious Italian ice flavors with the perfect texture. Staff was friendly and helpful with getting us familiar with their menu options since it was our first time here. Love that they give you samples to try their big selection of flavors. The small size was plenty for me and were allowed 3 flavors per small cup. Honestly my daughter and I could’ve shared one together and still be full! Price was very reasonable at just over $3 per cup. We look forward to coming back for more!**bonus** they have a drive-thru!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice
Ok now, a new ice cream place right up the road!! I'm beginning to think I live in the best location......but that can be dangerous for my sweet tooth. I love ice cream! The menu at Jeremiahs, seems simple, yet there are so many variations and mixes, especially with toppings and the added addition of Italian ice! You can get it layered, with any toppings, or just Italian ice or just ice cream. When I saw this place I want to sing "Jeremiah was a bullfrog" . I really need to look into why it's named Jeremiah's. I have visited Jeremiah's 3 times, 2 drive thru and once inside. I never took pictures and really wanted to see how consistent the service was. My very first visit I pulled in through the drive thru and was greeted with a very friendly smile. Service was quick and the ice cream was such an amazing treat. Tried the Grasshopper. So refreshing with the mint ice cream. On my second visit I went inside for just a small cup of vanilla ice cream. They were rather busy that night but service, again, was very friendly and quick and looking around noticed how clean the store was. My third visit, in the drive thru (pictures this time) and again was greeted with a very friendly welcome and smile, and service was quick. The mango tango was absolutely delicious and the sprinkles...... mwah....perfection. sprinkles make everything perfect. I love this place. The drive-thru is an awesome touch for a quick on the go treat. Just remember, they over-fill the cup, so if it's a very hot day, it may be best to pull aside and eat a bit before driving away. The ice cream is always delicious and today was a nice little treat on this warm, almost spring, day. Great place for a nice cold treat! Summer will be busy busy for sure! Ciao for now.
Fun atmosphere, great selection of flavors and selection of what kind of ice cream/ Italian ice combination you'd like! Large portions!! Definitely be ready to enjoy some sweets or share with a friend ?
I am a big fan of Italian ice. Jeremiah's Italian ice has to be one of the best by far!! Give them a try.
Wonderful soft Italian ice and delicious gelati! Service was quick and friendly! Will be going back often! Love that there is a drive thru too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Medium Gelati
Our school dropped by in a bus during a trip to get ice cream late, and they handled it extremely well. Some of the best ice crema Ive ever had. Amazing workers. Would recommend to everyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love love love this place. Tried it for the very first time 3-3-24 with my pops my sister & my nephews & niece. I had the small chocolate gelati had chocolate chips in it and a small was more than enough. So so so amazingly good. Staff is awesome. Sure this place will be packed during the summers. But this will be the place to go. ????????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice, Small Italian Ice, Medium Gelati
This place is unbelievably good. Seriously. I'm a big ice cream kind of guy, and Jeremiah's is as good as it gets. Choose between a variety of Italian ice flavors (pineapple, strawberry, cotton candy, and cookie butter to name a few), go with a classic, creamy custard, or get the best of both with a combination--you can either create your own or choose one of Jeremiah's signature creations. I got the animal cracker and loved every bite (it's a combo of cookie butter Italian ice, cotton candy Italian ice, vanilla custard, and sprinkles)! One of my favorite parts of Jeremiah's was the samples--I was expecting to be able to try the different Italian ice flavors, but you can try a sample of entire signature flavor combinations too! Such an awesome place!
Restaurantji Recommends
I really enjoyed this place. I like that it's Italian ice and soft serve and there are so many options. The aesthetics are amazing and the workers were helpful when I was deciding what to get! They helped provide suggestions based off me saying I like peanut butter and chocolate. I ended up getting the Oreo one and it was delicious. I really like that they have multiple sizes too! Check it out! And make sure you download their app!
It's good. It's better than I expected. It's great, even. With a wide selection of very good Italian ices and soft serve (with some dairy-free and sugar free ice options), you'll find something here to please anyone in the crew. I'm an instant fan of the horchata ice, with just the right amount of cinnamon sweetness. Even with a huge line (it was 96 cent promotion day), things flowed smoothly and the staff nailed it with service. I will be back many, many times. Good to see some new life filling out the New Garden shopping center after the loss of Feeney's.
There's a reason they have 5 solid stars. Product taste and quality is spot-on. But more amazing is the incredible level of C/S. So cheerful, helpful & personable without being smothering. It's jaw dropping. And REFRESHING. This kind is totally lost in our world today. I'm just... how do.. its... Just Wowww!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This spot has become one of my family’s favorite places for a sweet treat. The staff are friendly and seem happy to be there. Josie recently served us and she was so nice and helpful and even offered suggestions. The inside is very cute with a lovely mural on the wall. The Italian ice tastes great and they have so many flavors.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place. Great ice cream and icies. Was very busy the day we were there.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4