Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

They make up their prices, called to place an order just for baby flounder , Baked potato and corn. Told me $18 then $ 22 in person it’s just $12 on the menu for flounder and baked potato smh

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

The waitress was very helpful and polite
I like that the manager
Came out and helped them
But the food was not enough seasoning for me
And I love this season word up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

My wife and I had lunch there on Friday August 15, 2025. We've been there a few years ago and the food service was pretty good, but not this time. The shrimp was barely cooked and the fish had more fried batter than the fish itself. It tasted like it had been frozen for a while before being cooked. Also, the prices have almost doubled. The waitress acted like she had an attitude and was barely nice at all. We won't plan to be back here to eat anymore.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Fish platter was good. I'd visit again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Great food and staff, Love you Mr. Bill!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you want to waste your money please be my guest!!! The food is horrible and very bland. The manger (Bill) ole Olies old man looking ass don't give a damn if you like your food or not...I literally had to beg and go off on him for him to take something off my bill...I was with friends and their food was horrible too and he did not do his due diligence as a manager to take anything off their bill..the server took care of everything ...So management is horrible too..the servers are sweet as pie but bill ass needs to be fired alone with them cooks. I knew it was something when the place was empty but we had to learn the hard way. Soon as we left we all got sick. So please when you see this place go the other way!!

I got takeout shrimp. The server who helped me was nice and I have no complaint about the service but the shrimp was inedible. It was the worst tasting shrimp I've ever tried to eat. It was hard and way over cooked. It also tasted freezer burnt. I didn't even let me dog eat it. Into the garbage went the entire order.

The quality of the food served has unfortunately gone downhill.

You still receive large portions after all of these years but if the food is not edible then you just have large portions of junk.

The clams and baby shrimp were undercooked and my husband’s fries were practically raw. We had to re-cook the food just to try to salvage the meal.

First time eating here in a while and probably the last.

We haven't had Mayflower in a while I decided to stop there after with left Walmart I order Whitten fish and my wife order the trio shrimp, oysters and claws trash the fries was even under cook who the hell under cook fries we are so disappointed in the food Mayflower Ship has sunk..

Relaxing environment

Food was OK. Place looks run down. When pulling up I thought it was shut down. Weeds growing all throughout parking lot. Outside of building is in much need of paint and cleaning. I ordered via phone and was not familiar with the area. If I had seen the building beforehand, I would not have ordered. Only 2 people eating at bar and 1 behind me in take out at 630 pm.

Don't recommend! Rude workers, That asked for a tip on a takeout order. Asked for butter for my baked potato, got handed whipped spread 48% vegetable oil. Shrimp, scallops, and fish broiled had no flavor.

Great food. Service is ok. Tables were sticky.

This Mayflower used to be a family go to over the years but however the quality has diminished in a way that is indescribable. We ordered wings, calamari and mozzarella sticks. The calamari was overcooked and , the wings tasted of fish ( reflecting the grease being refused), and the mozzarella sticks had enough grease to fry chicken for Sunday dinner. We ended up complaining only to have the same issue when the remade appetizers were brought back out to us. The steak was decent but not up to par with the price. The fried shrimp tasted of grease and batter. The French fries were not fresh. The cold shrimp tasted of fish water. This is disheartening considering how tasty their food use to be. Despite the disappointing visits prior, we decided to give this location another chance. However, this visit only confirmed that they need serious help in that kitchen. The only enjoyable part of the experience was our waitress MeMe, who did an amazing job as a server. Especially since she was the ONLY waitress there.

In summary do not waste your time or your money dining here.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Good size portions, seasoned well and delicious. Waitress did very well even though it was her third day.???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Combination Fried Shrimp and Fish Dinner, Combination Fried Baby Shrimp and Fish Dinner