Michelangelo's Pizza

We came in at 7:40 to get the last of the buffet (the website and door says buffet until 8pm). The older lady Melissa at the front with short hair was extremely rude. She says it will be closing soon and we said that's fine we just wanna get the last, the buffet was practically full besides the salad bar which was fine to us. She said we can't get the buffet and we can just leave. So rude unprompted we love michaelengos been coming since we were kids but this just sucks.

Service: 1

If I could put no stars that’s exactly what I would do. First time there and excited because we saw all the good reviews listed, it was the worst food and service we've ever experienced. About 4 pizzas out at the buffet maybe 2-4 slices left on each pan, not fresh completely cold. While no staff came out to check if any fresh pizza needed to be put out, they were all just laughing gossiping in the kitchen. We had to ask the host to refill 2 of them, and they never did. We were there for over an hour and we didn’t eat but 2 slices each of only cold pizza. The pasta was hard and cold, looked like it had been there since morning. Never going there again. Definitely do not recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cant believe weve been in the area for 2 years and are just now trying this lil gem. I was wanting a fresh salad bar and def got what I wanted. We all loved the pizza and dessert pizzas. They made 2 requested pizzas for us. If you're not a pizza lover, there was plenty of pasta and soup options. Highly recommend. Super friendly. We will be back. Support local 😉

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of the few places to get green olives on our pizza around here. Great flavor in the sauce and crust. Crust is right on the border of too thin, but the taste makes up for it. We’ll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don't waste your money don't go there.

Disrespectful Ownership – Great Food, Poor Leadership

Michaelangelo’s may have great food, but unfortunately, the behavior of the owner is driving loyal customers away. Her attitude toward guests is rude and dismissive, and it’s clear she prioritizes squeezing money over delivering genuine hospitality.

If she continues to treat customers with such disrespect, it won’t matter how good the pizza is—this place will be out of business in six months. Businesses thrive on community, respect, and customer service—not arrogance.

We’ve supported this place for a long time, but enough is enough. We won’t be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

It ok . I would eat there again . Just not gonna become a regular

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

It's great. Spend your money here. Who doesn't like a pizza buffet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Live Michealangelos pizza. Gonna eat there tonight. Good buffet with courteous staff.

We walked in and ordered an X-Large pizza- the pizza was not freshly made. The pizza was bland and it was not good. So disappointing. I will never buy pizza here again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

I’ve ordered from this place regularly for the past almost a year. When I moved down here from New York, I gave up on finding “New York pizza”. This place is fantastic and would have had amazing reviews even smack in the middle of Manhattan. Thank you so much for giving me a taste of home!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti and Meatball Sub, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza

The boy on the phone at Michelangelo's pizza, Tyler, was very sweet and patient with me. He was very efficient putting down my order and my order was swiftly at my door before my episode even ended! When he showed up at my door with my order he presented it with a little dance and a smile. Pizza was great, will be ordering again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

W place

Food was good. We opted for the All You Can Eat buffet.
Staff seemed more interested in conversations among themselves than attending to establishment.
Was not busy, yet many of the tables were not cleared or cleaned from previous customers.
In need of deep cleaning and some furniture repair.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Never will We ever go back to this Place,, do yourself a favor don’t go…there food had No taste..we had eggplant parm.. my partner had chicken parmigiana…it was horrible No flavor zero Sauce..tons of mozzarella.. Ketsup has more flavor than there sauce, like the sauce wasn’t even
cooked. My husbands was so white, barely had sauce on it..
The Buffet..Everything was dried out.. There was no moist sauce covering the meatballs, or anything else for that matter .Save your money, and go else where! We left our whole meal..and walked Out..

Wheelchair accessibility: No e

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2