The New Yorker Pizza

8567 Linwood-Southmont Rd, Lexington
(336) 798-1030

Recent Reviews

Lisa Hughes

Ordered food to be delivered Super Bowl Sunday and the food was cold and the delivery took over a hour and half. Tried to contact them and they kept hanging up on me. I don’t know if they were just that busy or if this is their typical way of handling deliveries but this is unacceptable!Avoid having food delivered and go in to avoid these issues is all I can say.

Food: 2

Service: 1

Rodney Baccus

Great place for baked Spaghetti and pizza and the people are very happy to serve.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Christin Hutchins

We’ve only had delivery but both times they’ve told us it’d be over an hour and both times it was under. Their portions are HUGE! Also try their fried mushrooms. They’re the best we’ve ever had and they have amazing homemade ranch!

Food: 4

Service: 5

Hubert Bailey

Great people, food, and an overall experience.Show respect and receive it back.Remember, you only get what you ask for.Food is amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Younts

We live in the area and New Yorkers has become our go to especially when we are craving a burger or pizza. Tonight we decided to try the spaghetti with meat sauce and the pepperoni Stromboli. The spaghetti was very over cooked but the meat sauce was flavorful. My husband enjoyed his Stromboli. I will say I will stick with the burger next time, they can make some really good burgers. I will include a picture of my burger plate from a previous visit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice

John Roberts

Best pizza & wings around! The Sweet Thai Chili sauce on the wings is outstanding! All the menu is wonderful! Don’t let the gas station full you. You’ll be glad you gave it a try.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Roger Holden

Not what you'd expect in a gas station, but good pasta and pizzas to go. No complaints, and friendly service. Prices are good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jessi Leftwich

The owner of the restaurant side was very rude when they sent the wrong food as was the manager of the store area. I would not advice telliythem of any mistakes on your meal or they will be rude

Jeff Henley

Wow,was told about this place and had to check it out..I will go as far to say it was the best LARGE slice of pizza I have ever had.its in the outskirts of Lexington but its worth the drive if you love pizza.

Angela Jones

Country store with a twist New York style food. It's great love the food.

Heather A

Huge slice. Almost couldn't finish it. Delicious. 10/10 recommended.

Christa Corkins

Food is amazing. Giant pizzas, I don’t like wings, but I’ve gotten their wings for all of my wing connoisseurs and they have all hands down said their wings are the best.

Christine P.

The food is good. They have a good selection. They offer delivery service in some locations.It is a little pricey, but you are paying for the convenience of having it close by or delivered. Getting through by phone to place your order by phone can take some patience at times. When they are busy it may take awhile to get your food or have it ready for delivery.

Charley

My family used to come here when I was a kid, it was like a hidden gem every-time we went to the lake!! So happy to have found it again.

Jonathan Reina

Food was actually pretty good but I think their prices are a little high for the amount given.

Load More