Love this place and the staff! The food and service are great! The garlic rolls are the best ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Garlic Balls, Side Salad, Meatballs, 5 Topping Large Pizza Perfection, Garlic Knots, Lasagna
Christian Chapman
It is the only pizza place in town, so it seems that they know that they don't have to try very hard. I've had to wait over an hour for pizza anytime we've ordered takeout. The pizza is decent but not really noteworthy. We haven't dined in yet, but we hope to soon. The reviews of their garlic knots are strong. Mmmmm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
AHB
My nostalgia for this place is definitely biasing my review, but Papa Nick's has been here ever since I moved here. Never once had a problem with getting the takeout. The people there often do very well with attention to detail. I think the fact that they have been here so long is indicative of at least something that they are doing right. Better than a lot of pizza places when it comes to food and pricing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tami Stewart
Love the pizza except our friends asked for there's Well-done, it was not (it was very busy when we went on a Friday, they didn't want to wait any longer to return it). Our side salad was disappointing for $5, small handful of lettuce, 2 small slices of cuc and 1/2 slice of tomato (drenched in dressing). Atmosphere was great but very loud when they are busy. Garlic rolls are extremely garlicky.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nick Fischer
Just okay, could be quite good with a little more effort.Glad they have vegan pizza and that part was generally good. But the crust was basically like white bread with almost no salt and no seasoning. It is airy which is good, just really could use some more seasoning and salt.Vegetarian options: Vegan cheese and lots of veggies
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Kyle Norton
If you place a to go order plan on waiting 45 mins plus after the time they give you for it to be
Food: 2
Service: 1
Randy Smith
Ordered online for one pizza and one Stromboli. Said it would be ready in 40 minutes at 5:11 p.m. I got there 5 minutes ahead of time, let them know I was there. Time came and went, at 5:41 I went to the pickup window and said my order was supposed to be ready 30 minutes earlier, and was there a problem? The employee got the completed order from the top of some shelf. I asked how long it had been there. She said "around" 10 minutes. I saw one guy get his to go order and turned in a pager. I wasn't offered one, and the employee said "oh, they never gave you one?". She was the one I spoke to when I got there! I'd even ordered 2 pieces of pie from her also. I asked why couldn't someone have let me know, since I was standing outside ( in the heat) by the pickup window? No answer, no apology, just a stupefied expression. I really wish employers would let their staff know a simple apology goes a long way. The food is good, but the experience ruined it.Addendum: 8/20/23 Owners response of "Poor randy" should tell you all you need to know about how much Papa Nick's respects their local customers. Sounds like they don't care. Their choice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Gods Eyes
Foods great good service very friendly eat here very often would suggest too anyone who will
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls
Marissa S
On multiple trips to Papa Nicks we have gotten different items. The pizza is consistently good. However, the ravioli was highly disappointing. It tasted like the premade ravioli and canned Alfredo sauce you get at the supermarket. Definitely didn't taste made from scratch. We will continue to get pizza, but probably won't dine in anymore.
No salt or any other seasoning in pizza or dough.Bland tasteless and undercooked.Worst slice and calzone I have ever Moy from a microwave.
Victor Womack
This is a small Mountain Pizza place if that’s amazing!! It’s off the beaten path, but well worth coming.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza X Cheese
Kim Boggie
We ordered pick up. It was about 15 minutes past estimated time . The most aggravating was the Greek salad for 10.95. It had black olives, green peppers, ricotta as a very very thin layer on top of nothing but lettuce . 4 small cherry tomatoes, 4 cucumber slices. 75% of salad was lettuce. We also ordered a pizza and calzone and for 54 $ we were very disappointed. Which is too bad because we live very close and hoped for better.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
92ncca
Italian in little Mars Hill and we drive up from Asheville for the Fantastic food. Best garlic knots (compared to several other very good NC restaurants)! Friendly service. Sort-of crowded tables and often too loud in there.
Tony Harrison
Great place to eat in Mars Hill, NC. Had lunch with wife and daughter. My chicken fetticini was good but was not hot, not even warm. Still, I highly recommend it.
The food and service was
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place and the staff! The food and service are great! The garlic rolls are the best ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza and Garlic Balls, Side Salad, Meatballs, 5 Topping Large Pizza Perfection, Garlic Knots, Lasagna
It is the only pizza place in town, so it seems that they know that they don't have to try very hard. I've had to wait over an hour for pizza anytime we've ordered takeout. The pizza is decent but not really noteworthy. We haven't dined in yet, but we hope to soon. The reviews of their garlic knots are strong. Mmmmm.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
My nostalgia for this place is definitely biasing my review, but Papa Nick's has been here ever since I moved here. Never once had a problem with getting the takeout. The people there often do very well with attention to detail. I think the fact that they have been here so long is indicative of at least something that they are doing right. Better than a lot of pizza places when it comes to food and pricing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Love the pizza except our friends asked for there's Well-done, it was not (it was very busy when we went on a Friday, they didn't want to wait any longer to return it). Our side salad was disappointing for $5, small handful of lettuce, 2 small slices of cuc and 1/2 slice of tomato (drenched in dressing). Atmosphere was great but very loud when they are busy. Garlic rolls are extremely garlicky.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Just okay, could be quite good with a little more effort.Glad they have vegan pizza and that part was generally good. But the crust was basically like white bread with almost no salt and no seasoning. It is airy which is good, just really could use some more seasoning and salt.Vegetarian options: Vegan cheese and lots of veggies
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
If you place a to go order plan on waiting 45 mins plus after the time they give you for it to be
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ordered online for one pizza and one Stromboli. Said it would be ready in 40 minutes at 5:11 p.m. I got there 5 minutes ahead of time, let them know I was there. Time came and went, at 5:41 I went to the pickup window and said my order was supposed to be ready 30 minutes earlier, and was there a problem? The employee got the completed order from the top of some shelf. I asked how long it had been there. She said "around" 10 minutes. I saw one guy get his to go order and turned in a pager. I wasn't offered one, and the employee said "oh, they never gave you one?". She was the one I spoke to when I got there! I'd even ordered 2 pieces of pie from her also. I asked why couldn't someone have let me know, since I was standing outside ( in the heat) by the pickup window? No answer, no apology, just a stupefied expression. I really wish employers would let their staff know a simple apology goes a long way. The food is good, but the experience ruined it.Addendum: 8/20/23 Owners response of "Poor randy" should tell you all you need to know about how much Papa Nick's respects their local customers. Sounds like they don't care. Their choice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Foods great good service very friendly eat here very often would suggest too anyone who will
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls
On multiple trips to Papa Nicks we have gotten different items. The pizza is consistently good. However, the ravioli was highly disappointing. It tasted like the premade ravioli and canned Alfredo sauce you get at the supermarket. Definitely didn't taste made from scratch. We will continue to get pizza, but probably won't dine in anymore.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
No salt or any other seasoning in pizza or dough.Bland tasteless and undercooked.Worst slice and calzone I have ever Moy from a microwave.
This is a small Mountain Pizza place if that’s amazing!! It’s off the beaten path, but well worth coming.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza X Cheese
We ordered pick up. It was about 15 minutes past estimated time . The most aggravating was the Greek salad for 10.95. It had black olives, green peppers, ricotta as a very very thin layer on top of nothing but lettuce . 4 small cherry tomatoes, 4 cucumber slices. 75% of salad was lettuce. We also ordered a pizza and calzone and for 54 $ we were very disappointed. Which is too bad because we live very close and hoped for better.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Italian in little Mars Hill and we drive up from Asheville for the Fantastic food. Best garlic knots (compared to several other very good NC restaurants)! Friendly service. Sort-of crowded tables and often too loud in there.
Great place to eat in Mars Hill, NC. Had lunch with wife and daughter. My chicken fetticini was good but was not hot, not even warm. Still, I highly recommend it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Homemade Garlic Rolls