5250 Old Charlotte Hwy # A, Monroe
I ordered takeout today- a spaghetti with tomato sauce and since I have a dairy allergy I asked for no cheese, but when I opened it I realized it had cheese on it.. I called them and let them know. They made me new spaghetti and were so apologetic about the mistake. I really appreciate it when restaurants take responsibility and fix things. Thanks so much you guys for awesome service. The spaghetti was great as well! Also if you want a pizza with no cheese they make those too :)
Born and raised on Long island .Just moved here and I was depressed as there is no good pizza here.I passed this place last night and ordered a fresh cheese pie .I felt like I was home .This pizza is amazing ,the gravy is delicious. I cant wait to come back you have no idea how happy my family and I are knowing there is real Italian food here.
You owe my mom an apology. I had to slap her, your pizza was so good. Also, I need you to pick up the bill for the hole in the wall from when I took a bite into your canoli’s! Doesn’t get much better ??
I gave a 5 star on the pizza cuz I had it twice I’m yet to try the rest of the
Alfredo spinach pizza great BUT they still charge for chicken when I requested no chicken. So I had to pay more for the dead ingredient that makes it expensive being a vegetarian. Boo-hiss!!
Excuse: "No option on computer to deduct chicken" Lame, lame, lame!!!
The owner is super friendly. Great atmosphere. Pizza was delicious. We’re from NYC this pizza reminds us of home.
If they close at 9 they don't answer the phone after 8:01. Kids these days. Amazing food but nah.
Think we found our new favorite pizza, not easy to find good NY style down here.
Johnny tomatoes went above and beyond for my order that a food delivery platform really messed up. A huge shout out to Jen...she was awesome while we both tried to figure the mess out. No shout outs to the delivery agent who really wanted nothing to do with it, but refund 5 dollars on a 30+ order. I do still feel bad of the lost order that was made way before it should have and I hope my review helps others to choose johnny for the needs/wants of an amazing pizza experience.
Dough is good but I was not crazy about the sauce served with their rolls. The Margarita pizza was good though (different sauce)! Disappointed with the Nutella knots. The sauce tasted more like frosting than Nutella and the knots seemed microwaved as the dough stiffened up fast.
Everytime I go , its always delicious and fresh!! I was a pizza man in New York City and this is another spot that tastes exactly like home!!! Highly recommend!!
they forgot the sauce in the wings!!! pasta not even al dente way far i drive from charlotte because someone recommended but not worth it
Food so delicious and I recommend you to check out!? It’s very clean, the music is a great vibe and the customer service is awesome! Thank you Jennifer for your pleasure attitude and to the rest of the team -Thank you for great customer service! I’ll definitely be back! Sn: I ordered mozzarella sticks, garlic Parmesan wings and Stromboli ( black olives, onions and pepperoni) So delicious!! ?❤️#TeamJohnnyTomatoes❤️
I ordered a sausage onion and mushroom pizza. Got tons of rolled-up onions tons of mushroom and no sausage. I was very disappointed I was also told they had fresh garlic sauce, for the garlic knots and I asked for extra and got nothing. Paid $35 for all that. Last time Jonny Tomatoes will see me in there
5250 Old Charlotte Hwy # A, Monroe, NC 28110