Sugarloaf Island Deli & Yellowfin Pub

501 Evans St, Morehead City
(252) 222-0236

Recent Reviews

Lee Henry Henry

If you want a coastal pub/ grill feel this is it. My wife and I eat here a lot. We love that our dogs can go with us. They have covered dining, patio dining and upper deck area for awesome views. In the colder months they have brand new heaters overhead to keep you warm.Parking: It's nice if you can find street parking for free. If not then you have to pay.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: AG's Buffalo Shrimp Wrap, Club Sandwich, Crab Dip with Pita Chips, Spinach Dip, Fish Tacos, Bacon Cheeseburger, Shrimp Basket, Shrimp Tacos

Denny Clark

Tabled at 2:40 on St Patrick's Day. Waitress (KATIE) arrived for the first time 20 minutes later - without waters for the 7 person party - apologizing for the delay and asked that we not "judge" her because we had to wait so long after being seated. She took our drink orders and came back 25 minutes later with only 5 of the beverages. Took our food orders, came back 10 minutes later with the other 2 drinks.......still no water served. Twenty five minutes later food (just burgers, tacos and pizza) arrives, again with apologies from server for delay. We are local residents and will now avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Randy Mcsendy

The grouper crab cake sandwich is one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had but closing at 8 on a Saturday ? And no one answering the phone at 7. That’s disappointing.

Tanya D.

I had the fish and chips and my son had the mahi tacos! Best fish and chips I've had in a long time! Love the atmosphere too and the water view! Definitely recommend this place :)

Ryan Amaral

Came back a second time, and very happy I did. The staff was incredibly friendly, service was prompt, and the food yall...is outstanding! Plenty of options to choose from, and I look forward to trying all of em! Oh, and the views don't suck either. Enjoying a meal on the waterfront is tough to beat.Shout out to Gale (manager). Her communication and humble personality drew me back, and she really cares about the guests, and strives for perfection. Thanks for having me! I shall return ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Dunaway

We love this place! Their sandwiches are the best in town and always great service. Love the view of the water while we eat, too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Dip with Pita Chips, Spinach Dip

Arie Kachler

I was pleasantly surprised by this place. The food was really good. Real tasty and huge portions. The staff is friendly and did their best to accommodate us, as busy as they were.From all the waterfront places in Moorhead City this has been the best one I’ve tried.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert Tyndall

Jeff and Stephanie have created a unique dining experience. The food is fresh, well prepared, and delicious. The waterfront location and incredible views cap off a great meal. The Yellowfin is always one of my top choices for dining as well as a top choice to recommend to friends. It is always full of locals which speaks for itself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emlaurenzana

We were looking for a place to eat lunch outside on the water. Happily, we stumbled on this place. Lively atmosphere and a nice breeze coming off of the water. Friendly servers, good local beers on tap, and some interesting food options. I was ready for a break from fried seafood and was pleased to find several fresh options from which to choose. I had the fresh catch quinoa bowl, which came with tuna and an Asian style peanut dressing on the side. Very tasty. My husband has the softshell crab sandwich special with a side of potato salad (made with new potatoes and slightly mustardy), both of which he really liked. There was a ni

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chase Bishop

Went to get dinner with my family and ordered the $15 Chorizo Chili Cheeseburger. What was served was a burger with marina sauce and hamburger from a meatball sub! When I asked the waitress if the cooks had made a mistake, she went to ask them, returning to tell me that it was “a marina based chili”. So either the chorizo chili tastes a whole lot like a meatball sub, or the cooks lied to my waitress, and by extension, me.

Food: 1

Charles Nash

Great beer on tap. Great fish tacos. Great service. Great venue. I might come back or I might never leave.Vegetarian options: Available

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Tacos

David G.

Great food. Great staff. Ate dinner in a rainstorm so an atypical dinner but they did what they could to make it comfortable. It's all outdoors, part under a roof and part without. Great view, but very oddly they chose to block the view with 3 large screen tvs! Why would anyone decide to do this is beyond me. It's the reason I didn't give 5 stars. Get rid of this televisions in front of the seaside view! What's wrong with you?

Bull City Soles

We paddle boarded for 3 hours today and was thirsty, tired and hangry. Found the restaurant on google and was able to leave our boards on the dock, eat an amazing lunch and rest. Loved the steam shrimp, beet salad and blueberry cheesecake! We didn’t have any money on us but they took Apple wallet which was awesome!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ben Davis

I had the oyster basket and the oysters were pretty good! They gave a very generous amount. The service was okay. I think our waitress checked on this maybe two times not including coming with our checks. The atmosphere was pretty good. The only weird thing was the great view of the water was blocked by a big screen television. I personally when eating at an open-air restaurant on the water would rather see the water than a big screen television with a All-Star high school basketball game on.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

jonicross

We stopped for lunch. I had the fish and chips made from haddock. It was so good. Hubby had a grinder that was also very good. The service was also excellent. We will be back

Load More

Sugarloaf Island Deli & Yellowfin Pub

501 Evans St, Morehead City, NC 28557
(252) 222-0236