Benny Tesoro's

My kids love this place. Every time we go to Nags Head my son asks to get the pizza here. The slices are so large that it impressed my 10 year old enough that he's told all his friends about it.

Good large sized slices with a nice crisp crust

It's a by the slice or the whole 28in pizza it was really large. Me, my wife and kids 16yr 14yr 6yr old only could eat one slice and had 3 left. Which we wasn't real hungry and didn't expect the pizza to be so large. It was well worth trying.

It’s on the water next to a delicious brewery. Pizza is awesome and the biggest slice I’ve ever seen. Beautiful view!

We traveled hours to get to the obx and wanted some pizza. We picked up a local coupon book to use at Benny Tesoro’s. As we placed our order the young girl said the coupon was expired. It was only a couple weeks expired and I have never had a place not honor an expired coupon. We ended paying almost $30 for just 3 slices. If the coupon books all throughout the area are outdated, we feel that the business should still honor the coupon. I’ve been in the food industry for a very long time and I’ve never thought twice about not honoring an expired coupon. I don’t believe we will be going back to this location.

Gotta love the supervise slices of pizza. Each family member orders what he or she wants on their slice. The water side deck views are phenomenal!

We ordered online and decided to do delivery instead of pick up. Well Door Dash sucks and never picked up the order. A wonderful young man called 30min AFTER the store had closed and asked if we were picking up. I said it was supposed to be delivery but he said they never picked it up. He said he'd call Door Dash and try and figure it out. About 30mins later a car pulls up and asks for me by name. It was the guy from the store. He decided to drive it out to us himself. He absolutely refused to take our tip and was just the nicest guy! Hats off Benny's! They are awesome! And fantastic pizza too!

The best pizza by far. Wish there was one near Wilmington or Goldsboro. Will definitely be returning with a LARGER appetite. The 28inch pizza was HUGE 😂😂😋😋😋

My sister picked up this pizza on our first night. Can’t speak to the restaurant itself. But the pizza was mid at best. Sauce flavor was good, and cheese was decent enough quality. The dough however, was barely risen. It was super dense and virtually no air bubbles in the crust, almost like a squished slice of white bread. Also, don’t advertise a 28 inch pizza if you’re putting like a 18” of toppings on it. Feels like a poor value for the cost. Was debating doing their pizza challenge, but after tasting a slice the first night, no way. I might give them another chance. Maybe it was a staff issue. That’s the reason I’m sticking with three stars. If it is this awful the next time, I’ll have to re-rank down to a 1. At this point I’d probably say you should avoid this spot… even for the novelty.

The pizza is good but the views are incredible

Got pizza a few times and it was good. Tonight something was off. Got slices instead of whole pie.

Largest pizza slices ever!

This was the first visit to this particular pizza place. The slices are very large and of a good taste. I will admit, my tastebuds were a bit thrown off at first with red sauce underlayment on a buffalo chicken pizza, but it was still an overall good pizza slice.

My son enjoyed his slice of pepperoni as well. We would visit the place again.

Pizza slices are massive and delicious! Will definitely make this place a go to when visiting the OBX!

I had an exemplary experience in the place. I ordered 2 pizzas for us while on vacation. It was delicious and it was hot and fresh. The staff there made me feel welcome, and I enjoyed every bit of the experience