Cookies and Cream

106 E Finch St, Nags Head
(252) 715-5199

Recent Reviews

Florian Teinfalt

Really wonderful place with amazing service. Ice cream, shakes and COOKIES are amazing. When you visit, you don't feel like a customer, you feel like family. It's on our OBX "must do" list.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Butler

Unique and delicious ice cream flavors abound in this local creamery. Most delightful is the oversized, warm, plump cookies that sit atop their generous sundaes! I highly recommend the cookie sundae....a tantalizing mixture of cold, creamy ice cream and big, fresh-baked cookie.

Jim Butler

Unique and delicious ice cream flavors abound in this local creamery. Most delightful is the oversized, warm, plump cookies that sit atop their generous sundaes! I highly recommend the cookie sundae....a tantalizing mixture of cold, creamy ice cream and big, fresh-baked cookie.

Nicole Topolski

Most amazing cookies! We had the peanut butter, lemon cooler and white chocolate macadamia nut, and a chocolate milk to wash them all down. Absolutely delicious and well worth the $11!

Christina Chenoweth

Cute little ice cream shop! They offer cookies, milkshakes, and more! It's definitely unique with their menu offerings!

Uhmanduh W

The BEST ice cream in OBX...seriously. Almost the best ice cream I've ever had. Super friendly staff, and it smells amazing!

Zachary Richards

Any place you can get cookies AND ice cream together is a winner in my book. Grab a half dozen or dozen cookies to go. You’ll regret it later if you don’t! My favorites were the Lemon Cooler and Chocolate Chip.

Shawn Gimpel

Awesome cookies and milkshakes. We go almost every time we visit and we are down at least once a month

Anna Gimpel

Amazing every time. Fresh cookies and really delicious fresh homemade ice cream. Friendly atmosphere.

Becky Edwards

Such a cute little place! The ice cream & cookies are delicious!

Denise Bryan

The place is very clean and smells amazing of course. Staff was very friendly and the cookies were AMAZING!!! Seriously the best I've ever had. They are worth the money trust me. I will definitely be back!

K W

What a wonderful experience. Very clean and cute establishment. The clerk greeted us warmly as we entered, asked if we'd been there before, and proceeded to explain the menu upon learning we hadn't. Caroluna crunch was new to us, so she explained it, scooped us some cones, and carried a pleasant conversation with us while fulfilling the orders. The ice cream was delicious, and the waffle cones were very good. The kids loved it. We will probably be back before the trip is out, and I will definitely recommend to anyone travelling to Nags Head. Well done!

Kathy Harris

Cookies are scrumptious. The royale cookie was out of this world. I really like that some of the sales help the church. I will definitely go back when I'm in the OBX.

Robyn S.

Love loved this ice cream shop! My husband loves cookies and I'm more of an ice cream fan... This was perfect! The cookie sundae is the absolute best choice- the warm cookie plus the ice cream and toppings was the best treat after a beach day! The shop is clean and neat, we will be back!

Asha Rankin

The cookies were fresh-baked and delicious and the ice cream was good too! I liked the pomegranate raspberry flavor.

Load More