Papa Johns Pizza

2725l Northwest Blvd L, Newton
(828) 464-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kiley Simpson

Food was wonderful per usual. I however do have an issue with the fact that EVERY employee had ear buds in their ears. So after saying my name to the lady upfront, she said it shouldn't be too long. Sat for 15 plus minutes waiting. Not once did she ask if I had placed the order or anything to that extent. After waiting the allotted time period, she asked for the name of the order & misheard the name. Yelling a completely different name for the order. Order was not found. Yes this is partially my fault for not placing the order, but the upfront staff needs to not be using any headphones. Therefore I am VERY dissatisfied with the way your employees do things around the store. This NEEDS TO BE FIXED ASAP!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Jamie Ross

Very good pizza my once every other week cheat day.

Rick Reid

They only have carry out or delivery hear. Still, their quality & price is good.
Get on the email list to get a large 1 tipping pizza for cheep.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shawn V

The people here are very friendly, the service is fast for a pizza place, and they always seem like they're having a good time. Best Papa John's I've ever been to. Will definitely be going back again, and again lol

Tariah Roberson

ABSOLUTELY disgusting and horrid I ordered pizza for my family 1/8/2025 and this is what I received I called back to talk to the general manager CHRIS because we did not want the pizza he said they would remake the entire order and we never received the second order I feel like he put it in the system that the problem was rectified so that I wouldn’t be able to get a refund I’m very disappointed that we had to throw the first order away and my family had to be hungry because my order wasn’t replaced with 3 papadias and 2 medium pizzas it was dry COLD and OVERCOOKED VERY DISGUSTING VERY RUDE AND I WILL NOT BE ORDERING FROM THIS LOCATION AGAIN

Chris Tackleberry

They sub out their deliveries to DoorDash.
If there’s any problem with your order, it’s a huge pain to get it fixed.

And you have to text with the driver to tell them where to leave the pizza instead of just leaving a note in the app.

Stephanie Jones

I adore Papa John's!!

Chris Shope

Use the app to order
Always have great deals there. Food is always top-notch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Extra Large New York Style Pizza, Shaqaroni, Pizzas Wings

Racheal Hilton

Pizza was cold my drink was b very hot and the person delivered it claimed they didn't have no change so there for got a 10.00 tip wth never again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jadea Sigmon

Do not order from this location. Your pizza will be "delivered" by door dash even though you didn't place the order with door dash. Through the pappa johns app the pizza will say "delivered" however there's no pizza to be found. Whenever you call and ask about what's going on they don't even care. Save yourself the trouble and don't even order with them.

Hana Pichalsky

Me and my roommate got pizza for dinner. Her pizza wasn’t cut and neither was mine. This is absolutely ridiculous. I don’t know if the workers are getting lazy but the pizzas are supposed to be cut. It looks like it’s cut but it’s not.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Rob Postlethwait

I'm a truck driver and showed up at 9:45 and they refused to serve me cause I'm a walk in and they close at 11 and said I had to order online, I'm sleeping in my truck and still can't get pizza. Won't be coming to this place ever again

chris

Manager is always cussing his employees and even with customers and kids in the store. Food is decent but this manager needs to be fired. If I worked for him I wouldn't last a day...I'd quit or he'd get a nice beat down.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Kimberly “Mommy or Wifey” Skarzynski

They're very polite and they have been very respectful to me especially when i go in there for my dash deliveries. I appreciate them and they're amazing food and customer service skills. Thanks so much guys!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

anna taylor

Corporate needs to check the manager of this store. He treats his employees terribly and yelled at them with customers in the store. That’s not how you make customers want to come back. I don’t care how stressed you are, you don’t treat people like that!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

Loading...