Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

Great experience! People were very friendly and the cookies were delicious! Will be returning!

The ice cream and cookies were delicious! We got the cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie and the strawberry ice cream with confetti cookie. They were both delicious. Will definitely be coming back!

Cookies are good but ice cream is not. Some of the flavors we got tasted too artificial. Ice cream cookie sandwich is over priced and melted quite quickly. Would come back for cookies only and add my own favorite ice-cream at home to make a cookie sandwich!

Absolutely the best ice cream cookies ever. Basically a meal in it's self! 😍

Just okay cookies but the ice cream was not good

We came just because the name of this place. The cookies are soft and delicious and so is the ice cream. I got 2 scoops in the cup and couldn't finish. Highly recommend and will be going back

I absolutely loved the service however I expected the cookies to be softer and more chewy! If they are meant to be harder to work along side ice cream I completely understand, I just didn’t expect what I got! All around very clean and well put together just not the place for me!

I got the chocolate chip and the double chocolate chip cookie. I thought tollhouse cookies taste better than these cookies

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

The October Special cookie was delicious!- Along with everything else we got!

Stopped in for a late night snack! Had the build your own ice cream sandwich. Chose the peanut butter cookie and coffee ice cream. Cookie was super fresh and perfectly baked. The ice cream was amazin

Oh, wow! I cannot contain my excitement! I feel like I'm on cloud nine after indulging in that heavenly combination of cookie dough, soda float, and the delightful duo. It was an absolute delight! Even though I have to be careful with sweets due to my condition, I just couldn't resist. I highly suggest checking out this place; it's truly worth it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oh, wow! I cannot contain my excitement! I feel like I'm on cloud nine after indulging in that heavenly combination of cookie dough, soda float, and the delightful duo. It was an absolute delight! Even though I have to be careful with sweets due to my condition, I just couldn't resist. I highly suggest checking out this place; it's truly worth it!

Ice Cream was great. Kids enjoyed their scoops. I went for the ice cream sandwich with their in house cookies and the cookie and ice cream combo was on point.

Found this place on Google, didn't realize it was inside a food hall. Food hall was neat and we ended up getting a sides of empanadas from one place and spring rolls from another to go with our ice cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich

Cute food hall. Cookies are good but nothing super special.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Website and Google listing says they open at 10am Saturday. But they’re not. ??‍♂️