Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

500 E Davie St, Raleigh
(919) 909-6965

Recent Reviews

Juan Rivera

Delicious, fresh taste. Cookies come soft, warm, and buttery. Cookie dough is delicious. Easy to get addicted!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Assorted Half Dozen, Edible Cookie Dough Large

eric hernandez

Sophia was amazing. Cookies are sooooo good especially with a milkshake.Definitely coming

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miguel Salinas

Sunday, 3/3, 2:30pm….worst service ever. Girl behind the counter had a horrible attitude. Her whole approach was off putting. We would’ve left had we not been with our kid. We wanted to order a milkshake, her response: “yea no we’re not making milkshakes right now”. Kind of believe she just didn’t want to make one. Then when we ordered cookies she proceeded to grab them toss them in the container and basically throw them across the counter. And still has the audacity to show me the screen asking for tips. Oh but her friends show up and her whole demeanor changes. Your employees are a reflection of you and your business. Choose wisely.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Quintin Callahan

Whoever you had working the night of Tuesday February 27th had probably the worst attitude I have ever encountered in the service industry.when we arrived at about 8:15 p.m. she was nowhere to be found, thinking she was probably in the back as the place didn't close till 9:00 p.m., we began looking at the menu. she comes from the back a few minutes later and rips a note off the front of the ice cream case glass that we hadn't noticed.Her body language was very clear that she was not happy that we were there, She did not address when she came from the bank . She had airpods in her ears and she began cleaning the counters. We asked her what she recommends multiple times with no response. She didn't make any suggestions to my friend when asked what she likes and just scoffs at the idea.So at this point I had every intention on leaving but whatever I ordered my ice cream sandwich she slaps it together and then proceeds to throw it on the counter next to the register a couple feet away.with all that said, the cookies and the ice cream were pretty good. I had the peanut butter and butter pecan respectively.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich

Parth Patel

Solid cookies but nothing

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Aresa Hairston

Cookies are awesome especially the confetti

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich

J R.

It was my first time trying Captiain Cookieabd Briii was a big help and super cool definitely will be back!

Karen Swanson

Delicious, homemade cookies. Not ridiculously big. Highly recommend!

Kristen Jones

We have come twice in the last two weeks and each time we were turned away due to the staff being on break. Each time with a thirty minute wait which is outrageous for someone to wait for cookies and ice cream. We have come in the evening and afternoon.

Wes Green

This place is amazing! Great desserts and great service! Derrick Little was awesome! 10/10 recommend!

christine hamby

Delicious customized shakes and fresh baked cookies!

Warren Ginn

These folks were so helpful with our gathering last week. Everyone loved these ice cream sandies! My fave is the double chocolate cookies with coffee ice cream. Yum! Thanks so much!

Joseph Finnegan

Great cookies. Great ice cream. Might even be worth the price of potentially getting jumped down the street for the color of your skin!

Jaimi Grether

Highly recommend! The employee was working by themselves, but was so patient with the flow of customer.I especially appreciated their attention to hand hygiene! Great ice cream!

Jessica Cromar

The ice cream cookie sandwiches are huge and very affordable. Awesome flavor combinations!! This was an awesome treat at the end of a long day of walking.

Load More

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

500 E Davie St, Raleigh, NC 27601
(919) 909-6965