I ordered a slice of the supreme and a slice of tiramisu cake. As a foodie, the slice itself was not bad it just wasn't great. Pros - SLICES! Saves money from ordering a whole pie. Pizza had pretty good flavor and lots of toppings and the slices are pretty big. Cons: Pizza was a bit dry. Needed more sauce and I wound up feeling a little nauseous later. I am always concerned when food is left out for hours as it is here because most of the pies for slices are already made and just reheated. There's a greater chance of contamination. However I know this a a common practice. Service was good. The place looked clean and the bathroom was clean. Overall I may return to give it another try. Price was comparable to others pizza by the slice places. The tiramisu cake was delicious.
Britt J.
We've frequent this place since 2016 and they've remain consistent. If you've ever been to NY- it'll remind you of the dollar slice. The grease offers an authentic NYC pizza.
Dulce Knight
I had the white sauce Pizza, cheese was okay but pizza was too greasy and the dough Didn't have the NYC bite that I was hoping for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Monica Hodge
Excellent thin crust pizza, and extraordinary customer service! Accidentally ordered (online) to the Hillsborough St location, meaning to order at the Brier Creek... The guys were so kind and made the order for me on the fly!Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian options, gluten-free options, pork-free optionsParking: Parking located around the back side, near the Chili'sKid-friendliness: Very kid friendly! Multiple high chairs available
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Slice of Pizza
Molly L.
Sensational. This was a sleeper hit. Unexpectedly good pizza by the slice. Crunch, flavor, price, salt ratio -- had to get another slice.
Marc P.
Great pizza for a former New Yorker. Good size slices and they serve wine! Eat in or take out!
J'Narias C.
The food was on point. Service was excellent. Definitely coming back for more of the Original NY Stromboli!
Jason& Deangela
Amazing flavor.. must try... and we are pizza snobs....great variety as well...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer J.
I recently developed an allergy to pork, and it's been horrible adjusting to a life without some of my favorite food staples. But that's what makes me love this pizzeria even more! I went to NC State for college, so I am familiar with the quality of these giant slices of pizza that is bigger than your face. It was a quick lunch/dinner for me when I was low on time rushing in between classes back then, but now it is a familiar place that offers me pizza with ALL BEEF PEPPERONI and recently I saw a sign inside that all of their meat toppings are 100% pork free. I CAN FINALLY EAT MEAT LOVERS PIZZA AGAIN! In addition to their pepperoni pizza I also love their bbq chicken pizza, and my husband loves their gigantic calzones as well (think 2-3x the size of a regular calzone size). I've had their ziti, which was good but I still think their pizza quality is better than their pastas. The location itself is a super casual place, so I don't expect any sort of 5 star service. It's a casual drop in place, and most times I prefer to order pick up. Whenever my husband and I have a busy week, we prefer to order a whole pie to get them fresh out the oven as some ready made slices that are ready-made are still good but not as fresh as a whole pie. Overall, I am a fan and will continue to order pizza from here!
Jerone P
I only rate them a two due to their steak and cheese subs, which was not good at all. Though steak and its seasoning was blah. They may have really good pizza, but because of my cheese steak experience, I don't want to risk it.
Five stars thanks to Devin at the Brier Creek location! He took the time to read out the ingredients of the gluten-free pizza due to many family allergies ! We could NOT get the Knightdale location to do the same thing-although we called back 3 days in a row! I see many good reviews of the Brier Creek location! tTme for a raise for Devin and the crew there! ? Thanks guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Kitts
Great pizza in a hospitable and inviting atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
André Cleofe
No line coming in, and the staff was very
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia Adams
Update...... I do not have the wrong locationand it wasn't just 1 day. I dined in with my daughter so you'd have no idea of my order. Don't make up excuses.I've been here twice and both times it was just awful. Pizza is just greasy beyond words. I went through so many napkins trying to soak it up. The soda machine, both times had little carbonation. I got a salad and it was literally just greens and red wine vinegar. When I asked if there was more items to add to the salad the girl behind the counter rolled her eyes. The place smelled like sewer and everything was dusty. I thought the first time was a fluke but it wasn't. Just gross
I ordered a slice of the supreme and a slice of tiramisu cake. As a foodie, the slice itself was not bad it just wasn't great. Pros - SLICES! Saves money from ordering a whole pie. Pizza had pretty good flavor and lots of toppings and the slices are pretty big. Cons: Pizza was a bit dry. Needed more sauce and I wound up feeling a little nauseous later. I am always concerned when food is left out for hours as it is here because most of the pies for slices are already made and just reheated. There's a greater chance of contamination. However I know this a a common practice. Service was good. The place looked clean and the bathroom was clean. Overall I may return to give it another try. Price was comparable to others pizza by the slice places. The tiramisu cake was delicious.
We've frequent this place since 2016 and they've remain consistent. If you've ever been to NY- it'll remind you of the dollar slice. The grease offers an authentic NYC pizza.
I had the white sauce Pizza, cheese was okay but pizza was too greasy and the dough Didn't have the NYC bite that I was hoping for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Excellent thin crust pizza, and extraordinary customer service! Accidentally ordered (online) to the Hillsborough St location, meaning to order at the Brier Creek... The guys were so kind and made the order for me on the fly!Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian options, gluten-free options, pork-free optionsParking: Parking located around the back side, near the Chili'sKid-friendliness: Very kid friendly! Multiple high chairs available
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: House Salad, Slice of Pizza
Sensational. This was a sleeper hit. Unexpectedly good pizza by the slice. Crunch, flavor, price, salt ratio -- had to get another slice.
Great pizza for a former New Yorker. Good size slices and they serve wine! Eat in or take out!
The food was on point. Service was excellent. Definitely coming back for more of the Original NY Stromboli!
Amazing flavor.. must try... and we are pizza snobs....great variety as well...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently developed an allergy to pork, and it's been horrible adjusting to a life without some of my favorite food staples. But that's what makes me love this pizzeria even more! I went to NC State for college, so I am familiar with the quality of these giant slices of pizza that is bigger than your face. It was a quick lunch/dinner for me when I was low on time rushing in between classes back then, but now it is a familiar place that offers me pizza with ALL BEEF PEPPERONI and recently I saw a sign inside that all of their meat toppings are 100% pork free. I CAN FINALLY EAT MEAT LOVERS PIZZA AGAIN! In addition to their pepperoni pizza I also love their bbq chicken pizza, and my husband loves their gigantic calzones as well (think 2-3x the size of a regular calzone size). I've had their ziti, which was good but I still think their pizza quality is better than their pastas. The location itself is a super casual place, so I don't expect any sort of 5 star service. It's a casual drop in place, and most times I prefer to order pick up. Whenever my husband and I have a busy week, we prefer to order a whole pie to get them fresh out the oven as some ready made slices that are ready-made are still good but not as fresh as a whole pie. Overall, I am a fan and will continue to order pizza from here!
I only rate them a two due to their steak and cheese subs, which was not good at all. Though steak and its seasoning was blah. They may have really good pizza, but because of my cheese steak experience, I don't want to risk it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Five stars thanks to Devin at the Brier Creek location! He took the time to read out the ingredients of the gluten-free pizza due to many family allergies ! We could NOT get the Knightdale location to do the same thing-although we called back 3 days in a row! I see many good reviews of the Brier Creek location! tTme for a raise for Devin and the crew there! ? Thanks guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza in a hospitable and inviting atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
No line coming in, and the staff was very
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Update...... I do not have the wrong locationand it wasn't just 1 day. I dined in with my daughter so you'd have no idea of my order. Don't make up excuses.I've been here twice and both times it was just awful. Pizza is just greasy beyond words. I went through so many napkins trying to soak it up. The soda machine, both times had little carbonation. I got a salad and it was literally just greens and red wine vinegar. When I asked if there was more items to add to the salad the girl behind the counter rolled her eyes. The place smelled like sewer and everything was dusty. I thought the first time was a fluke but it wasn't. Just gross
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good Ny pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3