Sebby's has Excellent food and is a delightful place to eat! The service is Fantastic and the cooks are Amazing! Tonight we ate pizza. My husband got pepperoni with crumbled sausage and I got the Caprese; both were Delicious! ? If you're near Southport / Oak Island NC be sure to eat here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TJ MC
DO NOT order online. EVERY time I have done so, the pizza took another half hour AFTER i received a text it was ready. It seems so screwed ip that they take the payment, but don't make the pie until you get there, wait & ask why its not done.
Food: 4
Service: 1
John R. Monroe
Top 3 pizza shops in
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
Kevin Wagster
Ordered wings on doordash. Excellent flavor and meaty. A little more breaded and soft than I usually like. Put them in the toaster oven for a bit to get them more crispy for my liking and they were spot on. Will definitely order them again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Meg Brady
My husband and I went on a date night to grab a vegan pizza (being I'm vegan) and we ordered the Kimberly pizza. Well, to start with they ran out of vegan cheese, but the positive thing was they did call us to let us know that, so we agreed to have them fold our pizza like a Stromboli. Then halfway through my eating, a huge chunk of sausage rolled out of my food. (Thank goodness there was no cheese bc it rolled out) I called the lady over and asked her what it was and she said sausage. Never got offered a refund for the pizza even though it made me upset and cry, but my husband got offered a complimentary beer. In my opinion, we will never be back because this is honestly careless and I think people need to pay more attention.
fabiana santucci
Great Sicilian style pizza. Best we have had in the area. The sauce is really good, not strong and bitter like most chain restaurants. Growing up in a Italian family and being Italian, I can recommend this pizza. We ordered the Sicilian (grandma) and added onions. Staff is friendly and the place looks quaint and nice. We did carry out. Would recommend.
Awesome service and always customer friendly and awesome doordash service with dashes working for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Irene B.
We tried Sebbys pizza and we're in heaven. The Margarita pizza is the best I have ever had. They have great garlic knots and you cannot beat their salads. We generally go about 5:00 and the place never gets crowded. They have one waitress who is an angel. She is so pleasant and efficient and has been there whenever we have gone. Anyone wanting good pizza has got to try this place.
This is a busy place, with good reason! Parking is heinous at best. I ended up parking next door and walked over. This was less than ideal, but there literally were two additional cars trying to park in the same tiny lot. We got two thin crust pizzas. The toppings on one were so sparse that it was a challenge to find all the ingredients. This was pretty annoying considering the price we paid per topping, I expect more than five black olive slices on the pizza! I might as well have ordered a plain cheese pizza. Seriously disappointed. The other pizza was much better, with a decent amount of toppings. Acceptable. But certainly not generous. Pizza was good, very good even. Sauce was yummy, crust was great. Both were cooked to perfection. I'll try Sebby's once more to see if they figure out how to add toppings fairly so I don't feel like I got ripped off. There's a lot of competition in the area, they aren't the only game in town. Come on Sebby's, don't let me down!
Pippi G.
Wanted to try something new and ordered for pickup. It did not disappoint. Looking forward to having again when company comes to visit and trying other dishes. It really is a hidden gem.
Jackie S.
We are always worried about trying new pizza places coming from NY to the south. We were pleasantly surprised with Sebbys pizza! We got the Sicilian pie and also ordered their honey bbq wings. Definitely our new go to pizza spot.
Pete M.
Every restaurant has bad days, but it's about how the people that work there handle it that matters. Today (Dec 31st), I ordered a Cheesteak Sub via DoorDash. When I received the order, the sandwich had almost no meat in it. It was basically just bread with a small amount of steak and cheese. Now, I have ordered from Sebby's many times, so I thought I would give them a call, not to complain but to let them know. I wanted nothing in return.The woman that answered simply did not seem to care. I told her what happened and she did not say she was sorry, just that 'she would let them know'...whatever that means. She went on to say that everything is portion controlled so it's unlikely there was an issue. I then told her that I have ordered before and this has never happened.Bottom Line: I want to support local businesses, but it's not just about having good food. It's also about the service you get, especially when things don't go right. Hopefully they can do better next time.
Sam
I ordered a margarita pizza. It was not good at all the basil was cooked on it and nasty. You should know the basil goes on after . I took it home and ended up not eating it. But our garlic knots were great. Salad great. But who ever was cooking just it wasn't good. I heard so many good things that maybe I was expecting great. We ended up paying 100 for 3 small pizza and drinks garlic knots and a salad. Was kinda surprised at the price. But would pay happily if the food was good. Great waitress. She was amazing but the food was subpar
Sebby's has Excellent food and is a delightful place to eat! The service is Fantastic and the cooks are Amazing! Tonight we ate pizza. My husband got pepperoni with crumbled sausage and I got the Caprese; both were Delicious! ? If you're near Southport / Oak Island NC be sure to eat here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
DO NOT order online. EVERY time I have done so, the pizza took another half hour AFTER i received a text it was ready. It seems so screwed ip that they take the payment, but don't make the pie until you get there, wait & ask why its not done.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Top 3 pizza shops in
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza
Ordered wings on doordash. Excellent flavor and meaty. A little more breaded and soft than I usually like. Put them in the toaster oven for a bit to get them more crispy for my liking and they were spot on. Will definitely order them again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
My husband and I went on a date night to grab a vegan pizza (being I'm vegan) and we ordered the Kimberly pizza. Well, to start with they ran out of vegan cheese, but the positive thing was they did call us to let us know that, so we agreed to have them fold our pizza like a Stromboli. Then halfway through my eating, a huge chunk of sausage rolled out of my food. (Thank goodness there was no cheese bc it rolled out) I called the lady over and asked her what it was and she said sausage. Never got offered a refund for the pizza even though it made me upset and cry, but my husband got offered a complimentary beer. In my opinion, we will never be back because this is honestly careless and I think people need to pay more attention.
Great Sicilian style pizza. Best we have had in the area. The sauce is really good, not strong and bitter like most chain restaurants. Growing up in a Italian family and being Italian, I can recommend this pizza. We ordered the Sicilian (grandma) and added onions. Staff is friendly and the place looks quaint and nice. We did carry out. Would recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza Square Focaccia Style Pizza
My first time visiting and I was not disappointed. Friends had already recommended it, and they were right. Very good quality food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Garlic Knots
My favorite pizza in the Southport
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza, White Pizza
Awesome service and always customer friendly and awesome doordash service with dashes working for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We tried Sebbys pizza and we're in heaven. The Margarita pizza is the best I have ever had. They have great garlic knots and you cannot beat their salads. We generally go about 5:00 and the place never gets crowded. They have one waitress who is an angel. She is so pleasant and efficient and has been there whenever we have gone. Anyone wanting good pizza has got to try this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a busy place, with good reason! Parking is heinous at best. I ended up parking next door and walked over. This was less than ideal, but there literally were two additional cars trying to park in the same tiny lot. We got two thin crust pizzas. The toppings on one were so sparse that it was a challenge to find all the ingredients. This was pretty annoying considering the price we paid per topping, I expect more than five black olive slices on the pizza! I might as well have ordered a plain cheese pizza. Seriously disappointed. The other pizza was much better, with a decent amount of toppings. Acceptable. But certainly not generous. Pizza was good, very good even. Sauce was yummy, crust was great. Both were cooked to perfection. I'll try Sebby's once more to see if they figure out how to add toppings fairly so I don't feel like I got ripped off. There's a lot of competition in the area, they aren't the only game in town. Come on Sebby's, don't let me down!
Wanted to try something new and ordered for pickup. It did not disappoint. Looking forward to having again when company comes to visit and trying other dishes. It really is a hidden gem.
We are always worried about trying new pizza places coming from NY to the south. We were pleasantly surprised with Sebbys pizza! We got the Sicilian pie and also ordered their honey bbq wings. Definitely our new go to pizza spot.
Every restaurant has bad days, but it's about how the people that work there handle it that matters. Today (Dec 31st), I ordered a Cheesteak Sub via DoorDash. When I received the order, the sandwich had almost no meat in it. It was basically just bread with a small amount of steak and cheese. Now, I have ordered from Sebby's many times, so I thought I would give them a call, not to complain but to let them know. I wanted nothing in return.The woman that answered simply did not seem to care. I told her what happened and she did not say she was sorry, just that 'she would let them know'...whatever that means. She went on to say that everything is portion controlled so it's unlikely there was an issue. I then told her that I have ordered before and this has never happened.Bottom Line: I want to support local businesses, but it's not just about having good food. It's also about the service you get, especially when things don't go right. Hopefully they can do better next time.
I ordered a margarita pizza. It was not good at all the basil was cooked on it and nasty. You should know the basil goes on after . I took it home and ended up not eating it. But our garlic knots were great. Salad great. But who ever was cooking just it wasn't good. I heard so many good things that maybe I was expecting great. We ended up paying 100 for 3 small pizza and drinks garlic knots and a salad. Was kinda surprised at the price. But would pay happily if the food was good. Great waitress. She was amazing but the food was subpar
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5